finishing
Kernie Gilliam
I am building a red cedar dining table and this is my first big project. Anyone have a plan for finishing? Should I go with varnish, oil, ??????
I want semi gloss or satin I think
any help would be appreciated
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
finishing
Kernie Gilliam
I am building a red cedar dining table and this is my first big project. Anyone have a plan for finishing? Should I go with varnish, oil, ??????
I want semi gloss or satin I think
any help would be appreciated
Re: finishing
Dale Lenz
IMO, oil on ERC will "muddy" the picture, I'd want as clear of a finish as I could, I would use lacquer, myself, maybe varnish second. BTW, ERC would not be my choice of wood species for a dinning room table, due to ERC is pretty soft and will ding easily.
Re: finishing
Barry Irby
Not sure, but you should practice on a scrap. I seem to remember ERC will keep some varnishes from drying properly. Its always a good idea to do a practice piece.
Red Cedar
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
Needs a tie/sealer coat, usually a coat of 2 lb. cut dewaxed shellac.
Instead of using satin product. Spray full gloss then kill the sheen with wool. Satin and other "flattened" coatings will tend to kill your grain.
As mentioned, this is very soft wood. No coating will make it more durable. Only way to do that is put a glass top over it. Absent that, pick a finish that's easy to repair, even after the passage of time. That's a recipe for solvent lacquer which will allow you to spot repair without redoing the entire surface.
BTW, you'll want to keep your table out of strong or direct sunlight; you won't like the color change very much.
Re: Red Cedar
George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
I agree with Mark.
When I finished SWMBO's cedar chest, I applied dewaxed shellac initially, then top coated with satin poly since we didn't want too much sheen. The amber cast of the poly helped blend cedar sap wood with the curly maple top and trim and resulted in a striking peice of furniture.
For a table, cedar is very soft wood. I think a piece of glass to cover its surface should serve you well despite the cost.
George
Re: finishing
Kernie Gilliam
Thanks to all, I do not want to sound ignorant but I am just beginning. What is 2 lb cut shellac, what does cut mean?
Relax
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
This forum is where we learn. To do that efficiently, ask questions 
"2 Lb cut" refers to the concentration and amount of shellac dissolved in a given amount of alcohol. The reference is to 1 gallon of alcohol, so the term refers to a solution which would have 2 pounds of dry shellac dissolved in that gallon. Of course it's rare to mix a full gallon, thus to get an identical solution, you might put 1/2 pound of dry flakes in a quart or 4 oz in a pint of alk. The more shellac is added, the heavier the solution, and the more resin will be deposited on the surface when the alcohol evaporates. A "wash" or "spit" coat may be done with a very dilute solution of less that 1 pound cut, and solutions of more than 3 lb cut are rarely used because they are hard to apply evenly.
I strongly recommend that you look up some of the excellent books on wood finishing. Jeff Jewitt, Michael Dresdner, and Bob Flexner are all recognized experts with a number of books to their credit.
There is also free information
Gary Smyth
on the web concerning shellac. You will not only be able to read about cuts of shellac, and their application but also the various types of shellac and the advantages and disadvantages of the shades they impart. If you can't get what you need online then by all means get to the books. I would also suggest that you look into dyes if you want to manipulate the color of the cedar. They will allow the grain of the wood to show. Finally, I consider Cedar an outdoor dining table wood. Before you build your table, take a piece of cedar and drop a piece of your dining room weight silverware or the edge of a (not essential) dish on it from 6" or so. Check to see if you can live with the result. You might wish to consider alternative woods for a indoor more formal setting.
more advice
Bill Tindall
What ever you decide, evaluate the finish and your application on a test piece.
A dining room that smells like a cedar chest does not sound appealing. Hence, you may want to consider a finish that locks in the smell.
Good point
Howard Acheson
Finishing eastern red cedar (aromatic cedar) with an oil based finish can be problematic. The oils that emit the aroma will prevent an oil based finish from curing properly.
Use a lacquer or a waterborne finish. You could also apply a barrier coat of a dewaxed shellac and then apply your oil based finish.
Re: Relax
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
The above post is correct - also 2 pound shellac can be purchased at most borgs or malls as Zinser seal coat. This is a "clear" de-waxed shellac. Zinser also sells a 2 pound cut of "Amber" shellac which does not have the wax removed - this is normally used as a finish by itself since the wax in the shellac can cause other finishes to not adhere properly, it really darkens the wood when a few coats are applied. I usually thin both with up to 50% or more of denatured alcohol , and apply multiple coats by wiping on. Takes longer but IMHO is easier to control and get a flawless finish.
My kitchen table is red cedar.
Basil
And as others have said, it's soft. It has very small to not so small dings in it. Drop a fork or a spoon and you may have a new ding. The wife usually has a table cloth on it so it doesn't show and doesn't matter. A dear departed friend built it and a cedar bench for me in exchange for some lumber. I wouldn't trade it for another table for anything. I often think of him when I eat.
If you can find some of a harder form of poly, say "gym coat" poly or the industrial grade of poly they used to use on cotton mill floors, it will help harden the cedar surface against normal use.
Re: finishing
Kernie Gilliam
I have finished my red cedar table, I finished it with conventional varnish sprayed with an airless sprayer. I would love to post a pic, can anyone help me with that.
Re: finishing
mdclor
In the FAQs section at the top of the page, you can find the following:
Q: How do I upload photos with my messages?
A: Registered users (those with valid profiles) may upload one or more images and/or files directly from their computer. All users may link to the URL of an image that is accessible on the Internet. To upload an image from your computer, first be sure it is smaller than the file size limit for that type of permitted file type. (Click the little blue button next to the "Upload embedded file" box to see the permitted file types and the size limits for each.) Place your cursor in the message text box where you want the image to appear in your post, then click the "Browse" button next to the "Upload embedded image" box and browse to the image or file on your computer and click Open. In a few moments, a line of code will appear in the message text, surrounded by tags. You may uplpoad as many images as you like, wherever you like, in the message body, as long as no image or file exceeds the file size limit for that type.
If the image you want to upload is somewhere on the Internet (e.g., Photobucket, Shutterfly, Picasa), you may include it with your message by pasting the URL of the image (JPG, GIF or PNG extension only) into the "Optional Image URL" box under the message text box. Registered users may also insert images in their messages using HTML tags. Please be sure you know what you're doing when using HTML in our message forms.
HTH