Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

How do you work? Philosophical question.

Posts

How do you work? Philosophical question.

#1

How do you work? Philosophical question.

Gary Smyth

Example 1. I have an acquaintence who is better than “handy”. He does lots of stuff especially house maintenance, yard work, typical car, boat repair, and many other tasks. I’ve seen his repair of big items like a thirty foot dock, set up a camp in the woods, and a wrap around deck for an above ground pool at his home. He keeps all looking immaculate. I DON’T KNOW HOW HE DOES IT? Seriously. He has relatively few tools. His “eye” is not sharp. His skills are better than average, but even he would agree that he is not a master. Still, he finds things, cobbles stuff together and gets things done, and honestly, they work.

Oh, he was a helicopter mechanic.

Example 2. Me. No special training except books. I do tasks similar to my neighbor. I believe that my eye is better. For sure my work is more precise (except for perhaps, engine work). Trouble is I spend twice, maybe three times as much doing it - time and money. Whether it’s a tool or accessory addition, a better grade of lumber, new hardware, taking (when compared to him) more time to noodle things out, policing the work area,…whatever. He can do it seemingly faster, with less expense, and it works.

For example if I need to remove something I'll get the tool and remove it. He would use what is at hand and muscle it and fill and paint it. In the end it looks the same, or close.

It’s driving me crazy. The precision in his work isn’t as good as mine, but it does work.

You are my sounding board. When you do a project how do you work? Is it faster and less expensive, or more precise and more expensive? Where is the line? I have many tools, I use them, and keep them tuned. My neighbor seems less interested in that stuff. My miters are tight, his less so, My screws are recessed, not all of his are, but again, for example on his deck, it does the job. Do you make room for new project stuff, or make do with what is available? I can’t help but think that I get bogged down in what is “right” when maybe it doesn’t matter for the end result of doing the job. I know that I only have to satisfy myself, but is my satisfaction level too high?

Comments.

Re: How do you work? Philosophical question.

#2

Joe Bradshaw

Re: How do you work? Philosophical question.

Joe Bradshaw

I like to do it right the first time and then I don't have to worry about it. Remember that you only have to please yourself.

Re: How do you work? Philosophical question.

#3

are you enjoying life?

Bill Tindall

that is all the counts. Unless someone else is paying you, how you get from here to there is only your concern. If you are satisfied with your results don't be concerned about someone else. If you are not satisfied then learn what you are lacking. If you don't have the skill to do what someone else can do (for example play the tuba) and that bothers you then try something else. The bottom line is how I approach a job should not be relevant to you.

The people that frame houses for a living are a different mind and skill set from the finish carpenters. I suspect different personalities gravitate to these different jobs and it would be silly for one to envy the other.

Re: How do you work? Philosophical question.

#4

Difference

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Between "doing" and "getting it done". Not a function of tools, really. I've seen masters do amazing work faster than I can, and with 1/10th of the iron I use.

Your neighbor is fine with a "fill & paint" kind of job, and it seems he depends upon the old adage that a good coat of paint will hide a multitude of sins. He doesn't care too much what's under the paint, and will be happy if his work lasts as long as he's in the space. I have at least two friends who've bought houses from similar owners. When it can time to do some repairs or especially additions, they shook their heads at the sloppy-but-good-enough work that was cobbled together. Both wound up tearing stuff out and redoing it.

Re: How do you work? Philosophical question.

#5

Dale Lenz

Re: are you enjoying life?

Dale Lenz

I think I could build a flag case with a skill saw and a few jigs. My flag case design would be different than now but the case would house a flag,... appearance(?). As the above posts has stated, it's what you want and can afford, in both time and money.

Re: How do you work? Philosophical question.

#6

Re: Difference

Jesse Cloud

There's an old ditty:

A little putty

A little paint

Makes a job look like

What it aint.

I think both approaches are valid, as long as you stay consistent - If you are in a hurry, don't expect perfection; If you want perfection, don't hurry.

I flip/flop between the two. Stuff just for the shop is hurry up so I can get back to work, but I try to take pains to do my best on actual projects. I make some pretty chairs with some pig ugly jigs.

Re: How do you work? Philosophical question.

#7

Any job worth doing...

Pat Evans

is worth doing well.

Re: How do you work? Philosophical question.

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Define "well"...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I can give a couple examples, too, and it boils down to a very basic principle of a successful business: "Cheap, fast, good; pick two."

Every August, I bust my tail for the first 2.5 weeks painting apartments since this is a college town. I make pretty good money doing so. It's not my best work because that's not what I'm getting paid to provide--I'm getting paid to "get it done" with a reasonable level of quality. If I can cut corners, I do. I have to save time where ever I can because I might run into an apartment that is absolutely trashed and will take me longer. My wife and I might do as many as 3 or 4 3- to 4-bedroom units in a day if they're full paints, and maybe 8-10 smaller units if they're only partially painted. It might take up to an hour to roll a unit and a little over that to cut one in. In the end, the landlord has picked "cheap" and "fast". (The "fast" is as much about schedule as it is the speed I work--they need each unit done that is on the schedule that day so that cleaners and carpet cleaners can get in there on subsequent days).

Contrast that with painting a room in a nice house around town (say, for a professor), and I might charge double for that one room what I would for a whole apartment, and it will take me a day to do. They're picking "good", and if they want it squeezed in sooner than I planned ("fast"), it won't be cheap. If they want me to do it cheaply, it will have to wait until I have exhausted all other leads.

Either case could be considered a job "well" done, even though the professor's room would be light years ahead in quality. You wouldn't expect the same level of quality in a Honda Civic as you would a BMW 7-series, though both might be well built.

Jason

Re: How do you work? Philosophical question.

#9

Re: How do you work? Philosophical question.

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Evening Gary,

When I started working for several antique dealers, I had to reconcile my own concept of acceptability with my employers' practicality. It became evident that they knew how much an item would sell for and that determined how much they could afford to pay me to repair/replace/refinish. Easy to work around that, and to exceed their expectations. I had more business than I could handle for a 3rd job. Lots of repeat business, and I still get calls from old clients. Now I can concentrate on the quality level which pleases me.

George

Re: How do you work? Philosophical question.

#10

Journey vs. Destination

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

For me, woodworking is about the process of working wood and creating things that I am personally proud of. It is not about getting the job done and out the door but, luckily, I am not expecting a paycheck from what I make either. My day job is working for one of those outfits (local governement) that is all about the "quick and dirty". Maybe I am turning into one of those "anarchists" like Chris Schwartz. Afterall, I am reading his book, "The Anarchist's Tool Chest".