Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

Posts

Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

#1

Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

Stephen Kirk

I'm getting ready to put in pull out trays in a pantry. They will be about 20"x24". I picked up some 3/4" ply for the shelves. I'm thinking it is very heavy, just for a shelf. I like torsion boxes, but I don't want to mess with all the ribs. I'm wondering if 1/2" rigid foam between two pieces of 1/8" hardboard would be strong enough. The slides are only rated for 100 lbs. The shelves are intended for small appliances, dry goods, pots and pans, etc. I'd also have to find what adhesive would work and not melt the foam. I'd have hardwood edging for attaching the slides.

Of I could just use the plywood. But I do like trying new things.

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

#2

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

Jesse Cloud

Interesting idea. I think I would just try it and see. Just buy a little bit of the 1/8 ply and a sheet of foam (useful for a sacrificial cutting table if nothing else), put the hardwood trim on and put some serious weight on it.

Let us know how it comes out!

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

#3

JL

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

JL

Interesting thought. A closed cellular foam actually has a reasonable amount of strength, but no real puncture resistance.

In terms of adhesive, I've used latex adhesives (and also paint) to stick pieces of foam together while building sets. Sometimes you have to do "shapes" and it is easier to carve foam :) . You can also make nice "beams" that are very lightweight.

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

#4

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

John McGaw

Rigid foam (usually PVC) between skins works for yacht hulls. It is certainly worth a try.

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

#5

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

Stephen Kirk

Yeah, that's my thinking too.

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

#6

So, if there's a flood

Stephen Kirk

I can just grab a shelf!

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

#7

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

NickinMass

Man, that's a lot of work for a pull out shelf. If you really want to play around with foam sandwiches then go for it by all means, but if you are just looking to make a pull out shelf, use the plywood. Granted, I will be playing with foam sandwiches myself in the near future (see my thread on torsion box design), but in that case weight is a major factor.

If you think that the 3/4 ply is too heavy, why not 1/2" ply? You're talking a pretty small shelf and you're going to need to put a solid wood edge around it anyway, so I wouldn't think you'd have a sagging problem.

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

#8

Re: So, if there's a flood

John McGaw

If you make it big enough, yes. Or you can surf on it -- fiberglass skin over rigid foam is the standard for surfboard manufacturing.

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

#9

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

Stephen Kirk

Funny, I just got the "do whatever is fastest" from my wife, which means the ply. I want to try this out, though, so I hope to get out and pick up the supplies. I make enough jigs that extra hardboard is always useful.

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

#10

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

For a torsion box to be strong and rigid you must have a good bond between the skins and the web. Many glues don't stick to most foams. Some two-part adhesives and resins dissolve the foam. For experimental aircraft we used Epoxy with the open-cell foam for good bonding. The primary foams we used were the blue (or orange) Polystyrene also Polyurethane, and PVC (Divinycell and Klegecell) foam.

A better alternative if you can find it to use honeycomb between your skins. Honeycomb comes in expanded aluminum, Nomex, and cardboard. You can easily bond 1/8" or 3/16" tempered hardboard to cardboard honeycomb.

Here is one source for honeycomb, but it is a bit expensive.


img

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

#11

Expensive but you get 10

Gary Smyth

I would call and ask if the supplier has a distributor near where you might be able to purchase 1,2, or whatever. Failing that, you could buy 10 and sell what you don't need. I'm thinking that over the long term with foam with even moderate but constant weight will eventually sag or compress. You don't want to repeat the process six months from now. Also, is the extra space taken up by the interior of the box worth it? Weight notwithstanding, solid something or double solid something might be more workable in the long rum.

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

#12

sagging?

John B

The roof of my shop is constructed with 8'x 16' foam sandwich torsion panels,SIPs, there is no sag. Boy i would be in a world of hurt if i had to replace it every six months. john b.

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

#13

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

John E. in SC

That pic reminded me of a hollow-core door - that's basically the same cardboard stuff in a hollow core door, and with the dimensions needed, you could by a 24" door, cut it in the length you need, and cut a filler piece for the cut end(s). I did that once to make at doorway for an attic access space, and it's held up fine. If the luan (sp?) skins are too thin, you could easily laminate a piece of hardboard or plywood onto it.

Re: Rigid foam for small torsion boxes

#14

I think that you know what I meant.

Gary Smyth

SIPs are structural and engineered. They are also machine made consistant and industrial strength glued. The tolerances are a bit more rigid for SIPs than what a home made unit might encompasss. Just looking at them you wouldn't expect strand board or particle board to sag but sure as other worlds exist they will over time and gravity. I was attempting to call attention to exploring other options to save time and space and still solve the problem long term. Torsion boxes have their application; I was questioning if this was the right one. No harm intended.