Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

advice please - Garmin or TomTom

Posts

advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#1

advice please - Garmin or TomTom

Terry Alexander

Yep....making the leap into GPS systems.

I have a new job that requires a lot of travel throughout West Texas. This last week I probably burned 1/2 tank of gas and even (accidentally) toured part of New Mexico. I need a GPS that will talk to me (I don't want to read and drive) and one with a large display (I'm not getting any younger). I don't need bluetooth, MP3 player compatability....just a dang good GPS.

Seems like Garmin and TomTom lead the pack.

Thanks in advance!

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#2

Garmin

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I update before every trip.

My kids, however, have iPhones so they get the same plus traffic as part of their package.

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#3

suggestion

Bill Tindall

go to a store that has both. Play with each and see if you can figure out how to use it. In my case Tom Tom failed miserably.

Do buy with life time updates. The Garmin web site has reconditioned units that are cheap. Also check Amazon and Walmart on line.

They are not fool proof. Also buy a Deloreme (spelling?) map for Texas which will show every road and some you don't want to drive on. You need to check on the big picture for the journey before blindly trusting the GPS route.

Best of all will be its utility in finding places to eat, especially in the out back. I was hungry for BBQ somewhere in remote Oklahoma. Searched and located one of the best places I ever ate for BBQ. Ditto for an ice cream Sunday in Roanoke one afternoon.

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#4

Yup Garmin

Dustmaker Mike

I had a Tom Tom when my wife had a Garmin. We went on a trip with both of them and the Garmin was a whole lot better and easier to use. This was about 5 years ago I got rid of the Tom Tom and got a Garmin with life time map updates. After it was stolen last year I got another one and if this gets stolen I would replace it with another. Get the life time map updates they pay for themselves pretty fast

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#5

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

Barry Irby

I also have a Garmin and like it. I did not get the lifetime maps, figuring that it would get stolen or they would update the hardware to the extent I would just buy a new unit. My son has one too and likes his as well. A friend has another brand (don't know what it is) but it is so poor she never bothers to use it. Get one with the largest screen you can a ford and you might check to see if some of them have the system that even tells you what lane to get in. I waited a long time to get one and now I can't figure out why.

PS. When you put in your Home address, don't actually put your real address. Put in your curmudgeonly neighbor with the shotgun. That way, if someone steals your unit while you are in the movies and heads to your house, they will get a real surprise, and so will the neighbor. the neighbor will be sure he was right all along.

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#6

Garmin.. I've had both


Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#7

Garmin

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I have a Garmin and would quickly buy another if I needed to. Garmin will get you there, but if you know a local area you can probably find as good as or a better routing yourself, but then if you know the area why are you using a GPS.

There are errors in all the map data bases for GPS as they all use the same basic source for their maps. Also none of the GPS units will take into account how many traffic lights there are on a given route. I always preview the suggested route to insure it is taking me the way I want to go. The calculations will go with teh first route they come up with and do not consider alternatives that may be a bit further distance wise but would have fewer potential stops due to traffic.

I also recommend the lifetime updates.

Lee

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#8

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

Carol Reed

Garmin - biggest screen available - life time maps - vocal directions - and pictures of crazy multiilane traffic changes so you know which lanes to choose. I like mine.

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#9

Tom Tom

Ron in Sterling, CT

I was given a Tom Tom a year ago as a gift, and have been very happy with it. We have traveled across the United States with it, and it has take us where we wanted to go. I had no trouble learning how to use it. I agree with Bill however, that you should go to a store which has both of them and try them out for yourself because you will be the one ending up using it.

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#10

Re: Tom Tom

Doug Adams

HI

I just bought my second Garmin #1450LTM and LTT it has a 5in display , life time maps and lifetime traffic I got it from Amazon for $136 with free shipping and no sales tax. I love it

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#11

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

Scott Greaves

I have a Garmin, and I would buy another if this one were to die. Actually, I almost wish it would die! We've had it for about five years, and I wouldn't mind getting a nice new big one with lifetime maps. But this one is still doing great!

Actually, I guess I have two Garmins. We also have a Colorado for geocaching.

Definitely Garmin!

Scott.

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#12

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

Jesse Cloud

Piling on. One more thumbs up for Garmin. It has done everything I've asked it to do. I enjoy kinda roaming around a new city, going wherever looks interesting, then when its time to get back on track, I just ask Garmin to take me to the next city on the itinerary.

Also amazing how much detail it has. Here in New Mexico we frequently take long dirt roads in the middle of no where. Garmin never fails to show them correctly and always knows how far to the next gas station.

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#13

Re: advice please - 1 more for Garmin

Bob Entwisle in NJ

We've had one for about 5-6 years. Easy to use, talks to you etc.

When heading to an unfamiliar place I generally take a look at a real map just to get an overview of the general area, but the Garmin has not steered me wrong yet. One of the features I find I like a lot is that it gives good advance warning of when you need to turn or take an exit etc.

Bob

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#14

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

Carol Reed

Absolutely LOVE the nearest gas station feature!

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#15

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Garmin AND Bluetooth....

Jesper, Denmark

Another vote for Garmin, but pick one with Bluetooth. You cellphone probably already has it, so you can answer the phone hands free while underway and stay safe.

Here in EU, using a handheld phone while driving is illegal and results in fines that can be several hondred $$'s.

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#16

Re: Garmin AND Bluetooth....

Nelson

Tom Tom here and love it. Mine has all features talked about,it talks to me, tells me if acident ahead, time delays,multiple lanes etc,as all those features mentioned for the Garmin.

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#17

Re: Garmin AND Bluetooth....

Jim Shockey

One more for the Garmin and blue tooth.

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#18

Rick L

Re: Smart Phone

Rick L

I've had both Tom tom and Garmin. They are more alike than dofferent if talking about comparable models. I like my Iphone as it has the internet so it can search out places to go and give gas prices and will talk to you with directions. So getting a GPS with the internet is the best option and you might as well get it on the phone because I can't see paying for the internet on more than one device. It gives me traffic jams and if you decide you want to stop at a Mcdonalds it will get you there. You can also get that feature on the favorites on a regular GPS but you need to do the updates on it. As said by others if you get a regular GPS get the lifetime maps up dates and traffic. I prefer the the smart phone as the updates are automatic and you can look up things as you go as far as other sources such as shopping or on the spot info. I also have this great app called cam scanner for copying documents and articles I find that I need or just want...that alone makes it worth the cost.

Re: advice please - Garmin or TomTom

#19

Re: Garmin AND Bluetooth....

Barry Irby

I have both a Garmin and a phone that'll do directions (not an I-phone). The problem is that if you lose cell signal you lose the directions feature. And about half the places I go to do not have cell service. Garmin works well in those areas. And there is no monthly fee with it.