Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Planers and Jointers

Posts

Planers and Jointers

#1

Planers and Jointers

Steve Wendfeldt

Any one own planers or jointers from Minimax. I can't find any reviews. What about planer/jointers combo? Are they in the same quality class as their bandsaws?

Re: Planers and Jointers

#2

Re: Planers and Jointers

David Yoho

I don't own a MM jointer/planer but I do know there are several guys who hang out here that do. Hopefully they will see your post and respond. However, I have seen some of their combination machines in the past and I can say they are every bit as nice as their bandsaws.

The good thing I see is you get a jointer and planer that can handle the same width of stock, unlike dedicated machines where the jointer usually isn't as wide as the planer. The MM machine I saw years ago was simple and quick to change from one to the other. For me, the down side of the combo machine is the length of the infeed and outfeed tables aren't as long as I like.

I think there is still a Mini Max users group on Yahoo that you could check out.

Re: Planers and Jointers

#3

Re: Planers and Jointers *LINK*

Bill Earl

Fine Woodworking did a comparison review on Jointer/Planer machines a few years back. Minimax was rated "Best Overall"


Fine Woodworking Review

Re: Planers and Jointers

#4

Re: Planers and Jointers

Lester Gillett

I have looked at most of the top name joiner/planer and the cost has me chringing. I wounder

how the Grizzly or Jet unit are compaired to the outhers. I like the Grizzly best and i am going

down to there tent sale this summer.

Lester

Re: Planers and Jointers

#5

Re: Planers and Jointers

Steve Wendfeldt

Thanks, Bill. I've got the article in my archives, but forgot about it. I appreciate you pointing it out to me.

Re: Planers and Jointers

#6

Re: Planers and Jointers

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I understand almost all the Stationary planers are built in one place in Asia, I may have read it on this message board, I believe it is GeeTee tool or something like that. I'm sure the various vendors have some changes to the basic planer like roller or cast infeed/outfeed tables, labels, paint color, motors etc., but all that I have seen sure look like they came off the same assembly line. I have a 5 HP, 20" (can't remember the trade name but it came from Wilke machinery before they stopped selling equipment). I purchased the planer with the Byrd head but it was late in shipping so Wilke sent it to me with a straight blade then later sent the Byrd head, we converted it in my shop. I have the 8" Grizzly joiner that came equipped with the Grizzly segmented carbide cutter head (very similar to the Byrd). Both do a great job of joining / planing "wild" grain woods. I have actually sent a completed frame and panel assembly through the planer ( to try to salvage a screw-up), obviously some of the wood was cross grain planed. I didn't really think it would work but the assembly came out great and required little finish sanding. After looking at various planers and joiners tagged with various manufacture's names, I really think Grizzly has some of the best quality and prices in the Industry. They also have pretty darn good service when you have a problem and I believe carry the largest inventory of replacement parts for their equipment. I had a 6" Grizzly joiner for several years before upgrading and it functioned quite well, just wanted longer beds and more capacity (and the carbide head).

Re: Planers and Jointers

#7

Re: Planers and Jointers

Joe W

I have a CU300 Classic Combo Machine..I like it a lot. I am a home hobbyist and purchased the machine used from Minimax about 8 years ago.

I have the old style cutterhead in my machine which uses the thicker types of blade. They are not the quick change disposable type. It does a nice job for my use. It has the 3.5hp motors. The jointer tables are on the short side as is the case with most combo machines, but change over from jointer to planer is about a minute. The tables, when planing, are in the way a little bit so it takes a little bit more walking to get to the output side of the planer.

The only real problem I have had is is that some boards do not feed completely through the planer. This problem has occurred lately and I suspect that I probably need to finally change the blades on the cutterhead or readjust the tension roller. I have never messed with the setup since I received the machine.

The people at Minimax have been helpful over the years and the members at the user group have been good too. I would like to note that the technicians at Minimax monitor the questions posted and regularly post solutions to your questions there.

I know there are wider planers available, but I like the wide jointer capacity, and for my home use, the shorter tables have not been a problem. The machine is well built and it looks like mine was well used before I purchased it, but I have no regrets. I really like the mortising table that I got with mine too that works off the cutterhead.

Re: Planers and Jointers

#8

Re: Planers and Jointers

keith Turner

I bought a used Felder AD531(12") this summer,after spending a little time setting the blades the machine works exceptionaley well. It takes about 30 secs to change from jointer to planer and back. For anyone with limited space (like myself) I would highly recommend a GOOD combination machine.

Keith