Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

The downward slide of our trade.

Posts

The downward slide of our trade.

#1

The downward slide of our trade.

Keith Newton

Having a pizza in my favorite place on this last day of the year, I notice the chairs have changed. There used to be an assortment of old wooden chairs. Now they are all the Thonet Cafe chairs No 14, probably the most successful chair design in the history of this planet.

There were some 50,000,000 sold between 1860 & 1930, and have been in constant production since it's inception. There were only six pieces of steam bent beech to begin with, later braces were added to strengthen them. Ten. Screws and a couple of nut, and a woven and seat were standard back then.

I notice the feet are clear plastic half spheres, and think to myself, I need to find a source for those. Then i notice the thinner uniformity, and my hand reaches back to feel the back leg of the one I'm sitting on. Damn, just as I thought, it is metal. I'm not sure why I feel so dissapointed, the wooden ones were probably not as strong. Needed more attention, and weren't all that comfortable. But they could be shipped flat well ahead of its time. Still, I like the wooden one better.

Archiologist can argue over what the first tools were made of. But I know, if I were a neanderthal, and got up on a cold morning to go hunting, I would rather hold a wooden tool or weapon than a cold stone, i feel there is something in our DNA that makes us intrinsically like wood. Not to mention the warmth given off by burning.

Well, I'm glad they didn't go with the plastic stackable Walmart chairs, which may have already surpasses the Thonet Bentwood No 14 in the few years they have been in production, even of they are a darn lot more comfortable.

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#2

Re: The downward slide of our trade. *LINK*

Tom Dunlap

I didn't know what a Thonet #14 was, I thought, but I do.


Thonet #14

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

Moses Yoder

Our craft is actually getting more advanced, not diminishing in skill. New things and techniques are learned every year, better steel is being used for tools, etc. The problem is the customer. For instance, if your pizza parlor installed Brian Boggs chairs then charged $120 for a large pizza, nobody would eat there. If a pizza costs $11.99 at one shop and $11.98 at the other, everybody eats at the $11.98 shop to save a penny. They don't care about the quality of the pizza, all they see is the almighty dollar.

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#4

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

Charlie Lenz

I agree with you to a point Moses, price is a big deal nowdays when everything is going up but wages. But I think that people will still spend a little more on a better tasteing Pizza. I think that another major contributing factor to the decline of woodworking is that more people are finding themselves in the position that they can't retire, and may never be able too. They don't have the time for hobbys anymore. As far as it being a trade, I'm currently working for a guy painting walls, and finishing woodwork in new homes, I hate it. Everything is a million miles an hour all day, can't do much right, it's barely a liveing wage, and there are absolutely no bennefits.

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#5

Bart Goldberg

I will pay more for better Pizza!


Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#6

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Other contributing factors- fewer and fewer schools have WW shops. Kids today are too busy playing video games and texting, and many of their parents don't know one end of a screw driver from the other. What are they gonna do when they have money and time for a hobby like woodworking?

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#7

I've been on  diet for eight weeks....

Barry Irby

I would kill for any pizza. Or even a piece of bread.

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#8

I can't agree entirely, but the essence is there..

John in NM

On the one hand, if I were buying identical pizza's I would in theory go to the cheapest place.

But in practice.... I buy gas all over the state of NM, and I will often pay a bit more at a station that is easy to get to than one that is difficult.... I value the convenience.

We don't all buy all our tools at Harbor Freight, and in many cases we choose tools that are aesthetically pleasing in addition to being functional. That these tools tend to be more expensive is excused due to their giving us pleasure by their very appearance.

However, in the furniture and/or cabinet business, price does hold more sway than with gas or pizza. I think it is due to the products being relatively expensive compared to a lot of our purchases, and also due to broad competition in the trade - there is very little that is really and truly unique, but I've noticed that many of the genuinely successful furniture makers are pursuing unique design trends. In addition to being more interesting for the builder, they just plain sell better, when priced similarly, than something that 5 other shops in town are also making.

Getting back to the original post though, I don't find it to be the decline of craft so much as the incline of manufacturing efficiency. That the manufacturer chose to copy a wood design and even camoflage it as wood is simply poor taste. Take the same steel chair and hot blue it, and you might have a really nice wrinkle on an older design.

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#9

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

Charlie Lenz

That may be true Alan, but the tool manufacturers are trying to make it look like you don't need to know what end of a tool to use, anyone can be a carpenter or woodworker. HGTV, the DIY Network, and PBS all push it. For instance, I just got done watching on TV an infomercial about the Rockwell VersaCut circular saw. I also visit a paricular dust collection website, and I've noticed that craftsmanship seems to be a rare occurance there. I like to put some pride into my work, but it just seems harder to do and care anymore, very few seem to care. Hurry up, get it done.

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#10

Bart Goldberg

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

Bart Goldberg

Agree on the WW in school comment. When my township built a new Middle School a few years ago, much to my dismay, they did away with their woodworking program. Now they only teach cooking and sewing to my son. I assume they did not want to incur the added cost of equipment and insurance.

Bart

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#11

Re: I've been on  diet for eight weeks....

Joseph Mulherin

Barry. look into the Jillian Michaels fitness program. they say it only cost about $16/mo, and you can stay as long as you want to to loose the beforehand specified weight you want to loose.

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#12

Re: I can't agree entirely, but the essence is the

Jesse Cloud

John,

I think you nailed it when you said "there is very little that is really and truly unique, but I've noticed that many of the genuinely successful furniture makers are pursuing unique design trends. In addition to being more interesting for the builder, they just plain sell better, when priced similarly, than something that 5 other shops in town are also making."

There needs to be something special for the buyer, and usually thats not joinery or wood vs. mdf. I doesn't take much. When I build a chest of drawers, I put a couple of small drawers right below the eye level (which I make a point of measuring) of the customer. I fit chairs to knee height and to lumbar height. I charge $250 more for a fitted chair than for a generic chair. People complain that my generic chairs costs too much, but I've never had a complaint about the cost of a fitted chair.

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#13

And it's a big mistake....

John in NM

I've been thinking a lot about CNC, as a few things I currently make would lend themselves well to it. But even if I decided it was worth the investment in equipment, there's that learning curve :O

But it did get me thinking, when I was in HS in the 1980's all the guidance people were telling us to take computer classes. Learning to type and program basic on some old Apple the school had spent huge amounts on. Seems like HS's should be keeping their shop programs and integrating CNC techniques into them. An 18 YO with experience in both conventional tool use and CNC would not only be employable in almost any city in the US, he or she would be way ahead when it comes to solo production.

Why schools have been following the trend of dropping shop classes is beyond me. Even if a lot of manufacturing has moved overseas, there is still a lot of demand for people with manual skills, whether its in small production, specialized fields (we have a lot of that in astronomical instrument work), prototyping, and repair and maintenance. None of this is easily moveable to China, and never will be.

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#14

Does that include or come with,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

Keith Newton

Pizza or bread, and perhaps a beer? Te he he.

I wouldn't want anyone to get killed by mistake here. ha

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#15

John, Im not sure you are keeping up,,,,,,,

Keith Newton

Even the jobs which are produced by shops with loads of CNC equipment are failing daily. I was looking for a piece of equipment a while back, searching online, and found our about the site below, which I get emails from daily to bid on shop equipment.

Back through the eighties, nineties, and double-naughts, I was worried about being able to compete with machines which could produce perfect parts all day long faster than any of the old ways which utilized human hands. But I have seen a steady stream of those shops being sold for pennies on the dollar.

I'll admit that I being a custom maker, don't spend my time in furniture stores, but occasionally I find myself face to face with some fair to decent stuff, being sold cheaper than I can buy the raw material from my suppliers.

If you are considering a CNC tool, I would certainly be looking for a close auction, and even for a lot of supplies. I think the community colleges in most populated areas teach courses for CNC programing.

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#16

Re: Keith?  Did you intend for a link?


Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#17

Why?

John in NM

I'll grant you that cnc shops fail at the drop of a hat - it is because the overhead is monumental and they can make stuff faster than they can sell it, let alone identify and fill new demand. You'll always find shops going under when they think that a bigger newer machine will solve any problem other than being swamped with orders, and often they fail to realize that even that one may be a problem to be managed rather than solved.

On the other hand, I would speculate that cnc machinery can be very well suited to small shops with low overhead and a bit more flexibility when it comes to filling niche markets and maybe a better tolerance for temporary idleness.

In my case the missing link is the learning curve - how to make the thing carve a complex free form object. The point is that this is not an insurmountable problem, but in my case the time to learn it was 10 years ago, or better yet 25 (you see, I finally understand my father's frustration with trying to program the VCR :D ).

Obviously I don't know how HS counselors currently view computer industries, but in the mid 1980's I can tell you ours had a much more "Jetsons" view of it all than turned out to be the case.

Re: The downward slide of our trade.

#18

Yep, I did.  *LINK*

Keith Newton

I pasted one in the link square, but must have missed something.


http://Auctioneer@IRSAuctions.com