Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Large dining table construction

Posts

Large dining table construction

#1

Large dining table construction

Larry in Tennessee

I am building a large farmhouse style dining table. Yesterday we jointed and glued up the top. It is close to 300 lbs. and is made from 8/4 red oak. The width is 45" and the length is 11'.

The aprons are 4" wide 5/4 red oak and will be mortised (and pegged) into standard 29" table legs that are 5" wide at the top. The distance between legs on the side tenons is 9' 10".

My friend's wife would prefer just 4 legs but I think we need another one of two down the middle of the table for added support.

Any advice on how best to support this beast of a table so it won't sag over time?

Re: Large dining table construction

#2

Sag!?!

Bill Tindall

Not even with a roasted pig and two dancing maidens in the middle.

One will never find that much floor acreage level so some of a 6 legged table legs would never be on the floor anyway. Getting 4 legs on the floor will be challenge enough.

I can't imagine the difficulty gluing up something that huge. Tell us how it got accomplished when it's done.

Re: Large dining table construction

#3

Re: Large dining table construction

R Payne

I've seen large, old farm table that had 5 legs (on in the center. Either that or 6 legs is what I would do.

ron

Re: Large dining table construction

#4

Dale Lenz

Sagulator *LINK*

Dale Lenz

Check out the sagulator link below. This device will work between the legs, not the ends. Even at 84", 7 feet between legs, there is very little sag. Remember there is very little weight on "shelf" except during a Large meal.

I too would be interested in how you jointed 11' - 2" boards. I've got a 16" jointer with 80"-90" something beds, to be honest never have tried to edge-joint 11' . Have jointed 72" boards with my 07 handplane, years ago.


Sagulator

Re: Large dining table construction

#5

Re: Sag!?!

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Something that heavy tends to level itself, at least in terms of getting all 4 legs into solid contact with the floor. I made special provisions to get my 6'2" table to not wobble on an unlevel floor that turned out to be a waste of effort and hard ware.

Re: Large dining table construction

#6

How we jointed 11' boards

Larry in Tennessee

My jointer is a Delta 6" jointer. Nothing too fancy and certainly it doesn't have lots of infeed and outfeed table space.

I put two teenage boys (15 and 17) on the tool to keep it from tipping over and out of the mobile base. Then three men (myself included) very carefully jointed the boards. As long as we kept the edge on the outfeed table flat and square, we only had to joint each board twice.

The finished table blank is pretty amazing. Every glue line is perfectly tight with no gaps. I am still not sure how we did it.

Re: Large dining table construction

#7

Glue up details

Larry in Tennessee

We used #20 biscuits to keep the top in alignment. On a couple spots, it might be 1/32" of inch off, but otherwise, all it will need is random orbit sanding.

The glue was Tite Bond II, we dry fit everything, then stood five boards on edge, applied the glue, inserted the biscuits and clamped it all up. It helped having 5 of us, but we were all very busy for the duration.

6 long Bessey clamps to hold it together and cauls on each of the 5 glue lines to keep the ends in alignment.

I was going to put some band clamps on for more pressure, but it just didn't need it.

The rest of the table will be easy compared to the top.

Re: Large dining table construction

#8

Re: Glue up details

Yonak

I guess you have a plan for getting the table from the workshop to its final location. Will it be up steps ? ..A neighborhood project ending in a fiesta (or kegger) ?

Re: Large dining table construction

#9

Re: Glue up details

Larry in Tennessee

My buddy has a 12' trailer and 4 sons. I have 3 sons. Between us, we will move the base first, then carry in the top and attach it with Figure 8's. And then I get a nice steak dinner on the table.

Re: Large dining table construction

#10

Re: Large dining table construction

Keith Newton

Well, I'm with you, as for having concern. I would bet that 8/4 R Oak will sag 1/4" - 3/8" under it's own weight initially, at 10'. Then slowly sag more over time.

You mentioned 29" legs, which is what most people would like the finished top to be. I try to keep 25" clear under the aprons, which doesn't leave you much height for that weight and span.

I think I would consider adding a couple of other long sub-stretchers well back on under, which are tapered down on the ends, and fat in the middle. You could also build in some crown to all of the above if you feel the need.

Another trick I have used to stiffen long members where I didn't have height for the support members, is to screw on a sprung flat metal plate to the backside of the stretcher. You can drill a lot of holes in a 1/8 or 3/16 x 2" steel bar, then put a few screws near the middle, holding it down a little. Then pull the ends up, pre-tensioning the steel.

Don't use all your screw holes, so if you get a call-back later, you just take some screws out, and move them to new holes well away from the last holes, without having to drill the steel under there on your back. Those hot drill curlycues can put your son's eye out quicker than a bebe gun.

Re: Large dining table construction

#11

the bet is on......

Bill Tindall

I just happen to have some 12' x 8/4 red oak out on horses waiting for the customer to pick it up. I am going to bet it don't sag 1/16". And I have some sacks of corn I can add to see how much wt. required for 1/4 sag....which nobody would notice in 11'.

Re: Large dining table construction

#12

Re: the bet is on......

Keith Newton

Well Bill, you may be right, but there is a good reason structural lumber is usually up on edge, and even then, I have seen plenty of sag over time in that.

The last thick oak that I had around was from a yard tree, which had a spiral grain, which made for a bit of grain run-out in the lumber, which would tend to make it more limber than straight grained, and possibly skew my judgement.

Still, if Larry doesn't do anything extra, but later finds that there is a growing problem, he could go back with a metal strap, and add it to the backside of the apron. Of course, by then, he would be fighting the new memory as well as the gravity.

Re: Large dining table construction

#13

Sag should not be your worry...

John in NM

In my limited experience, you're more likely to have a failure at one of the M-T's holding the legs and apron. Usually happens when someone tries to slide a heavy table rather than lifting it to scooch a couple inches. In that case, a couple extra legs won't help much.

I'd be amazed if 8/4 oak with (or even without) a 4" apron sagged enough over 10' to be noticed. Maybe if dinner guests like to play marbles over brandy :D

Re: Large dining table construction

#14

Feedback from a cabinetmaker friend

Larry in Tennessee

I have a friend down the street who has run a cabinetmaking shop for years. His advice is to put corner braces in which will take the pressure off the corner M&T joints. He also recommended three cross braces and also recommended I put corner braces on those.

I do appreciate everyone's input. It has been helpful.

Re: Large dining table construction

#15

Sounds like a plan...

John in NM

Corner bracing across the apron should help a lot, it's often overlooked on M-T tables, being associated more with removable leg designs. I might even go so far as to screw or bolt through the brace and into the leg - as if the leg were removable. That would likely be stronger than pinning the M-T, but you do run the risk of splitting the leg if it's delicate (I'm guessing it's not :D )

Re: Large dining table construction

#16

A few more suggestions.....

Barry Irby

If you really don't want your pants to fall down you wear a belt and suspenders.

You could beef up the leg connection by making the rails six inches high at the ends and increase the width (vertical dimension) of the M&T joint. Make those tenons really beefy. I think you mentioned the legs were 5" at the top. You could use tenons three or four inches deep and 3/4" thick. Or more. You could still have the rails be 4" wide by using a radius at the ends or a "cloud Rise" like in arts and craft furniture so that the six inch dimension was only for the last few inches.

You could also provide a brace of the inside corner of the legs up to the top. That could be M&T into the leg and screwed to the under side of the top. It could come just low enough on the legs to miss the diagonal brace across the top of the legs suggested by others, also a good idea. This would rise at a forty five degree angle and would quickly get out of the way of the person sitting at the end or near the leg. Round over the lower edges to make it "knee" friendly.

If you are concerned about the top sagging you could truss it. The reason "I" beams are desirable is that the top and bottom flange do most of the work. Same for the relatively new wooden I beams they are using for floor joists. You could add two or more to the underside of the table, say about five or six inches from the center. Peoples knees rarely reach more than about eighteen inches under the table and this one is 45" wide. Cut a curved piece of oak in a radius that arches down from about two inches to about three and half and then glue a oak 1 X 4 along the curve. Then glue the straight edge to the underside of the top. These could be cut to the length that allows them to drop right inside the end rails and rest on blocks. The long joints must be glued. The idea is that for the top to sag, it would have to stretch the oak 1x4's. (they should have rounded corners to make them knee friendly as well.)

I am not at all convinced you need to brace the top, but I am certain really bracing the legs is a good idea. With a three hundred pound top that table will be a bear to move and those legs will be stressed severely at some point in their life.

(Another idea is to use a stressed skin panel under the top or a box beam. Ask me if you care.)