Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Contractor Doesn't want to work?

Posts

Contractor Doesn't want to work?

#1

Contractor Doesn't want to work?

Allen Bryant - Bumpass, VA

I contacted 4 different contractors in order to get quotes for foundation for my new shop. I gave each one the same spec sheet and copy of the foundation plans to work from.

When all the quotes came back in 3 of them were within about $150 of each other. Quote #4 however for the same job was over $2000 more than the next highest quote. I didn't see anything different quality or time wise and he is using the same supplier for block as one of the others as they both included a copy of the price quote from the supplier.

I'm thinking that this contractor is either thinking I don't know what I'm doing or really doesn't want the job and just put in a token bid hoping I wouldn't realize he's overcharging.

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

#2

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

Dave's Not Here

They probably just have more work right now than they can handle. I doubt if they were trying to screw you. You asked for a quote and they gave you one that they knew wouldn't get them the job.

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

#3

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

paul in AZ

A contractor told me that this recession has driven all of the fly-by-night guys working out of the back of a pickup truck out of business leaving those left standing with enough work. No need to shave prices to get business.

Frustrating to get someone to do a job -counterintuitive in a recession.

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

#4

You asked for a quote

Gary Smyth

He gave you one. He should know what he's doing. Move on. Oh, only if he should ever call, tell him why then.

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

#5

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

Dick Coers

I'm confused why you expected everyone to have nearly the same price. Who knows what their overhead is, the skill at which they works, worker benefits, how clean they leave the work sight, etc.....Ask around, maybe he's worth the extra money. If not, move on with one of the other bids. He's not trying to cheat you, that's his price.

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

#6

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

Joseph Mulherin

Allen, for that pricing you need to have a talk with him and ask for an explanation of just how he comes up with his estimates. And, ask for recent projects he has accomplished...address, so you can talk to the people who had the work done...and how good is the finished look and is it holding up to the expectations of the owner. Any good contractor will answer these questions.

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

#7

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

Barry Irby

Could be Mark up Vs Turn. Some businesses operate on markup, meaning they want to make a substantial amount of money off each sale (Think high end watches like Rolex.) and some want to turn a lot of product and make a little off each transaction, (think Seko or Timex). The two systems don't understand each other at all. The Jewelry selling Rolexes is baffled by the guy selling Timexes and vice versa.

We had a contractor bib climbing up some trees. One guy bid $350 and the other $1000. We weren't going to do it at all at a thousand. We hired the second guy and he couldn't have been nicer or more professional. My son mentioned the other guy to him and he seemed baffled that the other guy only worked about two days a week while he did about two jobs a day.

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

#8

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

Mark Nowicki

With all due respect, unless Allan is ready to sign and give a non refundable deposit, the how and the why are none of his concern.

A good contractor would tell him that and still remain a good contractor.

Multiple estimates, materials and labor breakdown and a touch of attitude are warning signals that good, experienced contractors pick up and deal with in their own independent way.

Mark

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

#9

Profit Percentage

Yonak

I am confounded by my customer's attitude about profit. He's got a set percentage he feels he must make in order to carry a product. When I offer him a new item, if the price he must sell it at doesn't quite give him the percentage of profit he needs he's not interested, even if it misses by just a little bit.

It seems to me if he's there anyway, what does it hurt to have an additional product that makes a slightly lesser profit rather than not carry it and make no profit on no sale ?

If there are two different items there, one sells for less, but yields the right profit, and other is a bit more expensive and yields a lower percentage but the same amount of profit, why would that make it that much less attractive ?

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

#10

Moses Yoder

Re:Bean counters

Moses Yoder

I understand people wanting to make money off their business, and how they do that is up to them. There are numerous different ways to calculate what your mark up needs to be in order to make profit; he obviously knows about how much people are going to spend there every year and bases his mark up accordingly. What you could do is sell your products to him at a loss, so you would get more sales.

Re: Contractor Doesn't want to work?

#11

Re:Bean counters

Yonak

Great advice, Moses. To paraphrase Groucho, I'll consult my accountant about your idea and, if he advises me to do it, I'll get a new accountant.