Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Strange Electric Motor Problem

Posts

Strange Electric Motor Problem

#1

Strange Electric Motor Problem

Sue McLam

I am having problems with my drill press motor on my Delta 17-965. The motor simply stopped working one day; well, when I turned it on it would only hum and not run. I took it to one of the only two businesses in my state that repairs electric motors. They replaced a bearing and then it ran fine at their shop. I brought it home and it was like nothing had been done to it…same problem. I took it back to them and had them show me that it runs and it did – they turned it on and off several times with me seeing it with my own eyes. My b-i-l has an electrical background, but hasn’t worked on electric motors. He took it home and found a broken wire at the capacitor. He fixed it and it ran 100% at his house. So I brought it home again and it still doesn’t run here…same humming. I have bypassed the switch and plugged it directly into the wall at a couple of different places in my shop so I know I’ve tested it on at least 2 different circuits. I would appreciate any ideas or suggestions that anyone might have in helping me get this thing running.

Thanks!

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#2

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

Bill Howatt

The 2 usual components involved in a motor that hums but won't' spin are the capacitor and the centrifugal switch. The start winding is another but it usually isn't a high-failure component.

The centrifugal switch is closed when the motor is stopped and this puts the capacitor and start winding into the motor circuit to give it starting torque. When it gets up close to run speed the centrifugal switch opens and takes the capacitor and start winding out of the circuit since it isn't needed (and if left connected would overheat since the start winding wire is usually thinner than the run winding wire).

My guess is a bad connection in the capacitor/centrifugal switch/start winding circuit. Since it works then doesn't work after being bumped around in transportation, I suspect the centrifugal switch contacts aren't closing well or the contacts are worn. If the motor has been run in a dusty environment and isn't a totally-enclosed, fan-cooled motor it might just be a bunch of dust that needs to be blown out. However, since the motor has been worked on this is not too likely.

The capacitor may be intermittently faulty and they are not too expensive to replace, probably in the $10 range for a new one. Maybe the bad lead is still not corrected properly? You can test them with an ohmmeter. Applying the ohmmeter to the capacitor leads (disconnected from the circuit) it should read a low resistance and then gradually increase resistance to a high value as the capacitor charges.

Bill

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#3

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

Barry Irby

Sue, Its hard to believe that the motor would have three problems at the same time but ...maybe????

It seems to me that if the motor seized because of a bad bearing it would hum but would likely trip the circuit breaker or blow a fuse. A little hard to believe the bearing failed while you were not using it to the point it just hummed. Seems you would have noticed the bearing grumbling.

The broken capacitor wire might be a culprit. Without the capacitor to "kick start" the motor it might just hum.

It seems to me the first thing to check would be the start switch and windings. Many motors have a centrifugal switch in one end that closes when the motor slows down and applies voltage from the capacitors to the start winding to provide the extra torque needed to spin the shaft up to speed from a dead stop. As the motor spins up, the switch is opened be the centrifugal force and it runs on the regular windings and current. This is a wild guess, but the only thing I can think of is that you are operating the motor in a different position that the others and somehow that affects the switch. If you try it again and give the shaft a really good spin with you hand and it takes off, its pretty likely the switch, assuming of course this motor has one. You might try blowing it out to see if that helps. Don't take this as gospel, it really is a wild guess.

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#4

Does the drill spindle turn freely?

Dick Coers

Seems too simple, but does the spindle turn freely? Sounds like the capacitor should be replaced to me if all else is correct.

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#5

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

Sue McLam

Bill, thanks. $10 is my kind of budget :) I'll run this by my b-i-l since he'll be the one helping me with this!!

Sue

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#6

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

Sue McLam

Barry - I know! 3 problems? I was surprised when they said that it was a bearing as I never had a sign of it going bad. I'm going to run these responses by by b-i-l and go from there. I really appreciate the additional input.

Sue

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#7

Re: Does the drill spindle turn freely?

Sue McLam

Dick - yes the spindle turns freely and always has. That's why I was surprised when they said it was a bearing.

Thanks, Sue

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#8

Just for the sake of completeness...

John in NM

Check the line voltage where you've plugged it in. Very odd that it would work at the repair shop and your BIL's place but not at yours. Two outlets could easily be on the same circuit in your shop, best to check the voltage and get that ruled out.

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#9

Possible explanation for intermittent operation

Gary Evans

I'm going to guess that the springs in the centrifugal switch are weak. When the motor is turned vertically like it would be on the drill press, the switch is not making up like it should. Take the motor off and lay it on the bench and the springs have enough oomph to hold the contacts closed.

Gary

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#10

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

During my slow typing, Gary beat me to it. Is the checking at the alternate locations being done with the motor in the vertical position. A bad or miss-positioned switch, bad bearing, or bad thrust washer could contribute to this and allow it to run in a horizontal position. ALWAYS REPLACE BEARINGS AS SETS. A bad bearing's wear will stress the other bearing. The labor cost to replace the other bearing is usually small.

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#11

Re: Just for the sake of completeness...

Sue McLam

John, I'm pretty sure my BIL checked the voltage...he checked a lot of things. Plus I've run other stuff in that outlet but couldn't say for sure if they were comparable or not.

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#12

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

Sue McLam

Gary and Bill,

They were testing it horizontally but when I took it back to them and ran it in front of me they did stand it vertically too after they realized that that is how it is used and it ran for them.

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#13

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Have your BIL check the voltage at the motor terminals while trying to run it. Be careful to clears meter leads from pulleys, belt, etc. PREFERRABLY use a rotary, not a digital meter. Dig meters can show trace voltages that go away with actual loads.

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#14

No belt on motor still didn't run ??


Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#15

Re: No belt on motor still didn't run ??

Sue McLam

yes that's right

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#16

Re: No belt on motor still didn't run ??

del schisler

Is it the same line cord that goes on the motor. Did you take it to the repair shop with motor. I have had a bad plug and it was hard to find. I been in repair radio and tv and i seen lot's of plug's that have been intermitt like a broken wire at plug or at the strain relif plug ? I guess try a new cord ?? Like i belive it has been mentioned that their is a start run plate on plate end where the wires goes. I would make sure that all those were good. They go into spade lug's and are cremped maybe one has came loose ? Of course you would have to take off the bell end to do that. It will be small when you find the problum.

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#17

Check for a bad ground on DP

Dustmaker Mike

You might have a bad ground or natural on the DP itself plug in the cord hold one meter lead on the DP and put the other to a ground and turn it on if you get 110 across it then turn it off and unplug it until you find the short. Just Guessing either that or a bad switch.

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#18

Just replace the motor capaacitor

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

I had the exact symptoms on my 20" Grizzly drill press. Switch it on, and it would hum. Give the motor a spin and flip the switch and it runs just fine.

I called up the Grizzly people with part number and cap. size in hand. They knew exactly what I needed and shipped it to me. As I recall, it was a $15 dollar item. The worst part was re soldering the the leads. I think the motor was assembled by a group of dwarfs.....

Oh yes, the drill press worked one day and would just hum several days later.

Happy New Year,

Ken

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem

#19

Re: Strange Electric Motor Problem - Solved!

Sue McLam

I know this original message is pretty old now but I wanted to thank everyone again for their input.

I bought a new capacitor for the motor --- it didn't help. From the info provided here I got my BIL to open up the motor and look at the centrifugal switch. Lo and behold there was a loose screw at the switch. He tightened it up, put my original capacitor back in and now I have a working motor! I'm a happy camper.

Sue