Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

Posts

Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

#1

Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

Hoa in Alameda

I'm about to install 800 sf of engineered hardwood flooring on the second floor. The subfloor is plywood (not sure 1/2" or 3/4" yet).

According to the manufacturer (BR-111), this type of flooring can be glued down, glued together (floating), or stapled.

"Glued down" is out. The choice now is either glued together or stapled.

The question: In terms of longevity and maintainability (installation cost and time don't matter), is there any advantage of one method over the other?

Thanks.

Re: Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

#2

Re: Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

nickb

Hard for me to think of any longevity difference between the two installation methods, although I have noticed a different "feel" to floating floor installations compared to nailed/glued down hardwood. The big difference from my point of view is the installation. If you float the floor, you need to either install before baseboard or install a quarter round/shoe molding to cover the expansion gap (although I find that baseboard over installed flooring needs a quarter round or shoe anyway, unless you have the only home in America with perfectly flat floors). If you nail/staple, then you're going to have to get a floor nailer and compressor if you don't already have one.

Good luck with the project.

Re: Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

#3

Re: Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

Thad Parker

Having never done a "glue together" floating application, I can only attest to my experience nailing and stapling down floors.

I believe the most significant factor for longevity and maintenance is going to be the manufacturers finish.

If you're considering the possibility of having the floors resurfaced in the future (some manufacturers boast this possibility) I would definitely recommend the floors be fastened to the subfloor (nail or staple).

I've installed floating floors (though not glued together), but have personally been more satisfied with the fit and finish of a nail-ed down floor rather than floating.

just my $.02

Re: Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

#4

Re: Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

Dick Coers

For floating, do they want you to install it over a foam backer? I don't like the feel of those floors. They don't feel like a wood floor to me when the backer is used. I vote for staples. No glue squeeze out and clean up either.

Re: Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

#5

Re: Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

paul in AZ

I put down an engineered wood floor in my bedroom just 2 weeks ago. This was glued to concrete slab rather than floated. Obviously couldn't be nailed. Nailing to plywood would be easiest.

With care the old baseboards came off intact and were repainted without having to add any tacky quarter round. New baseboard is not all that expensive.

To me the biggest difference is in the feel and sound of the floor. A floated floor rides on closed cell foam so no matter how solid the engineered material it will not walk with the firmness or sound of a wood plank floor.

That said I did put down a floating cork floor in my previous house up north. Cork's resilient and soundless surface lent itself well to that.

Assuming the surface finish is halfway decent it could be many years before longevity will be a factor. If you are concerned you could wash on a couple of light coats of water based poly with a sheepskin mop. I did that on the cork floor to seal the cracks to snow and mud traffic [don't get either of those here] more than anything else.

Re: Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

#6

Re: Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

Tony - Memphis

My wife and I installed a floater several years ago in our breakfast room. No issues installing or with longevity so far. We really like it and it was easy. It was a Pergo product that isn't available anymore (not here at least). The top is solid wood. Looks great and seems to be holding up well. We are on a slab btw. We did the foam layer first and that was over vinyl.

Tony

Re: Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

#7

Re: Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

Michael Wilkins

I had to glue down my engineered floor due to the particleboard underlayment. Never again. If I ever do another one, I will remove the crappy underlayment and install plywood. Then I would spring for a specialty flooring nailer for this type of floor (Bostich). Then I would sell the nailer by one of the usual selling methods (the bay or local). I have floating floors in other rooms of my home, but the nailing method would make for a solid footing. Just my nickels worth.

Re: Engineered wood flooring: glued vs stapled

#8

Stapled it is

Hoa in Alameda

Thanks for the inputs, folks.

I decided to go with the stapled-down method. Already having a small hotdog compressor, all I need is a stapler. I'll buy a stapler (don't want to rent because the whole project will span over several months) and sell it afterward.