Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Sound proofing

Posts

Sound proofing

#1

Sound proofing

Dustmaker Mike

Howdy well the electric should be done on my shop addition by the end of Jan. the next trick is insulation and sound proofing to keep the noise down for the neighbors. So my question is simple how can I sound proof the walls to keep the transmitted noise from going to far and insulate at the same time. Any brands or other? That is better or worse then the rest. After a year and a half I just want this project done.

Re: Sound proofing

#2

Foam seems best, from my reading

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Sprayed foam insulation seems to have the best results for soundproofing. If you haven't already put in your windows, and will be putting in double-glazed, you can order them with different thicknesses of glass in each part of the dual pane, which reduces sound transmission, too (the frequency at which one pane of glass resonates is different from the thicker/thinner one, so sound transmission through the window is reduced; apparently an incremental improvement, not worth spending a lot of money on).

You can get sound-barrier sheetrock, too, but I bet it's spendy.

Re: Sound proofing

#3

Re: Sound proofing

Gary Smyth

Mass, absorbtion, and/or isolation between the sound and the receiver is the answer. Achieving that can be done using one or another method using materials that block sound (walls), redirect it (angled "soft" and "hard" panels), absorb it (insulation). and/or isolate (cut off sound waves by isolating the noise maker) If you just want it done then find foam panels. Some studios use lead sheeting and double walls, Some use anechoic materials, Some build a "room" inside a room so that no part of one room allows sound vibration to another. It can get extreme. Windows and door are going to be the biggest sound escapes. I'm thinking that reduction is your goal, not proofing. Sound panels are available but you can get almost the same effect with a wood slatted wall and blown in insulation -- the thicker the better. If you have old drapes, even that will help but the dust they collect is hardly worth it. Block much of the sound from leaving the room, reduce sound enhancing (reflecting) flat hard walls and seal windows and doors and the neighbors ought not get too upset. Power tools and sound reduction are opposites, but start with insulation on six surfaces and correct where needed. A little attention to sound attenuation will help a lot, but depending on your budget and the location of your neighbor(s) it may be a tough road. Good luck.

Re: Sound proofing

#4

not a difficult task

Bill Tindall

Simply putting fiber glass insulation in the walls will vastly reduce the sound level escaping. This technique is good for kids rooms, baths, and drain pipe wrap so I would think it would be adequate for the shop noise. I doubt your shop will emit more noise to the outside that typical traffic generates.

It will be a straight forward task to see if this approach is sufficient. Just set your saw or planer up in the kitchen, have someone run some stuff through it while you stand outside to assess noise level. You might even think of an alternative test if it is difficult to get the planer into the kitchen.

Re: Sound proofing

#5

Re: Depends how close the neighbors are

Henry Higginbotham

My shop's walls are 2x4s (dope-slaps self) with OSB and vinyl on the outside, 1/2" Chinese poplar plywood on the inside, and R13 fiberglass in between. I've asked the neighbors if they can hear my tools running and they all said no. It's a hundred feet or better to most of them, which helps, but I've also had someone feed lumber through a surface planer while I stood about 50' outside, and sure enough there's not much to hear.

Now, late at night it would possibly be audible, and opening a window or door just invites trouble, but normally it's not an issue.

2x6 or 2x8 walls would certainly help, but I assume it's too late for that sort of advice. There's also a product that goes between the studs and wallboard that claims to reduce transmission, but I have no experience with it.

Re: Sound proofing

#6

Re: Sound proofing *LINK*

John McGaw

There are a near-infinite number of things that can be done for sound deadening (real 'proofing' is just about impossible) and if you do any little thing wrong all of the good things will be for naught. I worked in broadcasting engineering for a long time and we never really tried for perfection -- just enough to keep the product clean.

The low-frequency, high-frequency, and mid-frequency components of sound all respond differently and no single method will be truly effective in reducing all of them equally. Tight sealing, thick high-density insulation via mineral wool or cellulose, and vibration isolation via high-mass materials such as doubled drywall mounted on z-channel are things that the layman can do without running costs into the stratosphere. You could also look into the product shown in the link or into something similar (I'm sure somebody has copied it by now -- it isn't black magic) which would cut down on the need for doubled drywall which is a PITA no matter how you look at it.

I find that being at least a couple of hundred feet away from my nearest neighbor is the best bet.


One Help

Re: Sound proofing

#7

Re: Foam seems best, from my reading

TomD

I suppose it depends how good you want it to be. I have 3.5 inch wall, and they have vinyl siding, plywood, the stud bay which is filled with bats, and 1/2 inch drywall. Unlike insulating for heat. Your neighbours wall construction also counts. I run some big machines, my wall is about 3 feet from his. His house has a garage right next to my shop, but the second floor over it is his bedroom, he is mildly deaf, and never complains. I do not run machines normally past 10, and never after 12. He goes to bed early.

What shouldn't be underestimated is the noise of hammering. I would rather hear the occasional hum of a planer, than sporadic dovetail hammering. That is part of the reason I use a urethane mallet. The peak noise of hammering is pretty high, it is just very short duration. Apparently full out nail hammering is around 22 cal rifle levels, above the threshold of ear damage, but very short in duration. Bad combo for irritating the neighbours.

As to your question. The best sound damper when I was building was considered to be z strips for the drywall. These are metal strips that have a Z shape. One flange is fastened to the studs, and the other stands well proud of the wall to receive the drywall. This will subtract from you workspace a little, and I would also want to check the impact on racks, though I would think there would be some workarounds there. The idea of these strips is that sound transmission is less a mater of insulation than providing a solid highway for the sound to connect through.

Re: Sound proofing

#8

Re: Foam seems best, from my reading

TomD

By the way, sound attenuates as to the cube of distance. So 100 feet is like 37 000 times less noisy than 3 feet, which sounds wrong, but is what my calculator says. My shop is about 6 feet from our house, It's walls are 8" concrete block with 3.5 inch studs, and insulation. My wife absolutely hears the noise of my machines in the house. It helps that I rarely use either table saws, or routers. I do run a large planer. Which would probably be the only thing she hears. I also mostly work during the day.

Sound really isn't all that rational an experience. If one has ever taken video next to a road, then played it back and been surprised at how noisy the road was, that is the psycho accoustic part of it. We heard what we want to hear, and also what we are able to hear. Which is presumably why Jeff Cooper the famous gun writer said he never was really bothered by the noise of guns but could not believe how noisy a country band was at some dance he attended. :) Those of you who build guitars know that the guitar is not able to fully produce some of the notes it is required to play. No problem, the human "ear" just fills them in.

Re: Sound proofing

#9

Re: Sound proofing

Gonzalo

There is a product called greenglue that works extremely well, much better than insulation alone.

http://www.greengluecompany.com/

This is the company I dealt with when I was soundproofing my shop and music room. They were very knowledgeable, and it may be worth a phone call to see what they have to say.

http://www.soundisolationcompany.com/

Re: Sound proofing

#10

Re: Foam seems best, from my reading

TomD

I should have used a different heading. I would imagine foam is very good.

Re: Sound proofing

#11

Re: Sound proofing *LINK*

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

Mike - The Z-channel that was mentioned works well, but for it to work, you have to install it so that nothing from the drywall side touches the stud side. Mounting things on the drywall will probably defeat the Z-channel effectiveness and it only takes one screw going through the drywall and into a stud to defeat the channel's advantages. I don't know about you, but every available inch of my walls has something on them.....

Woodworking tools emit mostly high frequency noises, which works to your advantage - it is relatively easy to block or absorb. There are some fiberglass soundproofing batts that can be used and they will insulate well too. As mentioned, spray foam would be best if it fills the stud cavity, the acoustic batts would be a good second. With either spray foam or batting, use as heavy a layer of drywall as possible. Even better would be a layer of OSB under the drywall. This would create a heavy mass that would absorb the sound. Remember to do the roof too. Any hole from the inside of the building to the outside that is in a direct line will allow sound to get out, so plug them all if you can.

Finally, don't forget the windows. At least double pane with really good seals will keep much of the noise in. Triple pane is even better.

I wouldn't worry about putting foam on the walls. It shouldn't really be necessary if you make the walls correctly and seal them well. If you do decide to use foam absorbers, be sure they are fireproof. Check out the link below for an example. Cheap non-fireproof foam gives of vapors that can quickly kill you, so don't go there.

Enjoy your new shop!


Station Club Fire