Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Found at a Crate and Barrel

Posts

Found at a Crate and Barrel

#1

Found at a Crate and Barrel

Bruce, a MN Galoot

This sign describes a dining table. The table was nice, but the description was obviously written by someone who doesn't understand the process. And the natural raw wood edge? It was applied, not a part of the boards of either edge.


Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#2

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

Terry Quiram

Sounds like someone trying to sell crap to the unwitting.

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#3

Good catch

Gary Smyth

After reading I had to look this up. They have two versions of tables. You would think for over $1300 (77 inch) and over $1600 (99 inch) they would be able to deliver an accurate description in the store. By the way, their catalog does a better job describing the item. Oh, and the benches (51 inches and 71 inches) for these tables seem to be a bit pricey at $600 and $700 also. Perhaps the shipping from Poland alters the cost so.

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: Good catch

Moses Yoder

Why is it that woodworkers think they can build something for less money than some of the most efficient shops in the world, equipped with millions of dollars worth of automated machinery? In my opinion this is a form of ignorance. Not calculating anything for your time means you believe time with your family is of no value. My wife and my daughter have bought numerous Sauder and equivalent furniture pieces over the years simply because when I build something it costs a lot of money in time and materials and they got tired of waiting. And the CD rack she bought recently holds CDs as well or better than anything I would have designed and built. Granted, it won't last as long, but what I built would have cost at least $800 in time if I only calculated $15 per hour for my time. I consider time with my family to be worth at least $30 per hour.

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#5

A.J. Hamler

I'd like to know...

A.J. Hamler

...how they set that table without getting any footprints in the snow.

Set the table first, and then put it in the snow? Maybe, but they guys carrying it and putting it in place would also have made footprints.

I'm guessing they used a crane.

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#6

Somebody...

Bob Hackett

Is going to have dinner guests with cold feet. :)

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#7

Re: Good catch

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I wasn't commenting on the price. It wasn't unreasonable given the shear amount of wood in the sucker. I'm quite certain that there is $300-400 worth of wood alone. The top and legs really are made of 2" thick oak. I bill out at what you do, and that doesn't begin to include benefits. That's not the problem.

I posted this mostly because I wasn't aware that fuming oak was a heat-treating process ;) .

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#8

You're assuming it's snow, too

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It could easily be some snow "fake," sprayed in place after the table was set, with a backdrop of trees in snow. Studio photographers do things that can look amazingly realistic.

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#9

Re: I'd like to know...

Yonak

Putting that stuff in with a crane would have been a trick, with those tall candle holders and canister of wine and all . . . Reckon how it snowed on the ground but not on the table or benches ?

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#10

Re: You're assuming it's snow, too

nickb

Looks like fake snow with a backdrop in a studio to me. Have a look at the table vs. the background - that limb looks like it is practically hanging over the table, yet it is out of focus (unlike the deep depth of field for the table). Nice job with getting the lighting right, though...

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#11

An applied live edge?

John in NM

Good grief... what is the world coming to?

PT Barnum would be proud :D

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#12

Re: An applied live edge?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Yup! It was a perfectly straight line along the joined edge.

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#13

Re: An applied live edge?

Dick Coers

On the left bench, the left edge looks correct, the right is applied. That lets them get the approximate width they need without looking at a lot of boards. I think it's a pretty good job. Glad to see furniture that looks like it is made from trees becoming a strong style in the general public.

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#14

My question is WHY is the table in the snow?

GolfSteve in Calgary

Looks like a cold dinner to me.

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#15

Re: Good catch

Paul Blackwell

The picture looks more like walnut than oak. Am I wrong?

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#16

Fuming?????

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

There isn't any heat involved in fuming!!! When you fume something, you put it in a tent or other enclosure filled with ammonia gas or with a tray containing liquid ammonia.

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#17

Re: Fuming?????

Bruce, a MN Galoot

See, that's what caught my eye, besides the fact that it was a nice table.

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#18

Crate and Barrel - not that bad

wilbur

It's fun to make fun of this, but Crate and Barrel does sell pretty good furniture overall. We have a coffee table from Crate and Barrel, and have never regretted the purchase. I always swing through the Crate and Barrel at the local mall, and the furniture consistently shows attention to grain direction, board selection, and good joinery choices.

They are showing some innovation in the woods used in their furniture lineup. Our coffee table is made with mango wood, and is just gorgeous. Crate and Barrel does go to some trouble trying to use renewable sources for their lumber, such as using plantation-grown woods.

As for the applied live edge, if you were mass producing this sort of table, of if the slab you had at hand for the table top was not the right width for the table, how would you go about doing it?

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#19

I `d rip the extra width out of the center.


Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#20

I agree with Bob

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Since the live edge is the star of this production, I'd leave that and rip the other edge accordingly.

I agree with you about Crate and Barrel furniture. I like their stuff, both in design and execution. Actually, we like a lot of their cooking and other stuff, too.

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#21

Re: I agree with Bob

wilbur

That would work well if you only have one, or a few tables to make. If you need to make a run of identically sized tables in the thousands, I can see where ripping just the live edge to get enough stock on hand and applying it to a standard-sized middle would be the better way to go, even if this comes at the expense of design.

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#22

Well, for starters,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

one side was done with a real board with its original edge, it was the other one that was applied. I should have made that clear.

The fact is, there aren't that many people who would recognize the difference.

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#23

I did

Bob Hackett

And I am not the sharpest tool in the shed. :D

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#24

Re: Well, for starters,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Yeah, but you're special. :D

Re: Found at a Crate and Barrel

#25

Poor choice....

John in NM

For mass production, some designs simply cannot be well executed by the thousand. I would say that a live edge is one of them. I give them an A for wanting to broaden the styles they offer, but at some point they need to draw the line on execution.

To me it's a bit wood grain paper glued to particle board - not as bad by any means, but the same kind of "cheat" that offendith the eye :D

Maybe gluing a cast resin bit of carving to imitate carved wood is a better simile.

Both are a bit hyperbolic, but they illustrate the point.