Douglas fir
Joseph Mulherin
What do you opine about using douglas fir for furniture? I think it is much stronger grainwise than pine and would make some very strong chairs, and the cost is vastly lower too.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Douglas fir
Joseph Mulherin
What do you opine about using douglas fir for furniture? I think it is much stronger grainwise than pine and would make some very strong chairs, and the cost is vastly lower too.
No reason why not with a bit of care
John in NM
Main disadvantage is that it's a bit tricky to cut neat joints and sand it because the annual rings are sooooo much harder than the pithy summer wood. This also makes is hellish splintery under heavy wear, like a bench top.
The only other thing I can think of is that you're limited to dimension lumber, even in the prime grades. Maybe that's not the case where you live, but it is here. But with a lot of designs that would not be much of a concern.
Might have stability problems too, I'd have to look it up. But that too you can work around easily enough.
I just cut up some old, old white pine last week, I've been saving it for carving some casting patterns. Man, there is no comparison to any pine I've used before. This stuff is from the stash of a violin maker who died in the 1930's (died young, I bought his wood from a granddaughter). Rings are about 1mm apart. Maybe them guys up in Maine still see pine like this, but I sure don't 
Re: Douglas fir
David Yoho
Personally, I would be inclined to use it only if I could get quartersawn. Locally most of what I see is already dressed and I think it's quite expensive because of it. I'd be more interested in stock in its rough state but dried.
Re: No reason why not with a bit of care
Joseph Mulherin
John, I have said I am making some Windsor chairs this year for family and friends. I checked out the prices of the whitewood(pine) at Home Depot and Lowes. 2x6x16ft is about $23; same size for DF is about $8. If it is smoothed sanded and covered with a good poly in finishing I am thinking it will not have the splintery effect the boards have in construction of walls with studs, etc.
I have the Shopsmith (5inone tool) which I will be using for most of the .work in shaping the chair items, as well as the 11" bandsaw.
I think that would work...
John in NM
Might be better than pine even for spindle work as the stuff is quite strong, you're quite correct that the splinter problem would be negligible in this case (I sure wouldn't use it for a chair seat though
). I think I would try to select boards with tight grain and try to avoid grain runout as much as possible.
I used quite a bit of prime fir when I lived in Tucson, for window frames, door jambs, and some cabinet work. It's actually very nice stuff, but quite expensive compared to framing lumber. Doesn't mix nicely with brad nailers though, I've seen the brad turn 90 degrees rather than penetrate a hard ring. Great way to get a pierced finger 
Re: Douglas fir
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
Fine Woodworking did an article on Doug fir in furniture years ago - back when it was a black and white magazine, which means 25 or more years ago. The consensus of the makers featured was that vertical grain DF was a great if demanding furniture wood; I don't recall that there was much of the flat-sawn coarse-grain stuff that most studs are made of.
I have noticed that some of the stud stock in my local yard is fine grain and, occasionally and accidentally, rift- or quarter-sawn. If I had more storage space, I'd grab those and sticker them as potential furniture stock.
If you can pick through and find some quarter sawn or rift sawn, fine grain DF at your local lumberyard or big boxy store, give it a shot. You might also see if your local yards stock vertical grain DF and, if so, what the price is.
The other issue is whether you can get it dry; wet wood will likely give you fits as a furniture wood.
Re: Douglas fir
paul in AZ
Decent Doug fir and pine are more expensive than they're worth IMO and neither are without troubles -one is soft and the other has very hard growth rings.
If those are your considerations why not look at something like poplar or birch? Work nicely, strong, smooth w/relatively closed grain, finish well and dirt cheap.
Re: Douglas fir
Thomas S Stockton
Joseph
I've made a fair amount of things out of Doug fir, the last project being 5 shoji screen style doors. What I use is vertical grain and it isn't inexpensive running around 6 to $7 a bdft on the west coast. It is nice to work with and on the vg stuff the grain is tight enough that sanding is not to bad using a random orbital sander.
I find it to be a really gorgeous wood and has a really nice tone and texture to it.
You're right it is much harder than pine, I feel like every time I work with pine i just look at it wrong and it dents.
Rough sawn tends to be a little thinner than rough sawn hardwoods and it does come in set widths like most softwoods.
Tom
Re: Douglas fir
Joseph Mulherin
Tom, I looked at the poplar too, and it is very expensive here and cost are per foot... that is the reason I am looking at the DF. I have made furniture using Honduran mahogany, birch plywood, red oak, walnut, and redwood. The uses I put DF to were to build my bench legs, etc.not any furniture, but it was intriguing to ask if anyone else here would approve on such a use for furniture. Will give DF a try with at least one chair.... and am making about 6 all together this year for family and friends.
Re: I'm with Paul on this one
Charlie Lenz
I haven't used alot of different types of woods, but I've noticed thar for not much more then what Select pine costs, I can buy Red Oak. But maybe the cost is not a concern to you and you want to just try something different. I have an old home that was built in 1917, and the upper floor is all Fir flooring, someday, hopefully soon I'd like to refinish the floor, it needs it badly, probably has the original finish still on it. But anyway I have a friend that refinished a Fir floor in his home last year and it looks nice. He didn't stain it, just applied 3 or 4 coats of Poly over it.
One more question...
John in NM
Are you limiting your options to those available at places like Home Depot?
Our local big hardwood yard sells red oak amazingly cheap compared to the s4s available at the home centers. I could see using framing lumber since for chair legs you can work around the knots, but if you're pursuing that option because HD is charging crazy prices for poplar and oak, you may want to look around a little for a better source of RWL hardwood.
Most cities big enough to have a couple custom cabinet shops will have somewhere to buy hardwood cheaper than HD.
Seat blanks for chairs
JL
Of the softwoods, I've used eastern white pine and cypress - I haven't used Douglas fir. I usually use poplar - unless I'm using another hardwood.
If you can find a decent, tight grained, near quarter sawn piece of Douglas fir, then go for it - you can drill, carve and rough sand a seat blank. If you don't like it, you don't have to use it.
The thing to remember is that you are making a heirloom piece of furniture. Do you want to compromise? My seat blanks are typically 22" x 24" x 2 1/4" - 8.25 board feet. The cost of the blank is minimal compared to the labor.
Re: One more question...
Joseph Mulherin
John, we do not have any more stores for hardwood here in Indio,
Ca.... have to travel many miles to find one and the costs are over the hill.
All we have...to my knowledge...is HD and Lowes.
Re: Seat blanks for chairs
Joseph Mulherin
JL, where do you buy your seats?
Re: Seat blanks for chairs
JL
Buy?? I make my seat blanks. There are places up in New England that sell Eastern white pine at not too exorbitant prices ($5/bd ft. + shipping). Ditto for butternut (also a place in WI). My poplar I get locally or I saw it myself. Cypress I get from South Carolina. There is a place down near the coast that sells decent size planks. The hardwoods come from wherever I can get it. There are a lot of sawmills, kilns and lumber operations in the Western NC region.
Try Woodfinder for places near you.
Re: Seat blanks for chairs
Joseph Mulherin
OK, JL, I looked up wood suppliers in my area of So. Calif. and found one about 50 miles away. Shall go over and see what they have and prices too. Around here they are mostly setup for nothing but housing and repairs of same.
Re: I think that would work...
Joseph Mulherin
John, all of the joints in my chairs will be glued and splined...no nails or screws. And all pieces will be worked using my Shopsmith equipment. Have had that machine since 1978 and upgraded to the 510 model several yrs ago. Have made some poker tables on it to which I gave away to friends and tried to give them to the local Senior Center but they declined them at the time. When I make something I always make patterns so I can duplicate the items later. This last Xmas I made some lap bedtrays; and a few yrs ago I made 19 mantle clocks(electronic clock movements) and gave them to family and friends.
This year it will be Windsor chairs...am thinking about 6...maybe more later after the first 6 are done.
Am still thinking I will use the DF lumber, stain it and then poly with a couple coats.
Re: Seat blanks for chairs
Joseph Mulherin
OK, I have decided to use my bench top to make the seats. The top is 6 2x6s x 5ft long which should give me much lumber to use for my chairs. Sanded smooth, glued joints(no nails or screws), turned spindles on lathe, 1/2" x 2 3/4"splats made and bandsawed, headboard cut and drilled for splats insertion, then steamed to make the curvature needed,. Seat will be 1 1/2" x 23" square with 3/4" boards laid 90 deg across the upper bottom, then bandsawn to shape, legs holes in bottom drilled out at 17 deg forward and backward x 6 deg outward slant for stability. Seat edging will be mostly done with the bandsaw, then smoothed out using the ROS. Seat sculping will be done using my Fortsner drill bits to various depths around the seat surface and then angle grind out the remaining material, then smooth sanded.
Am using my Shopsmith equipment for all operations to make the various items. Have planer also but no jointer.
Re: Douglas fir
Joseph Mulherin
Bill, most all of the lumber here at my local Home Depot and at Lowes IS green wet pieces...having just been delivered from the suppliers. That is the reason I decided to use my older benchtop to make some of the chairs...just because it has been in my shop here in the desert near Palm Springs for about three years and is as dry as the humidity allows....in low teens mostly.
I'm a little late to the party *LINK*
Bruce, a MN Galoot
I couldn't find this book at first, but here it is. Karg highlights the work of a bunch of European craftsmen who work in solid wood, much of which is fir.
Solid-Wood Cabinet Construction
Re: Douglas fir
Alex Grigoriev
Lowes and HD have kiln-dried 2x4 DF and HF. It may not be available in every store.