Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Would you return the Saw Blade?

Posts

Would you return the Saw Blade?

#1

Would you return the Saw Blade?

Barry Irby

I wanted a rip blade for a TS that provided a flat bottomed cut so I could use it to cut slots for splines (Feathers/keys/whatever you call them). I have a WWII I like a lot but it does not cut flat bottomed slots. Went to Wood Craft and looked at the blades. They had a WWII that was ground to make it cut flat, but it was $129. They had a Freud blade that had alternating flat and teeth that had the corners angled and it was $69. The Clerk insisted it was very nearly as good as the WWII and it was less than half price.

Bought it and put it on the saw and used it for a few minutes before I realized the teeth with the angle corners were "taller" than the square cut teeth and let a groove little "fillets" in the corners. The main reason I wanted the blade was for the flat bottomed grooves.

Would you take it back? It has less than 30 minutes n it but I still used it a little. Or would you send it out and have the taller teeth ground square to match the others?

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

#2

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Barry,

You should return the blade as it did not meet your reasonable expectations. I would have thought the blade would perform a flat cut with its rakers. Indeed, I nearly bought one within the past couple weeks to do just that. I decided to get by with a blade from my dado set, and that worked fine.

George

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

#3

I would definitely go talk to the store about it

John in NM

But I'm not sure I would insist they eat the loss on the mistake, pretty hard for Woodcraft stores to get by right now. Maybe I would, that blade is for laminate work (called a triple chip), and not really useful for much else. Might make a good smooth crosscut blade, but I've never tried it.

That clerk ought to know better.

As for blades you could look for some of Freud's ripping blades, they tend to be cut flat.

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

#4

You got the wrong Freud blade....

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

Get yourself a Freud LM72R010 dedicated rip blade. This is a really nice rip blade that gives glue line results. The added bonus is that it gives truly flat bottom cuts, great for splines. I had no idea how much better this blade would rip in solid wood than a Forrest WWII. The Forrest requires alot more effort and has a tendency to burn. The Freud cuts effortlessly and is burn free. About $50. Best rip blade investment you can make.

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

#5

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

Howard Acheson

You bought the wrong blade. The Freud blade you want is their full kerf 24 tooth FT tooth rip blade.

I'm not sure what blade you got but the store may not have understood what you really wanted the blade to do.

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

#6

I know the dilemma

Dave Paine

Barry, I would send this to either Forest or Ridge Carbide to be sharpened to be a truly flat cut. The clerk likely was not as familiar with the details of the blade as you expected.

I also own a WWII and love it except for not being a flat bottom cut when I want to cut grooves and do not want to spend the time to switch to my dado set.

I recently wanted to cut a 1/4in dado so I did make the switch. The dado set was claimed to be minimum of 1/4in by using the outside cutters. I mounted on the saw, made the cut and then found it was too wide for my previously cut insert of exactly 1/4in. The bottom was flat as desired, but too much slop.

Only then did I measure the dimension of the dado outside blades were about 1/128th too wide. When combined this meant 1/64th too wide. It would have shown in the particular project. I then had to cut another strip of wood.

So lesson learned for me is to test. In my case the manufacturer was stating minimum of 1/4in, so for me this infers a manufacturing defect. I am debating on whether to contact the manufacturer. The dado set is perhaps 2 years old, although rarely used. Clearly I could not add carbide to the width of the teeth by using.

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

#7

Re: You got the wrong Freud blade....

David Yoho

Obviously the WWII (40 tooth) is a combination blade and not a dedicated rip blade. Although it works alright, it's not fair to compare it to any blade specifically designed for ripping. When I do a lot of ripping, especially in thick stock, I take off my WWII 40-tooth blade and put on a WWII 30-tooth that handles the job much better.

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

#8

I think you should keep it.

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

It sounds like you purchased an LU82M blade which is an excellent crosscutting blade that will also do a good job ripping. If you look closely at the package they show the tooth profile and clearly show the raker teeth as being .5 mm higher than the angled teeth .

I have this blade and use it all the time. Try a couple of cross cuts and you'll love it.

Lee

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

#9

The blade I have ....

Barry Irby

is a LM74R010 freud INDUSTRIAL Glue Line Rip full kerf, TCG, 30 tooth with 12 degree hook. On the blade one picture shows a square top tooth and indicates its and 1/8" wide and another picture shows a square tooth and a tooth with the corners nipped off at a 45. Those two teeth are picture as being EXACTLY the same height. Nowhere on the blade or packaging is there a picture like the one above showing the height difference.

I was very clear with the clerk that the flat bottom cut was my first priority and the ripping characteristics were secondary. I actually picked up the Forrest blade and carried it around but did not want a second one at $129 since my main goal was to cut notches for splines.

I will talk to the guy that owns the store and if he is reluctant to take the blade back I will keep it and consider having Forrest sharpen it to cut flat bottomed grooves.

On a side note, I sent my WWII back for sharpening because I cut a nail in half lengthwise. I was amazed, it only had very minor chips on three teeth. Forrest returned it in like new condition and it is amazing how well it cuts. It is stunning compared to the piece of crap blade I was using to tide me over and it offers less kick back than either the crap one or they freud one I am considering returning.

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Re: That sounds like a reasonable idea....

Jesper, Denmark

But, may I ask? are you not obsessing unnecessarily over having square bottoms for the spline grooves?

They are not going to show, and will not degrade the glue bond, so ????

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

#11

Re: You got the wrong Freud blade....

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

The Woodworker II Option 1 blade is a special grind that is both a combination blade and it cuts a perfectly flat groove or kerf bottom. I have one and really like it. It also makes a great precision ripping blade, even better than the standard WWII.

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

#12

They are not going to show....

David Yoho

I disagree. They do show. When I've used my WWII to cut a groove for the intended purpose Barry wants, not only is the bottom not flat but the tooth angle cuts into the bottom edges of the groove leaving a small gap that shows after inserting a square cornered spline.

This doesn't matter when cutting a spline that will be on the interior for reinforcement and not seen but when it's for a "feather" application where the end or ends will be seen on the outside of the work it is noticeable.

In the past when I've needed to cut a groove for this purpose, I've used one of the interior blades from my Forrest dado set to get a true flat bottom cut. It works and removes the need to buy yet another blade.

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

#13

Re: They are not going to show.... *LINK*

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Freud does show the tooth profile for this blade at their web site as .

The blade he probably wants is the LM72 or LU87 series which has a tooth profile like this:

You can see all the Freud blades and their tooth configurations at the link below.

For the blade he has a simple chamfer on the corners of his splines will allow a better, although not a perfect fit.


Frued blades

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

#14

Didn't get what you wanted take it back

del schisler

Why should you pay to fix the blade. You didn't get what you wanted. Or it was sold for what it was not. Not your fault. I guess if they don't know their product's than that is not your fault. If they are in trouble business wise that may be one reason besides poor economy , my 3 cent's inflation

Re: Would you return the Saw Blade?

#15

Re: They are not going to show....

Barry Irby

I should have shopped before I went shopping. I think that it a shame to have to do product research before you go to the vendor. And It would have been good to put this piece of information on the blade or at least the package. I am just being grumpy. I feel slightly duped. I walked into a reputable place explained what I wanted, paid the money and got something else. The problem is I have very little use for this blade but I feel bad about taking it back and still don'to have a blade that cuts flat bottom grooves.