We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I have made some walnut boxes that have a pieces of crotch grain veneer for he top. There is some blond wood in the crotch. I was considered evening it out by staining for dying it. I bought some of Charles Niel's Blotch Control product and have coated a test sample of the same veneer.Now I am stymied. What do I use as a stain or dye for the next step? I have some powered die that came in a Mohawk furniture repair kit I have had for forty years. I have use some f it to color epoxy and this stuff is really potent. What appears to be a few rains of it will color a small batch of epoxy. I assume it is aniline dye. Could I just mix some of that in some alcohol(?) and sue it to color the tops. The tops are only 8" by 13" so I don't need much. Or how about Minwax? Any suggestions?
Berry i use the charles neil blotch control. What is so good about it is on the end grain and crotch wood it will stay that way and not go dark . i belive i would use minwax that is the stain i use. I use M.L.CAMPBEL lacquer also the sanding sealer and than i use simi gloss. for the finish. you can stain and wipe off tell you get the sap wood the color you want. Than stain the whole thing with another coat this should stain and match ? You may have do a trial run to get it right.
Oh man, Minwax stain on crotch figure walnut? Gotta be a law around somewhere preventing that! Sorry, but to me that will just muddy up the wood. I think that Mother Nature did a real fine job with walnut already. Others will suggest a way to help you color it, I just can't imagine doing that myself. To each his own, have at it!
Barry, you can use most any dye or stain you want as the next step after the CN Blotch Control is dry. The question is, and you seem to infer your preference in your posting, whether or not you want to color part or all of that crotch figure. Personally, I'd leave it alone and let it age naturally, but that's me.
I would definitely use a dye and not a stain (Minwax or other) because it will go into the wood, not lay on top and rely on pigment for color. Even those stains containing a combination of dye and pigment will not be as good as plain old dye.
For water based, I like W.D. Lockwood. For solvent based I like Transtint. You could always make a run over to the west end and pick up a bottle of Transtint that comes the closest to the color you need. Mix it with some DNA and you're ready to go. One tip I'd pass on in this situation is to "sneak up" on the color instead of trying for it in one swipe. That is to say - apply a coat and see how it looks. If you want more, repeat until you are satisfied. Also, don't mix your dye as dark to start off. Usually this approach will get the color just right.
I find the sapwood or blond color on the left end to be distracting and also don't like the small spot at the upper right. Just thought it might be an improvement to die them and even them out with the rest.
The problem you could run into using dye is in trying to color the sapwood areas to the shade you want without affecting the surrounding heartwood as much and leaving a "witness line" of sorts from the dye.
This Blotch Control will help greatly with keeping the color uniform. I would think you would want to wipe the entire surface first, followed by additional wipes in the lighter areas while the surface is still wet. The more times you go over the surface with a dye, the more it will darken (up to a point). Achieving a uniform color will take patience.
Let us forget the exact piece at hand for a bit. Suppose we had a table top and there was some sapwood in one corner. With an air brush or fine brush we would apply sap stain to make this area similar in color to the rest of the top.
You are right. What you have is distracting. So the task is to make it less distracting.
I don't see that the task at hand is any different than dealing with sapwood in a table top. Why "blotch control" got involved is puzzling to me. I would be getting some dye stain (or walnut sap stain formulated for this task), a brush or air brush, and applying stain to the sapwood until the shade resembled the rest. Then proceed to finishing the piece however you intend to.
Re: looks to me like a straightforward sap stain t
Barry Irby
I have no experience staining sap wood. I usually eliminate it during stock prep or leave it in and celebrate it. Depending on the piece, I either like it or not. This piece of crotch wood add this in it and it is too small to cut it out and have anything useful so I want to stain it. The Blotch control stuff came in because Charles Neil recommended it for this application. I have practiced on a piece that was damaged and I have relatively good success.
This sample was not sanded well and I forgot to sand the raised grain off. It has a single coat of semigloss lacquer. This looks acceptable to me.
You might also consider this alternative. Use a glaze to add some color to the lighter wood after you have applied a coat or two of your finish...I'll assume a varnish or poly. The advantage here is that you can apply the glaze gradually to build up the color, and if you don't like the effect you can wipe it off and adjust your glaze and try again. Once you are happy with the color, let it cure, and then add a couple more coats of your topcoat. I am not an expert finisher, but I have had luck with this approach. I've made glazes by mixing artist's colors in a mix of varnish, a bit linseed oil and the artist's colors. Maybe a Burnt Umber or a Van Dyke brown will work with the walnut. Some experimenting may be in order here. Perhaps someone else(one of the pros here) might chip in somme comments on the good/bad of this approach.