OT Plumbing question
Ellis Walentine
...Well, not really plumbing. I'm setting my stainless steel sink into a wooden countertop and I'm debating whether to bed it in plumber's putty or silicone -- or something else? Any help?
Ellis
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
OT Plumbing question
Ellis Walentine
...Well, not really plumbing. I'm setting my stainless steel sink into a wooden countertop and I'm debating whether to bed it in plumber's putty or silicone -- or something else? Any help?
Ellis
Re: OT Plumbing question
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
Silicone. Plumber's putty will leach oil into the wood over time. Same reason you don't use putty to bed fixtures into stone counters.
The sink's going in . . . . PAR-R-R-R-TY!!
Re: OT Plumbing question
Howard Norman
Ellis I would agree with Mark, use silicone. I prefer silicone from Dow Corning followed by silicone from General Electric myself. I don't trust some of the off brand silicone companies. I worked for many years with Dow Corning and trust their formulations.
Sounds like the kitchen remodel is getting close to being done.
Howard
Re: OT Plumbing question
Pat Riley
I did the same thing 6 years ago and used silicone.
It has worked great with no problems whatsoever.
I agree.
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
My father worked his whole career for Dow Corning. 
(Being a painter, though, we have had some disagreements on the suitability of silicone caulk for some applications!)
Jason
Re: I agree.
Howard Norman
My main contacts at Dow Corning were at the Hemlock plant which manufacturers Silicon, the starting material for electronic devices such as Integrated Circuits. However I did have contacts with other parts of the corporation over the years. A good friend of mine ran the medical facility for a few years.
Re: OT Plumbing question
Barry Irby
They are correct, use silicon. Plumbers putty is basically clay and oil. The wood will soak the oil out of it, discoloring the wood and drying out the putty to the point the seal will fail.
Re: I agree.
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
Dad was there starting in '92, and then moved back to the Midland HQ in the late '90s sometime to finish out his career as VP of Corp Enviro Affairs. He had also worked at the Carrollton, KY plant, Silinor, SA (in Brazil), and he oversaw construction of the plant in Taiwan in the early '80s. Now my brother works at one of the Midland buildings as a lab tech.
Jason
Re: OT Plumbing question
steve mackay
I'm not a pro but I've installed sinks and replaced faucets in every relative's house. I always use plumber's putty. Don't know why though. Its just how Dad did it. The troubling part is that no one has ever had a leak, seep or problem. I will say that every one I've REMOVED that had "silicone" on it was a majoir pain to work. One other point of order : The SOBs changed the size of the hole for that darn sprayer in the last ten years. It got bigger. Had to grind out the hole by about a quarter inch. I think they do it for laughs & giggles.
Re: OT Plumbing question
Barry Irby
Steve, if you install the drains Ina cultured marble sink or a stone sink you should NOT use plumbers putty. The instructions with the sink explicitly say not to. And I know why. The oil bleeds out into he surround material and come to the surface. In the case of the marble sink it ruins the finish around the drain. I know this because the plumber that installed mine used it and they are all damaged.
Re: OT Plumbing question
Bill Howatt
I can see that being a problem but I also have seen references that said using silicone will turn sink removal into a nightmare.
My last sink had a gasket around the countertop rim already affixed and no instructions to use anything else with it.
Bill
Re: OT Plumbing question
Barry Irby
I think you are correct, the last ones I bought had a gasket with them also. It was almost more than I could stand not to put some gooey in there anyway.
The problem might come when you try to reuse and old school drain set that does not have a gasket.
Re: OT Plumbing question
Don Evans
I'm curious Ellis, what does the instructions for the installation call for, one's that came with the sink?
As far as silicone being a pain to remove, I don't think I'd worry about that, this is and should be considered a permanent instalation.
Worry about removal if that day ever comes and go with silicone unless instructions say otherwise.
Had plumber install (cannot remember what it is called) but it is spout that goes in sink hole with the stopper in the middle of it. He used putty there which I've always done also but mould keeps showing up just around it and I've never seen that happen before. Clean it and it's right back week later. Think I will try tightening it more so it will squeeze out more and maybe that will stop it from happening. In past I would have done it, but neck trouble makes working under there next to impossible. I've never used any brand but Oatey, don't know what he used. FYI, this is a regular bathroom porcelain sink.
Don