A lesson in buying lumber
Bill Tindall
I advocate buying lumber in "large" quantities when funds and storage permit. The following discussion illustrates one reason why......
I needed to make 14 stair treads to be made by gluing up 5/4 poplar panels from clear cuttings. There is about 60 bdft in the finished treads. I had a large stock of 5/4 #1 common poplar to choose from. #1 Common poplar is graded to yield between 66 to 83% clear cuttings and it costs about 2/3 the price of FAS which yields greater than 83% clear cuttings. However, with a large amount to choose from for a specific project, the yield from #1 common can be much greater than the specification range of 66 to 83%. The feat is accomplished by choosing pieces to cut from where the the desired cutting comes closer to the defects than is the case with the theoretical cutting used to determine grade.
To illustrate, suppose we have two #1 common boards. In one board there are knots 42" apart and in the other board the knots are 51" apart. If our cuttings for the tread are 40" long there is almost no waste from the first board and 11" of waste from the second board. For this project we choose to cut from the first board and reserve the second for some future project. The important point is that by selecting boards for efficient cuttings among the defects we are not "high grading" the lumber. What is rejected will be of equal value for future projects were the cutting length is different from 40", a case most likely.

The picture shows the waste (excluding the tiny waste from end trimming the panels) from making 14 treads. I estimate it to be less than 10% of the lumber cut up to make the panels(treads). Keep in mind this is the waste from #1 common grade.
I buy 500 bdft packs of #2 common poplar for internal framing and drawers. By careful selection I get little more waste from this grade than FAS and the price is less than half of the FAS grade (30 cent a ft if I dry it myself).



