Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

new shop walls

Posts

new shop walls

#1

new shop walls

Paul Blackwell

We sold our house and I had to give up my 24 x 40 pole barn shop and downsize to a basement shop in the new house. I'm about ready to start building stud walls to partition off the shop area from the rest of the basement. The basement is absolutely dry, and a good dehumidifier keeps the humidity at about 50%. I think I read somewhere that any wood in contact with cement must be treated lumber. I'd be comfortable putting untreated lumber in contact with the floor, but does code require treated? I'm in New York State, and probably code varies from state to state. What's your thought, treated or untreated for the pieces in contact with the floor?

Re: new shop walls

#2

Re: new shop walls

Howard Norman

If the wood is going to be in direct contact with the concrete floor than I would say to use treated wood. However when my house was built the builder used metal standoff brackets that do not allow the wood to come in direct contact with the concrete for the pillars in the basement. They have been there for 15+ years with no problems.

howard

Re: new shop walls

#3

Re: new shop walls

Yonak

The answer to your code question, and maybe friendly advice, will be easily answered by your building inspector. In my county we can get quick answers with a phone call. Only rarely will they have to call back.

Re: new shop walls

#4

Re: new shop walls

Allen Bryant - Bumpass, VA

concrete by nature has some water in it, even if you can't see it. Untreated lumber will in time wick this moisture out of the concrete. Even if it's not code it's still a good thing to do to prevent the wood from rotting or as previously suggested put something between the wood and the floor.

Re: new shop walls

#5

Re: new shop walls

Bill White

Remember to use the new nails/screws that comply with the treated stuff available today.

Bill

Re: new shop walls

#6

Here's my view on code compliance...

RobCarr

Here's my view on code compliance...

If you were to hire someone to do the work, or if you were doing the work for someone else, then I would expect full compliance with the local codes.

But...

It's your home, you're the one that has to live in it, then you can do as you wish, regardless of any code book.

Maybe it's my hillbilly upbringing, but that's the way I approach it.

Re: new shop walls

#7

IBC Code

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

I looked and there is nothing in the IBC code that states pressure treated lumber MUST be used in this application. HOWEVER....many local townships or municipalities WILL require pressure treated lumber to be used.

If it were my home, and based on the fact that you have two disimilar materials touching one another, I would use PT. That and the wicking factor. I would also provide spacers or standoffs of PT to attach the wall to the masonry block. If this applies. My 2 cents worth.

Ray

(Licensed NJ Bldg. Inspector)

Re: new shop walls

#8

Good advice Yonak.

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

If in doubt, ask. In most cases, the officials are willing to help or point you in the direction you need.

Re: new shop walls

#9

Re: Here's my view on code compliance...

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

I'd have to partially agree with you Rob. Sometimes things are over regulated, BUT sometimes the building codes are there for a reason. I was a doubter too until I became an inspector. I can't argue with your logic.

Re: new shop walls

#10

Re: IBC Code

Barry Irby

I just looked at the IRC (International Residential Code) and In the section one Protection Against Decay It requires pressure treated wood for "Sills and sleepers on a concrete or masonry slab that is in direct contact with the ground unless separated from such slab by and impervious moisture vapor barrier."

Locally, I have never seen anyone get by with the Impervious Barrier because the local inspectors interpret the nails or bolts through the sill to anchor it as penetrations in the barrier and it is no longer impervious. The treated wood also resists termites. Treated wood is significantly more expensive than regular wood. Why not use it?

Also, it is my understanding that you can do your own work even if you are not licensed, but you must still meet the Code. Again, that's the local interpretation.m (Virginia)

Re: new shop walls

#11

Re: Here's my view on code compliance...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

It sounds good in theory, but what happens if you want to sell it and the prospective buyer asks whether it was built to code? And what happens if your insurance agent wants to know that, too?

I'll give you a for-instance:

We had our house built new (couldn't find an existing home to our specs). One of my requirements for the garage was that I wanted a dedicated 30 amp circuit. The electrician gave me that circuit, on its own breaker, #10 wire, and no other outlets or appliances on that circuit.

A few years ago our state electrical inspector came over to check out something else and he asked about that breaker. I told him the situation, and he honestly didn't believe it was a dedicated circuit, even though he was close friends with the electrician who installed it and trusted the guy. So, if I go to sell the house, say in about 3 years when I retire, how am I supposed to describe the garage, since I maintain that it was built to code and the certified electrical inspector has his doubts?

Re: new shop walls

#12

Re: new shop walls

Guillaume Dery

Up here (Ottawa, On, Canada) we just put a foam gasket under the sill 2X4 which acts as a vapour barrier. Our code requires a vapour barrier between the wood and concrete. Polyethylene is considered acceptable but the purpose made foam gasket is much nicer to work with and will only set you back about $10 to do an entire basement. It is cheaper than going the pressure-treated route and probably more effective.

As an aside, concrete is not friendly to your back or to dropped tools. As I have to finish the entire basement in order to get my new shop (as per SWMBO), I am laying down 1" foam board (joints taped) covered by 3/4" OSB.

If you have the headroom, I highly recommend this approach. It keeps your floors 100% dry and also warmer and the little bit of give is much nicer for your back. Then you frame on top of the sub-floor. However that is mucho more dinero

Cheers,

Guillaume

Re: new shop walls

#13

Treated

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The test for moisture on a basement slab is to tape some visqueen (polyethylene sheet) over a patch of floor and leave it for a couple of days. If there's moisture on the underside of the sheet, you've got moisture migrating up through the slab.

Why NOT use treated? Is it all that much more expensive where you are than untreated? It'd be a shame to do all the work involved and then find out that you've got moisture issues that rot out your bottom plate and require tearing out the wall.

After years of trying to save money here and there, I've concluded that a small investment in sensible stuff up front saves money and time in the long run.

Re: new shop walls

#14

Simple...

John in NM

You know it is a dedicated circuit, this inspector you mention merely has an unreasonable doubt concerning the truth of it. It is also demonstrable that it is a dedicated circuit. The "official" inspectors sometimes frankly amaze me :D

I've yet to see much fuss made over old permits and inspections, when it comes to selling a house. More typically, the home inspector hired by the buyer will look at any obvious newer work and note whether it looks to have been competently done or not. Shoddy work may have to be upgraded as a condition of sale or cause the buyer to re-think the offering price, but that's about the extent of it.

Re: new shop walls

#15

Some reasons to avoid treated lumber...

John in NM

Around here, it is wet, nasty stuff that generally won't stay straight even if you park a truck on it. A pain to work with.

Since they moved away from the arsenic treatments, I've had some doubts that it's even effective. More so than untreated, but no guarantee that the work won't need repair in a few years. I worked with a guy from Washington state who insisted on putting 30# felt under treated wood, cheap insurance.

That whole thing about finding the right fasteners... hot galvanized vs stainless... ugh... :D (you see I always have to justify finding the right one - far from town - while my wife wants to just use whatever is at hand and thinks I'm being overly fussy :D )

In many cases I avoid the stuff if reasonably possible. But it's so dry here we can get away with that. In cases where a repair is not difficult, say posts for a shade ramada, I definitely wouldn't bother with treated lumber... but I probably would use it in the OP's case - wrapped in 30# felt of course :D

Re: new shop walls

#16

Price????????

Keith Newton

Barry, I don't find much difference in price in my area.

I cut some pine a while back, which I had treated for 100$ per thousand. Which I thought was cheaper than I could dry it for. I guess it could vary with local,,,, but treating doesn't require drying, so there is a trade off.

Re: new shop walls

#17

Wet, nasty stuff

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I built an addition on our house, 12 X 16'. Actually, it was built on top of our deck, but the posts and footings for the deck were built with the intention of parking a sun room on top eventually.

Well, both my grandfather and father subscribed to the notion that when something is worth building, it's worth overbuilding. So I added four extra piers and 6 X 6's with double 2X12's supporting the 2 X 10 joists in the middle. I used green treated 2X12's for the cross-beams, and those suckers have now shrunk close to 3/4". The only thing that was supporting them after they shrunk (before I noticed) was the 1/2" bolts holding everything together. That shrinkage caused cracks in the interior walls. I stuck a bottle jack under each end, cranked it up and filled the space with white oak shims. They're solid now.

I don't know about the other stuff, but that green-treated stuff is realllllllly wet.

Re: new shop walls

#18

Oops, My bad.....

Barry Irby

Should proofread better. Meant to say it is INsignificanlty more expensive, not significantly more expensive. I have not looked lately, but there is so little difference locally that cost is not a factor. You do need to use the fasteners rated for treated lumber, but that's a good idea anyway, ordinary fasteners tend to rust when used in concrete or masonry.

(I just realized what may have happened. Spell Checker changes insignificantly to significantly every time.)

Re: new shop walls

#19

Re: Wet, nasty stuff

Barry Irby

You are correct about it being wet and swollen, and heavy and it does tend to warp. But it is available in versions that have been dried after treatment. KDAT is Kiln Dried After Treatment and ADAT is Air Dried After Treatment. This stuff costs about a dollar a piece more than the wet stuff and is much better. It has already warped so you can avoid those pieces and it is much lighter and is already shrunken back to it dry size so you can avoid the shrinkage issues. Its a joy to work with compared to the wet stuff.

Re: new shop walls

#20

Re: IBC Code vs IRC Code

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Barry,

You are correct and I didn't have time here at work after posting my comment to make that statement from the IRC. Very good point as most local municipalities will follow the IRC.

Agree...nails, anchors, etc. pretty much negate the vapor barrier code portion of that section but if I were inspecting a project like that, I wouldn't call a foul. Sometimes "the code" isn't worth the paper it's written on. :D

Ray

Re: new shop walls

#21

Re: new shop walls

Rick in Colgate, Wi

FWIW

My basement is dry and humidity levels run around 50%. The partition walls for my shop were built in 1995 using untreated SPF. The stud walls are open on one side and look as good today as the day they were put up including those in contact with the concrete.

Re: new shop walls

#22

Good to remember that...

John in NM

I always seem to forget the KDAT stuff, our local borgs seem to have the cheaper variety (there's a shocker, no? :D )

Re: new shop walls

#23

Re: new shop walls

Barry Irby

If the slab really is dry and you don't have a local termite problem the untreated wood will probably last as long as the rest of the building. You can plot termite activity up the east coast. Its terrible in Florida and very slight in Maine, but, its not a straight line on the chart. Where I live, ((Richmond VA) we have a significant problem. May be the rivers or the soil or something, but we are much worse off than would seem logical.

Why take the chance? Treated wood is cheap and readily available and it meets the Code and not THAT difficult to work with.

Re: new shop walls

#24

Re: IBC Code vs IRC Code

Barry Irby

Ray, it was my understanding that the IRC is a compilation of the three earlier major codes, BOCA, IBC, and the Southern one and that the three Code organizations got together a few years back and melded them into the IRC. And, The Local Building official Lead us to believe the entire country was using the IRC now. I actually have no idea if that is really accurate, I have not checked with any of the other 49 states. And I think an International Code is somewhat ridiculous. Conditions in Florida are so extremely different that Maine or Alaska, we don't need a nationwide code, we need regional ones. Ad old habits die hard. Local guys are still enforcing the code they grew up on whether its still in effect or not.

Also, local builders insist that all basements are damp dungeon like places and resist building them. When they do, they cut every corner they can and skimp on waterproofing and drainage and then say "See there, I told you basements were wet." And the myth is perpetuated.