Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

metal working mill bits in a router

Posts

metal working mill bits in a router

#1

metal working mill bits in a router

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I recently had the need to rout a 2" deep cavity in a chunk of walnut end grain. The bit I used was a solid carbide 1/2" upcut carbide bit with two flutes, but it does not have a flat end. It worked splendidly. I mostly use this bit for cutting mortises, for which it is unsurpassed. However, the cut at the bottom of this cavity was moderately rough and it took a lot of work to smooth that surface to my satisfaction.

Well, the other day I was in my local machine tool supply place and they had 1/2" four-flute cutters, solid carbide, spiral upcut. And these bits were flat on the end, which looked like it would give the kind of shearing cut I need to produce a good finish on the bottom of that cavity. I was thinking of doing the majority of the cutting with the other cutter and using this flat-end, four-flute bit only for the last 1/16" or so.

My question, which the store manager couldn't answer, is whether I can use that bit in my router, even though it was developed for a mill operating at relatively low speeds. Bear in mind that I only have one router (poor me), a wonderful 1/2" Makita that I dearly love, but it operates at about 22,000 rpm all the time.

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#2

Get Ready

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

for smoke. With 4 flutes engaged in wood, you'll have plenty of friction and the bit will tend to clog with shavings. Remember that mills are designed to be side cutters run with lubricants, whereas wood bits are designed to cut vertically as well as laterally. What, if anything, the increased heat will do to the carbide, I can't tell, but I would be somewhat concerned about it.

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#3

Try Misenheimer

Bill Tindall

Call Misenheimer in Morristown TN and ask the question. 423 587 4300 Also, this company makes carbide router bits for the wood industry. They either have or can make the bit of your dreams to cut a flat bottom hole.

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

Dale Lenz

My Dad a machinist by trade gave me two 1/4" sprial end mill cutter back in about 1981, they were some of the sweetest cutting bits I've ever owned. I too was concerned about the router speed, but nothing ever happen expect for smooth cuts.

Your milage may vary

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#5

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

I use them all the time. I have 1/8", 1/4", 3/8", and 1/2" carbide end mills that I use in my routers, and they do a great job.

End mills come in both two and four flute. I prefer the two-flute versions for wood, though.

I generally get mine from Enco. The work quite well, and they're considerably cheaper than most brands of router bits.

If you're shopping the Enco catalog for them, pay attention to the overall length of the bit. Some mills are very short. "Extra Length" mills are readily available, and aren't much more expensive than 'standard.'

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#6

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

Butch...Mn

There are two types of end mills for metal...centercutting and normal. Centercutting end mills allows one to make a plunge cut in metal. Maybe in a soft material such as wood, the regular bit would be fine anyhow. I have to admit that I have never used endmills on wood, but on the other hand, wood bits seem to work well on aluminum. Regular endmills do not work well on aluminum...you need to use a end mill with a different helix angle.

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#7

Re: Get Ready

PaulSV

Chip clearing shouldn't be a problem if you are only cutting the last 1/16 inch. Try to get a center cutting end mill, as mentioned above. Metal cutting end mills have less clearance angle than wood cutting router bits, which could lead to burning but, again, if you are only cutting the last 1/16 inch, it shouldn't be a problem.

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#8

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

Jesse Cloud

I use end mills for mortising a lot. One thing to be aware of, though, if you aren't familiar with end mills, is that the shaft and the cutter are always the same diameter,e.g. a 3/8 inch mill is 3/8 from start to end. The mill sizes you can use are limited by the routers you have.

As stated above, it should work fine. I usually slow my router down, but sometimes I forget and it works just fine...

Having said that, it sounds like you are passing up a great opportunity to justify another router. :D

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#9

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

John in NM

Should work ok, and you can get 2 flute end mills as well. But as far as I know they cost the same or more than your average spiral router bit, the only advantage being that HSS and Cobalt mills are more readily available than router bits of those materials (and those are cheaper than carbide). There is also the problem that Jesse mentioned, end mill cutting size tends to be the same as the shank size. Milling machines use a collet system with lots of available sizes, so if you use end mills, you'll be stuck with either 1/4 or 1/2 diameter cutters.

Why not have your router bit sharpened square next time? Any shop that does end mills should be able to handle that.

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#10

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Well, one of the real attractions of this end mill bit is that it's solid carbide, fine grade, and $9. The two flute solid carbide upcut spiral bit I have is $55. At $9 it's a throw-away (although I hate that idea). My router is fixed speed.

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#11

Re: Try Misenheimer

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Thanks for the reference, Bill. I'll give them a call.

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#12

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'm pretty sure that what I have is not an end mill. It's meant for a plunge cut, 3" long, two flute, spiral cut. It produces a spectacular, fine shearing cut, but the end cut does not, nor was meant to, produce a finely finished surface.

You probably have a Fastenal near you. I was absolutely amazed at the number of bits they had that I'd just never seen before. And CHEAP! Especially since they were solid carbide. I felt like I was missing the boat somehow.

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#13

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Oh I agree I need at least two more routers. One will be one of those Porter Cable models that fit really well into a router table, and the other will be a trim router of some sort. Mine is the Makita 3612 BR, 1/2" shank, with collets for 3/8" and 1/4". I use the 1/4" but never the 3/8".

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#14

Re: Get Ready

Bruce, a MN Galoot

That's exactly what I have in mind. Thanks.

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#15

Thanks to everyone for your thoughtful resposes

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Sorry to be so slow in responding. I'm just getting off a week of night shift, and consciousness returns slowly. You've all answered my questions.

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#16

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I recall a whole bunch of years ago running into some high speed steel Onsrud bits that were labeled for machining, but were identical to the woodworking variety, at a hardware surplus clearance place, all labeled at $2. I bought them all.

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#17

$9????

John in NM

Wow! Jump on a couple, most places I've seen carbide endmills for sale they were as much or usually more than the same size carbide router bits.

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#18

Nights are awful...

John in NM

I do a 7 day stretch of 6pm to 6am once a month... horrible :D

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#19

Re: $9????

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Well, that was my reaction, too!

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#20

Re: Nights are awful...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I do 7 nights every four weeks, but 5 of them are 8-hour stretches, the other 2 are 12's. I don't know how you handle 7 12's. My mind would be more mush than it already is.

The guys on my shift always wonder how the company trusts us with a couple hundred million dollars worth of equipment. :D

Re: metal working mill bits in a router

#21

Re: Nights are awful...

Howard Norman

Rotating shifts like that are bad as far as I am concerned. I know a lot of people do them but I never believed that it was productive. I did a lot of quality audits of chemical companies were they had rotating shifts like that. Never did convince any of them to change but I certainly tried. When I retired the company i was working for was using four 12 hour shifts to man the manufacturing area 24/7. You worked four 12 hour days one week and three 12 hour days the next week. You made more money if your 12 shift was at night as opposed to working the 12 hour day shift so many people decided that they would rather work at night for the extra income.