Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Help, math beyond me. Dog house shed.

Posts

Help, math beyond me. Dog house shed.

#1

Help, math beyond me.  Dog house shed.

Gary Smyth

Engineers? I have built a winter dog house shed. The roof is essentially flat with only a 2” drop front to rear in 33”. The roof’s total size is 33” deep x 51” wide 2 ½” thick. I hit the big box store and found an opened bundle of shingles and fortunately or unfortunately they are the 40 year architectural kind. I used the bundle minus two full length shingles (20 strips out of 22) and excluding waste from trimming according to Owens Corning specs. The bundle weighed 80lbs, and the wood roof is ½”ply top and bottom with frame and battens with 1 ½” of foam insulation in between. If I removed the roof completely and weighed it I would be pretty close estimating it would come in near 120lbs. The shed roof is hinged at the rear so that the front can be muscled and propped up for cleaning. (Think of it like a car hood without springs.) I need to find out how much weight will need to be safely supported by two metal props to hold up the roof if the angle of the roof is raised to 60 degrees from basically horizontal. I don’t even know what math is involved. If it’s trig I haven’t got a chance. Can anyone help with a formula that I can understand? Also, the center of gravity will move with the lift. How is the point calculated where raising the roof on the shed could cause it to overturn by the CG moving rearward? Is anything under 90 degrees safe?

Re: Help, math beyond me. Dog house shed.

#2

Re: Help, math beyond me.  Dog house shed.

Dale Stansbery

Forget the math. If it's that heavy you don't want it falling under any circumstances. I'd add 20 or 30 pounds as a safety factor, and figure props that could withstand 150 to 170 pounds each, in case one slips.

Re: Help, math beyond me. Dog house shed.

#3

Re: Help, math beyond me.  Dog house shed.

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If I understand your question, you plan to raise the roof up to about 60 degrees for cleaning purposes, and support it there. The safe approach is to assume that the full weight of the roof structure will be resting on your supports, although actually a lot of it will be on the hinges. Then you have to engineer your supports - My impulse is to recommend 3/4" pipe, but, really, lots of things would work (heavy duty metal fence posts, for instance - depends on what you've got around or what you find cheap, and can attach to the roof easily).

The center of gravity of the roof, raised up that high, will still be the geometric center of the roof structure. The tipover point would be reached as the center of gravity approaches a vertical line to the hinges, but your proposed 60 degrees should build in enough safety in theory; but see next paragraph.

Consider the strength of your hinges and the strength of their attachment, as well as how the load is carried - the hinges should, ideally, attach to structural members that go to the ground. You'll also have considerable horizontal loading - the roof, raised up that high and acting on the hinges, will try to knock your back (hinged) wall flat. So examine how your back wall is attached to the side walls, and how the side walls are held down on the ground. Even if the center of gravity is theoretically within reason, if the side walls aren't fastened down well, the tendency of the hinges to close could tip the side walls upward; unless the corners aren't fastened well, in which case the back wall will rip off the sides. Either way, you won't be having fun.

Composition shingles aren't recommended for any roof with a rise of less than 3 in 12* or 4 in 12 (should have been on the plastic); your roof's more like 2/3 in 12. For a rise that low on a utility structure like that, I'd have used roll roofing, lapped in the appropriate direction and sealed with lots of roofing sealant (I prefer Henry's; my limited use of other brands has not impressed me). I'd seal the edges of the roof ply, too - roof edging (flashing) would be good, but slather on a little paint before doing that.

*If you're not familiar with how rise is traditionally stated on roofs: a 3 in 12 pitch is 3" of rise in the roof over a 12" distance.

Re: Help, math beyond me. Dog house shed.

#4

Re: Help, math beyond me.  Dog house shed.

Barry Irby

The lumber used for framing will support about a 1000lbs per square inch. A 2x2 has 2.25 sq in. so in theory it would support over 2000 lbs. (and a short piece say under 6" or a foot will, but a longer piece would buckle.) For your purposes a 2x2 would support the roof easily and 2 would be over kill. So I would make two props out f 2x2'2 and be sure they are securely hinges and secure in some sort of pocket when the roof is raised. Fix them so that you can't knock them out easily. 120 lbs is a small load in a construction project.

And bill is right about the slope of the roofing. You are way below the recommended slope for shingles. You should have used roll roofing or Ice And Water Shield under what you have. Let us know if it does not leak.

Re: Help, math beyond me. Dog house shed.

#5

Math?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Coupla 2x4's and you're done.

Keep it simple; it's a dog house after all. :D

Re: Help, math beyond me. Dog house shed.

#6

roof slope, practical experience

Bill Tindall

I am certainly not arguing that the slope is way to little for a house or porch. But I have a cover over something that is very much like what is described. I roofed it with left over house shingles because they were free at the time. They lasted ten years. It was too heavy to lift off and on so when I replaced it I used the corrugated plastic roofing.

The weight of this roof is trivial for any hinge and all but the most frail brace to support.

Re: Help, math beyond me. Dog house shed.

#7

Ellis Walentine

Out of the box approach

Ellis Walentine

Why don't you attach a heavy eye bolt to the outside edge of the roof and run a cable up over a pulley and down to where you can stack weights on it until it exactly balances. Then you can raise and lower the roof to any slope you want. A suitcase latch will hold it down adequately when closed.

Worked for a buddy's solar kiln. It would work for this.

Ellis

Re: Help, math beyond me. Dog house shed.

#8

Re: Help, math beyond me.  Dog house shed.

TomD

You can model the weight at the front and the back with trig, however it is going to get a lot more complex, if you start varying where the strut goes, and it's angles. So the simple method is to rig a test. Just attach a spring scale to where you think the strut will go, and angle it as you think the strut will be angled. If the loads are too scary, or the range of you scale to light, remember you can use anything you like as a stand in. The strut is not going to care whether it is supporting a roof or a rod. So you could just lean a 2x4 against something, to act as the hinge, And attach the scale to it in various positions, and angles. You could even just use your hand in place of the scale. Does it feel twice as heavy, etc... A bathroom scale could be used under a strut. Unless you really know the math, it is often easier to just scab together a model.

Re: Help, math beyond me. Dog house shed.

#9

Re: Help, math beyond me.  Dog house shed.

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Gary - as an Engineer with neigh 40 years experience I would not do any calculations. I designed many pieces of automated equipment over the years - some weighing several tons - down to precision assembly equipment that would set on your kitchen table. The only advantage to calculating the stress load that you are discussing would come if you were building hundreds of thousands of doghouses for sale - then the cost of the support might be reduced by $.50 or $.75 each. As others have stated look at the entire weight and support it - then no worries. I always overbuilt equipment - the cost was usually borne only by 1 to 3 pieces of equipment. An extra cost of five to 10 thousand per a 100 to 200 thousand dollar machine doesn't amount to much. Could I have reduced the cost by using thinner tabletops - smaller shafts - lighter bearings - sure, but the time spent doing that (labor costs) may have exceeded the savings and I would have had a lighter machine more subject to vibration etc. The product Engineers spent many hours saving $.01 in material - but we sold millions of that product. Your over thinking the project use KISS (keep it simple stu---). I would be far more concerned with the roof leaking due to using shingles rated for a minimum slope of 4/12 - I would use corrugated metal, roll roofing or rubber roofing material. Ellis had an excellent suggestion as to roof mounting - I would sure look hard at that.

Re: Help, math beyond me. Dog house shed.

#10

Re: Help, math beyond me.  Dog house shed.

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

To answer your question. If the roof weighed 200# and you pivot it on one end to an angle of 60 degrees from horizontal.

Then your support hinge would be holding 86.6% of the weight or 173# and your support would need to hold the rest or 27#.

Lee

Re: Help, math beyond me. Dog house shed.

#11

Just completing the thread. Thanks.

Gary Smyth

I've been absent and could not reply promptly.

Here is followup on the dog house/former log cart, tundra wagon. It ain't fine cabinetry and Martha Stewart sure doesn't live there, but it'll do.

The shingled roof is well below recommendation of 4:12. I knew that. It is for show mostly. It was designed almost flat so that the dogs could jump and view if they chose. It still exceeds the 1" per 4 foot drop for waste water run off used around here. From the get go the total of the 1/2" ply roof was covered with rubberized underlayment and metal drip edge. I hated that look every time I passed by so I added the architectural shingles. I'll see if my addition causes a problem where there did not need to be one.

A pulley counterweight for assisting in the roof lift is not a viable option for this location.

To keep on the good side of the neighbor, the cart can later be used as a firewood log cart. It has 10" tire casters that move well over grass. The cart breaks down completely. It is held together with numerous unglued 3/8" dowels into a 2X8 base and the top of the front, back and sides is held in tension through the use of window latches which draw things together nicely

The prop to hold up the roof for cleaning (as soon as it stops raining and the wind dies down) is a copper coated steel 5/8" ground rod that was bent. It was useless to the electrical department but I can get two straight sections at least 31" which will give me plenty of strength and I can store them out of the way on the front frame on spring clips. The nil price was right too.

Winter has closed out paint until spring, but inside it's dog heaven. Wind and rain are miimal and the roof and floor are insulated. The Golden, "Hank", has a hard time climbing in, but his Laborador "sister" "Bear" likes it and seems to appreciate not stirring by looking out the plexiglas windowed ends. She mostly stays behind the temporary canvas rain/wind flap until called for food (not from me). Hank will have a intermediate step for access by the weekend.

Thanks again for all your thoughts