Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Finishing advice

Posts

Finishing advice

#1

Finishing advice

Jack Hartley

I am building a DVD&component storage cabinet out of cherry. The construction is frame and panel. I proceed to stain the panels with Minwax prior to assembly. The staining did not go as to plan. I ended up with a bad case of the blotches. Is there a way to salvage these panels or just start over? I realize that I should have used shellac prior to staining, but is there a way to fix the panels now?

Re: Finishing advice

#2

Re: Un-Finishing advice

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I'd start by removing as much pigment as possible with mineral spirits, a scrub brush, and paper towels. Then allow to dry and resand. Stain doesn't penetrate very much, so most will sand off, especially on woods like cherry and maple.

You'll likely wind up with a dark line where your panel joins the frame (unless you sacrifice the rails and stiles), but you'll now have a glazed effect finish with the remaining pigment accenting your construction.

If the above doesn't get you far enough back to "salmon", you can bleach the pieces, but I'm not a fan of bleaching cherry.

hth

Re: Finishing advice

#3

Ellis Walentine

Re: Finishing advice

Ellis Walentine

Hmm. you didn't say whether these panels have molded raised-panel edges on them, but it would seem so. Maybe you can go back to the molder and take just another whisker off the edges to get back to raw wood. Then sand the flat faces until they're clean again.

A couple things I want to mention here:

First, I wouldn't use shellac to keep stains from blotching. They make stain controllers for that, or you can make your own by wetting the surface of the wood with a very dilute mixture of linseed oil or varnish prior to staining.

Second, you might want to consider using either a dye stain or a gel stain on woods that are prone to blotching. Dye stains are usually my preference because I can get exactly the color or tone I want and it is uniform, whereas pigment stains accentuate the pore structure of the wood because the pigments collect in the larger voids. I usually use pigment stains over a ground coat of dye stain to add complexity and depth to the color. On occasion, I've found that the preliminary coat of dye stain will reduce the pigment stain's tendency to blotch, too.

Third, remember my friend Michael Dresdner's admonition: "Finish firewood first." Don't commit to a finish on your valuable wood without running a test sample of the whole finishing process first, unless you've done it exactly that way in the past and it is a known quantity for you.

Ellis

Re: Finishing advice

#4

Re: Finishing advice

JMOHNIKE

You may have better results with acetone or laquer thinner than paint thinner to remove the stain. Both will have somewhat of a leaching effect on the stain and wear rubber gloves. Some stain will remain where ever there is an end grain exposure, but should not be any big problem. Use a pre-stain conditioner and then reapply stain. I had bloches on some items I made many years ago, out of cherry. Over the years the cherry oxidized and the bloches dissapeard, but you may not want to wait that long. Just my 2 cents worth.

Re: Finishing advice

#5

Re: Finishing advice

Jack Hartley

Thanks for the information. I am trying to match the furniture in our living room otherwise I would not have stained the cherry. I agree good wood should not be stained. I will give you suggestions a try.

Re: Finishing advice

#6

A discussion of cherry "blotches"

Bill Tindall

There are two factors that lead to color depth variations when staining. Torn grain from planing or other machining operations will soak up stain more than non-damaged wood. The solution to this defect is perfect sanding. If when approaching the final grit sizes there are dull places, there are dull places because there is torn grain catching the sanding dust to yield a dull place. Go back at least one grit and sand away this torn grain.

Grain changes from flat to more or less vertical leads to more stain uptake as well as more finish uptake. These more or less vertical grain regions will be in darker contrast to the flat grain regions. In maple and mahogany this variation is highly desirable and stains and oils are used to enhance it. Why ever this same effect in cherry is indicted with the pejorative term blotching escapes me. Personally I don't do anything to hide shade changes that result from variations in cherry grain orientation. I am a fanatic about eliminating all torn grain before staining.

There is no relation between wood quality, or furniture quality, and staining. Minimalist finishing is a recent fad. Most of the finest Period furniture ever made with the best woods available was stained, and reproductions still are. Personally I stain everything made from cherry, walnut, oak and mahogany. Because of the style of the pieces I rarely stain ash or maple.

Re: Finishing advice

#7

Easiest way out

David Yoho

In the future you can avoid the issues of blotching in woods prone to this by applying a blotch control product available from my friend and pro furniture builder and finisher, Charles Neil.

Google - Charles Neil Blotch Control - and you should be able to find it. I use it and it works as advertised. It also resolves a couple of other issues we run into as finishers. Have a look and see what you think. I think he has a video demonstrating the product too.

Disclaimer: I'm not affiliated with Charles Neil Woodworking and receive no compensation. I'm just a friend who uses his product and I bet most folks here don't know it exists.

Re: Finishing advice

#8

Alan Young

I second David's comments..


Re: Finishing advice

#9

Charles Neil Blotch Control

del schisler

I use it and it work's here is the link and video also http://www.youtube.com/profile?user=InTheWorkshop#p/u/36/IfCYMdrP8rM