Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT - Answer to Which Came First, Chicken or Egg

Posts

OT - Answer to Which Came First, Chicken or Egg

#1

OT - Answer to Which Came First, Chicken or Egg

charlie belden

Kids are getting smarter.

Somehow, while hanging out with my 8 year old grandson, the question "Which came first, the chicken or the egg?" came up.

"The egg of course." he said, as if the answer was obvious.

"OK, so why did the egg come first?" I asked.

"Well, dinosaurs layed eggs and they were around before chickens." he explained with a semi-condescending smile.

Didn't have the heart to ask the obvious NEXT question . . .

Re: OT - Answer to Which Came First, Chicken or Egg

#2

Re: OT - Answer to Which Came First, Chicken or Eg

Evolution Larry says...

I don't see why there is even a question to "Which Came First".... I knew ever since I was a little kid that the EGG had to come first!

What produced the egg was not a chicken, but was a very close relative.

A few mutated genes and what comes out of the egg is a chicken.

Why is that so hard to understand?

Re: OT - Answer to Which Came First, Chicken or Egg

#3

Re: OT - Answer to Which Came First, Chicken or Eg

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Of course, it's a matter of defining "chicken." At what point does it qualify as a chicken?

Re: OT - Answer to Which Came First, Chicken or Egg

#4

Re: OT - Answer to Which Came First, Chicken or Eg

R. Payne

The question doesn't specify that the egg must be a chicken egg. Biologically speaking, an egg is the gamete produced by the female of the species. That pushes the egg back before there was anything living on land.

Now if you want to specify the egg must be a chicken egg then the question becomes how you define a chicken egg. Is that an egg a chicken hatches out of or the egg laid by a chicken?

ron

Re: OT - Answer to Which Came First, Chicken or Egg

#5

When He Gets Older

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

maybe he'll learn that chickens (and all birds) are the dinosaurs.