Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

octagonal bench problems

Posts

octagonal bench problems

#1

HapaJeff

octagonal bench problems

HapaJeff

This problem is sort of difficult to put into words, but I'll give it a try:

I am building a series of octagonal benches to go around trees. The seats are comprised of six 2” wide slats that will be spaced 1/4” apart, forming six concentric octagons with an outside “diameter” of 66”.

I spent some time making a cross cut sled to cut the 22.5 degree angles, and it is extremely accurate.

The problem I’m having is cutting the slats so that the resulting rings are spaced no more or no less than 1/4” from the adjoining slats. If my cut is off by 1/64” of an inch, by the time the pieces of a particular ring are assembled, the ring is spaced noticeably further away from the previous set of slats.

I’m looking for a way to easily cut the slats so that the resulting rings are 1/4” apart from one another.

Re: octagonal bench problems

#2

Re: octagonal bench problems

Terry Alexander

I would build 8 "seats", all 1/4" spacing. Then I would cut these 8 "seats" to 22.5 degrees on each end and assemble them around the tree.

My $.02 worth.

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: octagonal bench problems

#3

Re: not just angles! Lengths

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Just like the classic picture framing issues: cutting perfect 45.0000 degree miters is not enough. The opposite sides have to be the same length for the joints to close.

So while I'm not sure what your sled looks like, I think I would approach it as Terry suggests. I'd be inclined to make 8 seat assemblies and trim the ends (to angle AND length).

If your 6 slat seat assemblies allow, I'd consider pairing opposite sides of the octagon and cutting them simultaneously (paired top to top). If not that way, then a hard stop is needed on your sled to ensure accurate lengths for opposite sides.

Measuring lengths of mitered pieces (and trying to fit them in a frame) results in a nightmare I wouldn't wish on anyone (maybe that's what you have already found out?)

Henry

Re: octagonal bench problems

#4

HapaJeff

Re: octagonal bench problems

HapaJeff

I had actually thought of cutting each section of the pie as it were all at once as you've both suggested. Not sure why I rejected the idea, but I wish I hadn't. Better to spend a couple of hours making a new sled now than countless hours later fudging things and cussing to make them fit.

Thanks for the advice.

Jeff

Re: octagonal bench problems

#5

Re: octagonal bench problems

Guillaume Dery

Here is what I would do. Make 1/4" spacers (with sandpaper to aid grip) and gang the cuts. Basically you are laying out the parts as they will be in situ, flat on your sled with the 1/4" spacers (2 per gap) between the boards. This will maintain your spacing and ensure consistency of length. Once one set of boards is done, use it as a guide to lay out the next batch (stop block or trace them on your sled).

I hope I am making sense here... If not drop me a note and I will see if I can clarify a bit.

Re: octagonal bench problems

#6

Re: octagonal bench problems

TomD

You are talking about the seat or table sections?

I would nail them, or whatever in place, snap a chalk line, and then cut them in place. You can use a fence to guide your saw if it is supposed to be sorta cabinet grade. Sounds more picnic table grade, based on use. When you get to the last segment, just scribe them in place. I would probably go a fraction oversize, and then plane, or nibble them till they melt into place.

Something of this sort is often the best approach unless you are making kits or something where every single piece needs to interchange with every piece the world over. Think of framing roofs, the tolerances can be very tight, but nobody makes a table saw sled for every cut. I'm not talking woodbutchery here. Dovetails are scribed for a fit, and they can look poured in place.

Even with a sled, there are lots of ways for the fits to wander, for instance, most sleds will support the cut near the joint, but the actual geometry it to the centerline of the piece. So the angles actually depend on the overall straightness of the boards, etc...

Re: octagonal bench problems

#7

HapaJeff

Re: octagonal bench problems

HapaJeff

These benches definitely aren't picnic-table-grade. Made from teak, with almost $3000 in lumber. Precision and repeatability are/were key.

Anyhow, I ended up making eight carrier boards with 1/4" spacers between the slats. I nailed the slats to the carriers from underneath, and mitered each carrier, slats and carrier together. worked like an absolute charm.