Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Shop update and Electrical Question

Posts

Shop update and Electrical Question

#1

Shop update and Electrical Question

Allen Bryant - Bumpass, VA

Well the draftsman and I have still been hashing out a plan, but we are getting closer to having the final plans ready right after the first of the year. Considering he is doing this as a favor and promise of trade labor I'm not going to push him to hard to get done.

The contractor was having a slow week so since we have a rough foot print and size of the building he went ahead and came out this past week and cleared the trees and stumps out of the way. That's about as much as they can do till we get the permits.

Now for the electrical questions

The specs for my table saw states that it requires a 220v, 15 Amp circuit, but the max draw from the motor is 14 amps, isn't this cutting it a little close. By the specs I can install a 14-3WG wire on a 15 AMP Double Pole breaker. If I go to a bigger circuit do I run the risk of burning the motor out because it could overload well beyond 14 amps prior to tripping the breaker. I was wondering about running 12-3WG but with the same 15amp breaker. Around here I can put a higher class wire on a lower class breaker just not the other way around. This would mean that if I upgrade to something higher later that I would only have to swap out the breaker and would still trip at 15 amps without having to worry about overheating the wire or the motor.

Second question, for people who have dedicated buildings for their shops does anybody have a second power source run to it and not a feed from the main house breaker? If so was there any problems on getting the electrical source run by your provider? Even though I have can run up to 150 amp sub panel off the house it would be easier to get power to the building by coming off of the main transformer ( if it can handle it) than to come off the house feed.

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#2

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Lots of questions here; let me answer one, and come back later.

That breaker does sound undersized; I'd consider a 20 amp breaker. You might, though, contact the manufacturer to discuss their recommendation; you may be misreading the motor plate. The first purpose of a breaker is to protect the circuit, so oversized wire relative to the breaker is fine (in fact, on a long run where there are issues of voltage drop, it's necessary to go up a size or more anyway). It is also true that breakers should be sized intelligently against the load, so that they provide some protection in case the load (motor in this case) develops an ailment.

And the problem you'd run into with an undersized breaker isn't damage to the motor; the problem is frequent breaker tripping.

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#3

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

Barry Irby

It is my understanding that the circuit is "derated" for a continuous draw device by 20%. So, You should only draw 12 amps through a 15 amp circuit and 16 amps through a 20 amp circuit. It certainly does not hurt anything to put in a larger wire and a smaller breaker and there really shouldn't be any reason not to put in a twenty amp circuit with a twenty amp breaker. I might consider an even larger wire just to avoid trouble with future upgrades.

I would either contact the manufacturer or reexamine the data plate. I doubt a saw that actually pulls 14 amps should be on a 15 amp circuit.

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#4

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Breakers are only intended to protect the wiring. The motor takes care of itself- if it weren't so you could never use 2 Amp lamps, hair dryers, etc. on 15Amp house circuits.

Unless you are building a commercial shop, a 100 Amp subpanel should be more than enough.

Run the subpanel off the house panel- only if you have sufficient capacity there or if you want a cut-off switch at the house to secure power to the shop?

I ended up with two 200 Amp house panels so I could run a 100 Amp subpanel from one to my attached shop. As to a separate feed to the shop- I think it comes down to cost- I would go with whatever is most economical and convenient. A friend in Indiana had a separate feed and meter for his shop, cost was about the same.

Plan your electrical for worst case/growth. If you don't have them now, someday you may have a DC, drum sander, planer, etc. that require 220V/30 Amp circuits. You'll also want sufficient 220V/20A circuits and 120V 20 Amp circuits located throughout the shop as well- I would forgo 120/15A circuits. Will you ever buy any 3 phase equip? If so, decide if you will use individual VFDs or RPCs, or if you will have a central RPC. If you go with a central RPC you'll want to have a 3 phase circuit. Copper is outrageous now, but I doubt will ever go down where it was.

Bumpass? Are you on the lake Ana? Many times I've been to our friends lake house just up the road from you. Its at Waller's Quarters, on the north side of the lake, just across from the dike.

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#5

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Normally no circuit breaker in the main box is intended to provide any protection to the equipment being "plugged" into the outlet powered by the breaker. The breaker is intended to provide protection to the "stationary" wiring (that which is installed in the walls/structure) to prevent overheating /fire or damage to the stationary wire. The motor is normally protected by either a device internal to the motor or installed in the equipment. You can always use a larger wire than the breaker is rated for as obviously it will not never overheat. When I built my shop I installed several 240 V. receptacles - all wired with #10/3 w/ground, all with 30 amp breakers. Since building my shop, I have upgraded several pieces of equipment with larger motors that now require the 30 Amp circuits - This would have been a real problem had I not installed the larger wire prior to installing the drywall and finishing the shop. As a former Engineer and contractor, I feel the extra expense of installing many outlets, larger wiring with 30 amp breakers is often of huge benefit as you upgrade your shop. I have never regretted the expense of the larger wiring cost or the many outlets I put in when building mine. I installed a 120V duplex outlet every 32" , 4 foot high on every wall of my shop - then added a few where I thought I might need more. I also installed 8 or 10 - 240 outlets and one 50 amp 240 for a welder. Actually wish I had added a few more 120V near the main door and in other areas.

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#6

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

Charlie Lenz

What type of table saw are you useing ? Contractor's or Cabinet saw ? If it is a Contractor's saw, you would want either a 20 amp 115V circuit, or a 15 amp 230V circuit. As far as the wireing goes, if I was to build a new shop I would strongly consider installing the breaker box, conduit, and the boxes on the outside of of the interiors sheeted walls. It makes it so much easier to change wireing if you want or need to someday. You could probably run a new line off of the transformer, but you'd probably be geting the untility company involved to come out of the transformer, and installing a meter. You may want to check on the cost of that first.

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#7

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

Allen Bryant - Bumpass, VA

I'm technically in Holly Grove, but literally the people across the street from me are in Bumpass and are in a different area code. We have Bumpass mailing address but for some reason a Goochland phone number for the home phone and a Bumpass phone number for the cell phone each in different area codes, talk about confusing. I've got a pretty good idea of where you are talking about on Lake Anna and we are about a 15 minute drive south of there.

When i build the shop I am planning on adding the cabinet saw and a bigger DC and air compressor. The 100 AMP should be more than sufficient power wise, but with 3 tools that already run off 220 and the addition of 2 more plus the heat pump, I'm actually more concerned about breaker space. The lighting will probably go on 15 AMP circuits, but I have no plans to put anything lower than 20 AMP circuits for the regular 110 outlets.

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#8

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

Allen Bryant - Bumpass, VA

Many outlets is going to be a theme in the shop with them on all the walls at either every third or so stud. The only extension cords I intend to ever use is probably one or two cord reels suspended from the ceiling towards the middle of the room. Right now there are 5 planned tools that will require 220 plus the heat pump. I'm thinking of putting each of the 4 walls on their own 20 AMP circuit and an additional circuit for some ceiling outlets. The lighting will be split into two circuits one for the ceiling lights and probably the light outside the front door, and an additional circuit for the task lighting. Right now that adds up to 18 breaker slots. I've found a 100 AMP panel that has 30 breaker slots. Anything higher than that and I will have to run a separate line from the transformer. Can multiple 220 outlets be on the same circuit or do I have to run a separate run for each outlet. Being a one man shop, I can't see myself running the jointer and cabinet saw at the same time.

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#9

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

Henry Higginbotham

You probably need to contact your power company NOW, to see if a separate service is even available to you. My shop has a separate service drop and meter, and I recommend that if it's available to you as a residential customer. You will of course have a second base charge to deal with, but here that's only $12-14 per month.

When my shop power went in about eight years ago, Alabama Power was very accommodating and even dropped an open-delta 3-phase service to my shop at no extra charge. My breaker panel cost a lot more and I was, for a while, on a small-commercial rate plan (not a problem unless my demand meter went over 5kW for 15 minutes or longer, which it never did). BUT, a friend and I are currently building his shop on the outskirts of Birmingham, and he was unable to get a separate service unless the shop was declared commercial (hello, zoning and tax problems). The plan now is a 400 amp drop to the house, which splits into two 200 amp cut-off boxes to supply the house and shop. This is an extra $1100 expense. What a difference eight years and 60 miles makes, huh?

Larry Clinton's advice is good: Use big wire and lots of receptacles. More money now but you'll like it later.

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#10

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

Allen Bryant - Bumpass, VA

Just got off the phone with Rappahanock Electrical CO-OP and they state it is possible, they are going to send someone to the property to check it out and come back with costs.

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#11

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

David Yoho

Allen, I'll be interested to see what Rappahanock can do in your case and how they are to work with. Should we decide to build on the property we own in King William, they would be our source of power. Dominion VA Power is all I've ever used, so I have questions about how the smaller utility company compares.

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#12

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

Barry Irby

Consider running your outlets more than four feet off the floor so you can lean plywood on the walls and not cover them. DAMHIKT

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#13

On the other hand,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Having electrical cords starting at four feet up and dangling down can be a trip hazard. Electrical boxes and cable are relatively cheap, and, if you're doing the work yourself, labor is free; consider having parallel sets of outlets, one at, say, 50" off the floor (bottom of the box) and one at 12" off the floor.

As I've remodeled our place in phases, I've started to use 4" square boxes and mud rings (conservative me: I use metal boxes rather than plastic, because they can be repaired more easily in the future), rather than 2x4 boxes. It's way easier to have a box in which the wires DON'T fill the box.

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#14

Good thought, and I would want a few...

Barry Irby

hanging from the ceiling. Really.

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#15

Drop cords

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You used to be able to get drop cord fixtures with strain relief built into the fixture/cord. Advisable, if you're going to do hanging fixtures, but you'd probably have to go to a commercial electrical shop or find someone really good in the electrical aisle at your home center.

Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#16

Re:Actual outlet height is around 4' 5"


Re: Shop update and Electrical Question

#17

Re: Great forum

TomD

I like this forum, it has an active shop electrical forum. I remember being impressed (read confused by) this thread, but it shows how they can get into details on sub-panels):

http://forum.canadianwoodworking.com/showthread.php?40180-Grounding-a-subpanel&highlight=grounding