dust cyclones
Ray - Middletown, IN
Anyone have any issues with the leading contenders. Looking to upgrade soon if the CFO agrees.
Ray
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
dust cyclones
Ray - Middletown, IN
Anyone have any issues with the leading contenders. Looking to upgrade soon if the CFO agrees.
Ray
Re: dust cyclones
Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV
How big you want to go? I got the metal Dust Deputy, put it on a 30 gallon fiber drum, powered with the smallest Rigid Vac and I was impressed. The Performax is the most demanding of good dust collection. The plane make the biggest mess without it. No problems with thsi set-up. Not hard to connect the hose and go. Next up is the table saw. Haven't tried that yet.
Or are you looking to install a half mile of pipe and listen to the roar of wind?
Re: dust cyclones
Ray - Middletown, IN
Just want to hear the gentle roar of wind through the mountains like in NV. I built a cyclone back in the 90's from the Wood mag plan. It is rather pathetic and needs replaced. I already have the duct in place and just need to set a collector in the barn and plug it in. Looking at PSI, Grizzly, Oneida, Accura and any I can find in the price category. There is a Woodsucker on Ebay right now also, kind of pricey tho.
Ray
Re: dust cyclones
Randy Johnson
When I was putting the shop together several years ago I wanted to install a cyclone system and did a lot of reading on the subject. Not surprisingly, 95% of the reading was on Bill Pentz’s website. It bothered me that in one sentence he would say that 99% of the cyclones out there wouldn’t get the fine dust and then turn right around and say that the fine dust would clog the filters.
I wanted to get everything from one source and I preferred metal over plastic so that eliminated the Clearvue. I bought Oneida’s “commercial” 2HP model. Bill was right. For the most part, it’s a chip collector. It does well sanding at the lathe and with the drum sander. Adequate with the planer, jointer, radial arm saw, and router table. It’s only so so with the table saw, bandsaw, and, on the rare occasions when I use it, the shaper.
The filter on the air cleaner on the ceiling still turns brown in an unbelievably short time.
I made some major modifications to two of the machines to aid in dust collection. I cut a rectangular hole in the lower blade cover of the bandsaw and installed a right angle HVAC boot (4 inch). Since a 90 degree bend equals ten feet of pipe I eliminated a few of them by cutting a rectangular hole in the right side of the cabinet of my tablesaw and installing a six inch HVAC boot. I then made a new “ramp” for the inside of the cabinet that slanted to the right at a much steeper angle than the original. The tablesaw also has overhead collection with the blade guard.
This was several years ago. Oneida is always upgrading their product and today’s 2HP is quite possibly superior to mine. But there is only so much you can do with 2HP.
Also, to be fair I’m bad about not turning it on if I am only going be using a saw for a few quick cuts or touching up a small place on a turning.
If I had it to do over there are two things for sure that I would do differently. I would get at LEAST a 3HP unit. The other is make a large recess in the ceiling to be able to mount the unit several feet higher. With a large drum in place there isn’t enough room for the cyclone effect to work right because the bottom of the funnel is too close to the top of the drum.
I think we met several years ago at a shop in Lapel. (I was looking at lathes) If so, that cyclone was mounted the way I wish mine was. WAY off the floor. He had something like ten feet between the bottom of the funnel and the top of the drum.
Re: dust cyclones
Ray - Middletown, IN
Hi Randy, Yes we did meet at Lapel sometime back and yes his collector is where it should be. My pipe is at 10' and the collector will be mounted rather high to accommodate a large bin underneath. One thing wrong with my pipe is that long radius ells were not available when I installed and I may have to make some mods along the way. I may exhaust to the outside rather than mess with filters, still considering. I think that old cyclone that Wood magazine put out back in the 90's sparked a lot of the debate about dust collector, along with the lack of info put out by the manufacturers of the time, and culminated in the Pentz articles that followed. Thanks for the feedback, very useful.
Ray
Barn, did you say BARN?
Barry Irby
If you have a barn what are the chances you live on a large piece of property? If I could I would eliminate the filters and let the fines blow in the wind. NO deterioration in performance as the filters clog. In fact, I would not use a cyclone at all. I would just blow the stuff out into the woods and be done with it, or into a bin I could back my truck under and empty it once a year. Maybe. I don't want a dust collector. Why would I want to collect DUST. I want a dust remover. The only reason I can think of to use a cyclone is to avoid the chips and chunks going through the impeller.
Re: dust cyclones
Charlie Lenz
Have you considered a Thien Separator ? I have one with a dust collector and I luv it. It was fun to build, and the cost was very minimal.
Re: dust cyclones
George Koch
I have to agree with Chuck on the Thien separator. They work great! I have one on my roll arond shop vac and a larger one on my dust "remover" system.
Tried that once
Ray - Middletown, IN
Something got into the end of the opening (one of the hazards of living in the country) and clogged it. I also had forgotten to empty the bin under the cyclone. The pipe blew apart and I had about 100 gal of shavings from the planer over everything in the barn at the end of the day. Silly me I thought 10' above the ground was enough to keep things out. If I do it again I will put in one of those automatic louver things.
Ray
No room
Ray - Middletown, IN
Anything I put in has to reside outside the shop with ductwork running back in. Sometimes you have to walk sideways just to get around. Might help if I put things away once in a while.
Ray
Re: Tried that once
Barry Irby
I have a friend who has a Pro woodworking shop. He bought an old feed storage Bin from some farmer. Its original use was they stored cattle feed in it. A large steel box with a big hopper on the bottom. Probably 6 or 8 feet square and even taller. Raised off the ground on angle iron legs. He blows the sawdust into the top of it. Backs a truck under it and dumps it once in a while by opening the chute. I would look into something like that if I were in your position.
Re: I'll bet that I could make it work
Charlie Lenz
But you don't seem to want to put any effort into it, so I'll let it go.
Re: dust cyclones
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
Hi Ray, how have you been doing? I was hoping you might have one of your WoodCentral picnics again, really enjoyed the last one. To answer your question, I have the Grizzly 3 HP cyclone. Been in about 6 years or so. I did have some problems with the motor start switch and Capacitor right after I installed it, but Grizzly did a fairly good job of getting me the replacement parts and it has worked well since. Only issues I have had since is that the metal barrel has four casters under it that have caused the barrel bottom to bend - could be my fault as it has been handled pretty rough. I would recommend it, I have an 8" outlet pipe then a 8" X 6"/6" Y (homemade adapter from PVC sewer pipe) then 2 lines of 6" - one runs about 40' across the center / top of the shop with Y's and 2 or three drops with gates and a second 35' line across the back wall ceiling with multiple drops - works as well or better than I expected. I pull a 10' - 4" flex line to my 20" stationary planer off the end of the 40' line and it keeps all the shavings and 95% of all the dust off the planer even when running wide panels - couldn't ask for much more. It does take a 10' ceiling height to use the large drum under it - I think it is a 55 gal. When I run the planer a lot it doesn't take long to fill it.
Thanks Larry
Ray - Middletown, IN
That helps fill in some knowledge gaps about the Grizzly product.
Keep the second weekend in September in mind, there will probably be an announcement coming soon.
Jeez this Verizon sucks, it has taken 25 minutes to get this posted.
Ray
Re: dust cyclones
nickb
I have had a 2 hp Oneida for several years - no issues (although getting it up on the mounting bracket was a lot of fun). Outstanding chip collection and good dust collection (the dust that collects in the pan under the filter is amazingly fine - lighter than talcum powder and I get minimal settled dust on horizontal surfaces), although I probably did more to reduce dust in the air by being consistent about connecting my Fein Miniturbo (with the HEPA filter) to the ROS and plate joiner.
Re: dust cyclones
Ray - Middletown, IN
Thanks Nick, was looking for some feedback on that one.
Ray