cutting board theory and experience.....
Bill Tindall
I have owned butcher block counter tops for 41 years. The first 22 years they were cherry and the last years maple. When have them to use, an important point to put the following in perspective. Everything from bread preparation to cutting up deer and sheep gets done on these counter tops. Hence, what follows is a result of practical experience for used counter top cutting boards.
If you use the tops they will self oil to some degree. So, for example, when kneading bread dough that has any oil content, some of this oil will transfer to the top. Scraping(with pastry scraper) the top clean afterward leaves behind some oil. However, after butchering a lamb the tops are scrubbed and this removes oil. Too much of the later relative to the former and the tops begin to look "dry" and cracks at the joints may occur. We find that we have to oil them occasionally. Oil is added and then the top is scraped with a pastry scraper.
With use, the cherry tops will turn nearly black. If you want to preserve the look of cherry varnish them and don't use them.
What to use for oiling?
Mineral oil- easy in, easy out. I didn't find this oil to be long lasting. If used often it could be fine.
Varnish and the like- The other extreme is some film building finish. A film building finish is a bad idea. Working on this surface will cut and scratch it. Pieces will come off and it will soon look bad and be difficult to restore.
So, what would be best is something that is, or would become, more viscous such that it would stick into the wood better.
Fats and Oils- Fats and oils have more or less unsaturation which provides a means of chemically combining these materials after exposure to air to make them more viscous, or even a solid. Linseed oil and tung oil are the most unsaturated and they will cross link to form a film on and within the wood. I find their smell objectionable for a food preparation surface.
The food grade oils have been deodorized and have no objectionable odor. Depending on their origin they have more of less unsatuaration. While they will not form a film like linseed oil they will somewhat cross link to form a vastly more durable result than mineral oil. Used in excess they can make a sticky surface. After treatment the surface must be wiped "dry".
From the composition of the common cooking oils one would predict that soybean oil would react with air to make the most sticky(durable) product and olive oil the least. Walnut oil has also been recommended but I have no experience with it. It is in between the film building oils and cooking oils in unsaturation and hence reactivity to cross link to a durable product.
As a practical matter when our tops look dry what ever cooking oil that is handy gets used to restore them.
The objection to using cooking oil. Every time I recommend cooking oil for wood tops their follows a chorus of objections that the oil will become rancid. While this objection is true, as a practical matter it is unimportant in my experience.
Any oil that has unsaturation, and therefore can cross link, reacts with air to yield low molecular weight acids that stink (the rancid smell of old oil, or curing linseed oil). As a practical matter any top or board that is used is going to absorb fats and oils that will become rancid to some extent. So the real question is whether this result is a practical problem.
In my case all our tops and cutting boards are occasionally treated with some cooking oil in addition to what ever grease and oil they absorb in use. We don't find that the result stinks up the kitchen or food. BTW, many desirable food flavors result from these same stinky acids- bread, cheese, anything fermented or cultured- so the fact that a few molecules of these chemicals transfer from the top or board to the food being prepared is hardly a practical concern.
But if you find the thought of rancid oils on you cutting boards and counter tops objectionable then use mineral oil and don't use them for oily or greasy food preparation. Organic heritage greens will be fine, if grown locally.