Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Finishing Question

Posts

Finishing Question

#1

Finishing Question

tony r

I recently purchased a piece of furniture from Nakashima Woodworking, made of beautiful english walnut. I am not 100% happy with the finish... when I picked out the wood and it was wetted (with water), the wood was rich in color with strong contrasting grain. When the piece was completed it looked flat by comparison, and significantly lighter. When I wet it a bit, it looks much nicer.

Tonight I applied a single coat of minwax tung oil finish (an oil/varnish blend) to the underside of the piece... it had the desired effect of making it look wetted, but also added a sheen i don't like...

Any thoughts of what I should do to the top to get the darker, contrasty, wetted look without the sheen? I presume that Nakashima is finishing their pieces the same way that Nakashima himself did so, though I'm not 100% convinced of that given that the finish is so flat and uncontrasty... but whatever it is, it must be some combination of oil/varnish and perhaps wax...

thanks, t.

Re: Finishing Question

#2

partial guess

Bill Tindall

It is impossible to describe with words what you are looking for so suggestions will be "shots in the dark".

Oil (tung or linseed) on wood will bring out contrast in the wood. The result will be a dull surface once the oil fully absorbs and reacts(crosslinks). Additional coats will result in more luster as a film begins to build. In the extreme, a surface coating will result with the luster of a film of the cured oil.

Varnishes are formulated with a film builder that will be bright until it ages some in the sun and air.

I would suggest that you get a piece of walnut and experiment with various finishing techniques until you find something satisfying before messing with the furniture.

No idea what was used in your case but it was common in the day when "Danish oil" was the popular look for walnut that the finish was a thin lacquer or conversion varnish with a lot of dulling agent added. All the finish companies had products to meet the need. In the case of Sherwin Williams it was Kemvar C. If the piece was stained with an oil based stain first the result was an excellent match for truly oiled walnut. Without the oil the looks was just dull.

Re: Finishing Question

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: Finishing Question

Moses Yoder

Walnut will darken with time, and the contrast between light and dark wood will grow stronger, at least in my experience with air dried walnut. UV rays really change the color of the wood. I would just as soon paint the piece a black laquer so nobody knows it was a Nakashima piece before I messed with the finish. Really a Nakashima piece and you are messing with the finish. You already ruined it's value by messing with the underside. Just saying.

Did they give you any instructions as to the care of the finish? Using something like Pledge to dust it will change the sheen and depth of the finish with time, it will build up a slight waxy layer that heightens the gloss.

Re: Finishing Question

#4

Re: Finishing Question  *LINK*


http://www.nakashimawoodworker.com/pdf/nakashima_notesoncare.pdf

Re: Finishing Question

#5

Re: Finishing Question

Steve Schoene

Actually, walnut tends to lighten with exposure to light, becoming more orange and more uniform in color as it does so. Difference between heartwood and sapwood do remain.