We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I'm not sure if I should call it a shoulder plane or a rabbit plane. In either case, I want to use it to clean up a rabbit, say, for a picture frame. I once made a wooden plane that really is my best plane; so I was thinking that I might be able to make what I need, putting a sharp chisel in it. How hard would that be ? If I do decide to purchase one, what's a good one?
I asked pretty much the same question last week. Yesterday my new Veritas shoulder plane was delivered. I haven't had time to assemble and tune it yet. However, it has that silky feel of quality, and was the overwhelming recommendation of my friends on the forum.
If you can't afford the Lee Valley medium shoulder plane, they do offer a clever little casting you can put a chisel in; see link below. I have no experience with this tool; it is listed as a Veritas plane, indicating that Lee Valley thinks it's worthy of the name.
That's almost exactly what I had in mind. The problem with it is that the blade appears to be about an inch behind the front, so you wouldn't be able to plane all the way up to some kind of stop. The problem in frame making, is that after the frame is glued up, the four rabbits, where the glass has to sit, aren't always exactly at the same height all the way around. In other words, it isn't good enough to be able to use the plane on the rabbits before glue up; you may want to use it after the four sides of the frame are glued up. Then the frame member at right angles to the one you're working on would act as a stop barrier.
Another thought - Ron Hock (Hocktools.com or something similar) sells a shoulder plane kit, and you mentioned that you liked the plane you made. I know this because I bought one, and I'll put it together as soon as I get the Christmas presents done! Just checked his website and the kit sells for $89.50 or you can buy just the blade for $28.
Shop Fox makes a line of Stanley knock-offs that include their shoulder and bull-nose planes and a version called a 3-in-1. It disassembles into a chisel plane. The line is very inexpensive but I cannot vouch for their quality.
Bullnose or chisel planes* are rather awkward tools for planing in the length of a rabbet - the short or non-existent nose means they tend to "dive" into the wood. My limited use of them has taught me to use a regular shoulder plane for the bulk of the work, with the bullnose limited to cleanup of the ends. You might find the 3-in-1 mentioned in another post in this thread interesting - but you'd find, in practice, that you were bopping back and forth between the functions all the time.
Still, for the specific use you're describing - light cleanup passes on a small rabbet - a bullnose or chisel plane might do the job. Just use a VERY sharp iron and similarly fine setting on the iron.
You could consider a design like that linked below - either buying or making. I have NO experience with this tool, and limited experience with chisel planes in general, but the price is low enough. I've seen other versions of this design; ECE makes one (http://www.traditionalwoodworker.com/Stop-Rabbet-Chisel-Plane-by-EC-Emmerich/productinfo/535-5858/), but it's more of an architectural millwork size. I would go for one of this design with the iron at 45 or so degrees, bevel down; rather than in the traditional shoulder plane design, low bedding and bevel up. I think you'd get a little less diving into the grain (in theory, this should not make a difference: the cutting angle is often the same. But I get less diving with a chisel when I present it to the work bevel down).
*Bullnose: short sole in front of the cutting edge; chisel plane: cutting edge is at the very front.