Re: Question for John Lucas
Steve Schoene
Shoe polish is basically tinted wax. There really are no top coat finishes that would be satisfactory applied over wax.
Wax itself offers very little protection to the wood surface. For that matter if enough wax were applied to give protection, the color would be in danger of rubbing off onto clothes or other objects.
Colored wax can make sense as a final step over finish coats, as a bit of glaze, but should never be used in a basic staining operation. To get a similar effect, but one which will allow coating with a durable finish would be to use a pigmented stain (including gel stain) over wood which as been dyed. The effect can be modified by the extent which the dye coat is sealed before using the pigmented stain.