Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Question for John Lucas

Posts

Question for John Lucas

#1

Question for John Lucas

Rick Snyder

Hello John,

Will you explain your the red dye and brown shoe polish techinque in your reply to JL about matching mahagony. It sounds interesting and I would like to try it. One question I have is, what would be the "end" finish (or is there one) after using that techinque?

Thanks, Rick Snyder

Re: Question for John Lucas

#2

Re: Question for John Lucas

john lucas

It's a very simple process. I just use whatever red dye I have and dye the wood. Then I rub brown or cordovan shoe polish into the wood. It darkens it a lot and makes it look kind of brownish burgundy if that's a good description. If it's too dark you can go over it with steel wool, which will take away some of the brown and make it more red. If you use it on porous woods of course the pores will be filled at least partially with wax. If you want a really smooth surface you will have to fill it two or three times.

I have applied different finishes directly over it without problems but whenever I'm in doubt I apply a thin shellac first.

I should say that red dye is one of the least light fast so if you want your piece to last use one of the metallic dyes. I have some pretty old ones that were done with standard Annaline dye and they still look fine but haven't been in direct sunlight for any time at all.

As with any finish I would run a test on scrap because I'm sure not all finishes are compatible with shoe polish.

Re: Question for John Lucas

#3

Re: Question for John Lucas

john lucas

I forgot to mention. You don't have to use red. You can tint the red with other dyes to change the final outcome. I keep red, green, blue, yellow, brown and black dyes in stock so I can mix any color I want. Keep notes so you can duplicate it.

Re: Question for John Lucas

#4

Re: Question for John Lucas

Steve Schoene

Shoe polish is basically tinted wax. There really are no top coat finishes that would be satisfactory applied over wax.

Wax itself offers very little protection to the wood surface. For that matter if enough wax were applied to give protection, the color would be in danger of rubbing off onto clothes or other objects.

Colored wax can make sense as a final step over finish coats, as a bit of glaze, but should never be used in a basic staining operation. To get a similar effect, but one which will allow coating with a durable finish would be to use a pigmented stain (including gel stain) over wood which as been dyed. The effect can be modified by the extent which the dye coat is sealed before using the pigmented stain.

Re: Question for John Lucas

#5

Re: Question for John Lucas

john lucas

I agree about the making the stain or dye to the color you want. That's what I do mostly now. However I have used the wax over dye finish on many pieces over the years and have not had a problem with it.