Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

Posts

Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

#1

JL

Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

JL

Mahogany plywood is ~$95 for veneer core and ~$85 for MDF core.

Not what I call real affordable.

I was thinking about getting maple plywood ~$53 and staining it to be mahogany colored. I've got to get five sheets and I didn't want to blow the project budget on plywood alone.

The project has to match or go with some "mahogany" laminate flooring.

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

#2

Two problems to solve

Bill Tindall

The "easy" one is matching color. The impossible one is matching texture as well as color. While paying $500 for the materials will cause temporary pain, attempting to make a silk purse from a sow's ear will result in lasting pain if the result is unsatisfying.

The easiest wood to color is basswood. It comes white and it takes stain uniformly, boringly so. We sold mountains of it to frame birch cabinets when birch plywood cabinets were popular. The cabinets were then stained this or that color.

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

#3

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I certainly am not a pro, but to my eye anytime I have seen something that was obviously tried to match but doesn't, as Bill as said in texture or grain, even if it does match color it strikes a disconcert chord. If you don't use mahogany, (which I would even if it hits the pocketbook once), I don't think you will be happy with the result. Another option that you may find acceptable is to use a contrasting wood. This may be your best option. IE: not try to match but search for a pleasing contrasting scheme. Then you could select from a variety of woods and colors and will looked like you planed it that way (which you did).

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

#4

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

paul in AZ

I agree with the others. There is very little that sticks out like a stained wood that almost but not exactly matches the color and grain of your floor. The same as paint or clothing. Being off a tiny bit can be an eyesore.

Unless you want to glue on more of the laminate to plywood to get an exact match a different wood in a complimentary color and texture would be my choice. Call it a design choice.

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

#5

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

For what it's worth, you might look for Butternut. I've heard it called "a poor man's mahogany". You would still need to color it but something worth checking out anyway.

Tom

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

#6

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

john lucas

JL I have done really nice burgundy mahagony look alikes by using light woods like Oak. I dye it red and then rub brown shoe polish all over it. the paste fills in the pores with a dark brown and the brown polish changes the red dye to a really nice burgundy brown that resembles some mahagony furniture finishes.

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

#7

I like the Contrasting Wood Idea

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Morning JL,

I'd surely give it consideration if it would compliment the surroundings. I've just finished a Guest Bedroon Suite which used disparate woods: cherry and brown-mahogany dyed SQ Sycamore. Cherry darkened naturally to make a delicious contrast of color and texture. Maybe the idea can work for you. Otherwise, bite the bullet.

George

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

#8

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

Thomas S Stockton

JL

A couple of random thoughts.

1. trying to dye maple to match mahogany is going to cause you way more than $50 a sheet in grief and hassle. If you do go this route high quality dye stains will be your friend, the pigment stuff doesn't work as well on maple.

2. The prices you were given are not out of line for any high quality sheet good, including maple. the less expensive stuff might be a rotary cut face or the face will not match etc.

3. like others have said contrast can be good but see #2, good quality ply is expensive.

4. I used to do a lot of high end built ins and it was pretty common to use pre finished maple for the interiors and high quality ply for all the visible surfaces. If the job was of frameless design I would edge band with whatever the outside was.

Tom

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

#9

JL

Thanks all - some good things to think about

JL

I will go ahead with maple plywood. I figure I can talk them into a reasonable contrasting stain.

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

#10

something to thank about  *LINK*

del schisler

I bet you will get so much blotching that you won't like it. Maple that i stained with this blotch control come out very good and the part that wasn't didn't come out very good. Go here and watch this video and you will see what i am talking about. It is mfd. by charles neil


http://www.youtube.com/profile?user=InTheWorkshop#p/u/36/IfCYMdrP8rM

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

#11

Me too

Yonak

I don't know what the project is but maybe you could go with a contrasting color with mahogany highlights.

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

#12

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

Paul Blackwell

I think butternut is "poor man's walnut" because of the similar grain pattern.

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

#13

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

Steve Schoene

Paulis right, except that walnut and mahogany have similar grain structure themselves.

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

#14

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

gary peterson

I like that idea with the shoe polish. How do you finish off the piece? Seal with shellac and go? I do not spray but use wipe-on mixtures. thanks gary

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

#15

Re: Suitable match for mahogany in looks?

TomD

What is "Mahogany" laminate flooring. Real mahogany is one thing. Mahogany plywood is normally a form of tropical pine and is not similar, or all that nice though I love it for boats. Mahogany flooring could be anything. If it is based on furniture grade mahogany it is not a match for most ply anyway. If it just means something redish brown, then it could be anything.

So while I agree with Bill, I also have no idea what is really the match here.