Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Windsor chair design

Posts

Windsor chair design

#1

Windsor chair design

GolfSteve in Calgary

A while ago I built a Shaker style Settee during a Rob Cosman course. The settee design is copied from an antique and I don’t care for the look of it. BUT it is very comfortable. I particularly like how flexible the back is. There are 15 spindles that taper from 1/2” to 3/8” on the settee:


I love the look of Windsor chairs. I’ve sat in a few that are extremely comfortable and in a lot more that are not so comfortable. True Windsor chairs are hard to find in this part of the world so I haven't have much opportunity to study them in person. I took a trip to Pennsylvania this spring which was very inspiring for an aspiring Windsor chairmaker.

I’d like to build a set of comb-back Windsor chairs. This style of chair should have the nice flexible back that I want. Most comb-backs appear to be arm chairs, but on the comb-back arm chairs that I’ve sat in, the bent arm rail often digs into my back. Attached is an extract of a sketch from page 22 of John Kassay’s “The Book of American Windsor Furniture”. I like the look of this chair but would like to eliminate the arm rail.


I also like the appearance of many fan-back chairs, but I think the two stiles will stiffen the back too much.

I’ve found a few examples of comb-back chairs that have eliminated the arm rail. Most have a modern or Shaker appearance – for example the following chair by Timothy Clark:

http://www.timothyclark.com/ch_wsidech.htm


or the Thos. Moser Eastward Chair:

http://www.thosmoser.com/product/85/eastward_chair/


Below is a preliminary sketch of my design. I’ve eliminated the arm rail and increased the number of spindles from 9 to 12 (I’ll probably reduce that to 10). I prefer an even number of spindles so that there isn’t a spindle centred on one’s spine. Any thoughts on this design? Anyone seen anything similar?


10 spindle version:


Thanks,

Steven

(and no, I won't be wearing a hard hat when standing next to my chair. When you design heavy industrial equipment for a living, your choices of "standard" people in AutoCAD are all wearing hard hats)

Re: Windsor chair design

#3

JL

Re: Windsor chair design

JL

Some thoughts on design.

Do you want to have side stiles as well as spindles?? Would you prefer beefier spindles? Do you want a tail brace?

When I make spindles, the narrowest part is usually on the order of 3/8" to 7/16". If I have a "bulb", it is usually on the order of 3/4" to 13/16". If you want side stiles or a tail brace, you can go with thinner spindles. If you don't want side stiles or a tail brace, you might want to go with beefier spindles (7/16" to 1/2").

As far as even or odd number of spindles - your choice. I usually go with an odd number as I can center one spindle on the crest and the center line of the chair seat and "walk" my dividers out along the crest bottom for the top holes.

Re: Windsor chair design

#4

Re: Windsor chair design

GolfSteve in Calgary

No, I don't want to have side-spindles (like a fan-back). I think this will stiffen the back too much. I'd like to keep slender spindles perhaps 9/16 at the bottom and 3/8 at the top (by 26" long, which is hard to turn). I do not want a tail brace.

I might put a bulb onto the spindles at about 1/3 of their height.

I assume I'll have to to some steam bending to get the arc on the spindles - splaying both outwards and backward at the same time. I haven't really drawn it 100% correct. That might get tricky.

I'll probably build a quick and dirty mock up using 3/8' dowels for the spindles to get an idea of how flexible the back will be and see if it seems sturdy enough - but I won't get around to it until after Christmas.

Re: Windsor chair design

#5

JL

Re: Windsor chair design

JL

You probably won't have to steam bend the spindles to get the arc.

Usually if you have 3/8" - 7/16" thickness for the majority of the spindle length, you can get enough splay/bend in the spindles.

You are correct in the long spindles being hard to turn. You have several choices. One choice is to do it the old fashioned way with drawknife and spokeshave. Another is to rough turn the spindles (I recommend using hickory if you do it this way) using a spindle steady. After they are rough turned, use a trapping plane to get them thinner and round. Ashem Crafts in Britain has such a tool (NOT inexpensive).


Re: Windsor chair design

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: Windsor chair design

Moses Yoder

I really like the look of the Timothy Clark chair. On your chair design, you have kept the heavily embellished spindles of the base, removed the visual focus of the arms, and kept the fancy crest. To me it doesn't look right. In my opinion if you are going to remove the arm, it would look better with the plain base and a little plainer crest, similar to the Clark chair. Also without the arms there, it looks like the back goes up too high. We don't have dimensions so it is kind of hard to see where it would come on your back, but I think it should be around shoulder height.