Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

A different Shop Vac question

Posts

A different Shop Vac question

#1

A different Shop Vac question

Barry Irby

Did not want to hijack Ellis' thread.

Can somebody explain the bags for shop vacs you use for fine dust like drywall or sanding dust?

What is it and where does it go? Do you just slip it over the filter or does it serve as a drum liner? Can you reuse them or do you toss each one? Do they reduce suction? Are they worth the trouble, whatever trouble they may be? Cost? Where to buy them? What else do I need to know?

Re: A different Shop Vac question

#2

Re: A different Shop Vac question

Jim Toews

Barry,

I own a Shop Vac brand vacuum. The bag friction-fits over the intake pipe and fills the vac tank. In my case it works very well for capturing fine dust, but it greatly diminishes the vac capacity, which generally is not a problem for me since I rarely have the need to suck up lots of fine dust. (I have a Sears shop vac with a Dust Devil for most chips/sawdust (and a broom for hand plane shavings!).)

I hope this helps.

Cheers!

Jim

Re: A different Shop Vac question

#3

Re: A different Shop Vac question

Dave Paine

Barry,

I think there are several designs. Many years ago I had a Sears vac, looked like a Shop Vac brand.

I purchased a cartridge filter which would quickly fill with debris and was not easy to clean. I used to get the Shop Vac bags which fitted OVER the cartridge. This was a tight fit. I think they were intended to go over a plastic frame. These made it easier to knock off the debris and were eventually replaced when they tore. I used this trick for many years.

I later got a Ridgid unit and an after market pleated cartridge which was intended to be easier to clean, even washable. This was larger and so I did not find bags I could use to place over, so for this unit I had to clean with brush and compressed air.

I now have a Fein and its bags attach to the inside of the hose connection and so collect the debris somewhat like a liner. The difference is the 1 1/4in hole means MUCH less dust when it is time to replace the bag. These are paper and can tear, which then means I have to clean out the cartridge.

If your unit is not designed for a bag which connects to the hose, then you can either place plastic bags as liners, and be prepared to clean your cartridge, or perhaps you can find bags which will fit over your cartridge and use the plastic bags to make it easier to dump the debris.

Using any paper bag effectively means you should not use the unit in "wet" mode. I have a cloth filter if I need to convert my machine for "wet" service.

Re: A different Shop Vac question

#4

Re: A different Shop Vac question

paul in AZ

IMO those bags are not worth the bother. I have an old Sears cheapie that is used mostly for saw and sanding dust but has been used for drywall. I have never replaced the cartridge. Every now and then I pull the filter cartridge, take it outside and hose it out well. It takes a day or so to dry.

Complaining about the filter plugging up too fast is complaining that it works too well. Its SUPPOSED to catch all the dust.

Re: A different Shop Vac question

#5

Re: A different Shop Vac question

John McGaw

I have a Fein Turbo III and use the bags along with the HEPA filter. I find that this unit has enough power that any reduction of the suction due to the bag is not a great concern and they do keep the HEPA from getting packed with super-fine dust which is quite difficult to clean out of the little pleats. Some folks complain about the cost of the bags themselves but I buy them online and with a bit of searching I can usually find them for a reasonable price and when I do I buy a dozen.

Re: A different Shop Vac question

#6

Re: A different Shop Vac question

Jason in OC

I have used both the bags and a HEPA filter (not at the same time) and I much prefer the bags. With the bags you remove the full one, toss it, install the new one and you're done. With the filter you have to dump the canister, then beat, brush or wash the filter, which takes time and liberates a fair amount of the fine dust you were trying to control. The HEPA filter canister will lose suction as the filter clogs. I have not noticed much loss with the bags. The bags are generally available at the borgs, usually where the shop vacs are being sold. As noted, the bag attaches where the hose enters the canister.

Re: A different Shop Vac question

#7

Re: A different Shop Vac question

Don Evans

Shop Vac brand makes two different Vacuums, I have the one that uses both cartridge and bag at the same time. They also make 2 different bags for them. These are the large bags (not ones that go over the cartridge filter). These bags and vac's are also wet/dry, you remove both the bag and the cartridge for wet work.

You have to take care purchasing these vac's (Shop Vac) as one on sale is probably one that doesn't use the HEPA cartridge which wraps around the motor.

On the 2 different bags, one is white and other is yellow. I believe the yellow one's are for the fine stuff like dry wall dust. For general work around the shop, like cleaning floor etc I use the HEPA and the white bags. It works very well.

Lowe's carries these vac's, bags and the HEPA cartridges. I've had this vac for 12 years and will buy another when this one goes to Vac Heaven.

Don

ps: to make this little more clear, some of their vac's only use a bag, no HEPA in them, I don't recommend those, only one that uses both at same time.