Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Shop Vacs

Posts

Shop Vacs

#1

Ellis Walentine

Shop Vacs

Ellis Walentine

My daughter wants to buy a shop vac for her husband, so, naturally, she asked me which one to buy and where to get it. I haven't a clue. I have a 16-gal. Ridgid that I bought over ten years ago, and it has been quite satisfactory. Before that, I owned a Sears shop vac that also did the job, though it was as loud as a jet engine.

If you were looking for a shop vac nowadays, which brand and size would you choose and why? And if you wanted to spend less than $100 on a shop vac, how would that influence your decision?

Thanks for any suggestions.

Ellis

Re: Shop Vacs

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Shop Vacs

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I don't think there's a whole lot of difference between the units that are sub-$100. I've had several ShopVac brand units, and maybe a Craftsman or two thrown in over the years. For the last 10 years or so, they been acceptably quiet (to me), though mis-treatment can result in them getting louder before they expire. Rain is not kind to them. Also, drywall dust is very bad if sucked up without a bag.

I generally only get about 5 years out of a ShopVac, but that's using it on the job and toting it around quite a bit. I suspect they would last much longer if only used occasionally around the house and home-type shop.

Jason

Re: Shop Vacs

#3

Whatever you do ...

Mike Farinella

make sure you click on the WC link to say Amazon to purchase.

(Gotcha!)

Re: Shop Vacs

#4

Re: Shop Vacs

Ken Oakley- Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

I have had 3 Shop Vacs in the past 30 years. Very few problems. Good Customer support the one time I needed it.

Re: Shop Vacs

#5

A.J. Hamler

Re: Shop Vacs

A.J. Hamler

I tend to agree with Jason that under $100, they're very similar. Not sure what Ridgids are going for these days, but if they're in the under-$100 group I'd probably favor one of those. Heard many good things about them.

However, I still maintain that the Fein vacs are the absolute best on the market. They're pricey, but they're both quieter and more powerful than anything out there. And they last forever, which mitigates the high price a bit. My Mini Turbo (now the Turbo I, I think) is at least 13 years old.

A.J.

Re: Shop Vacs

#6

Ridgid

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I've had a larger one in the shop for more than 10 years and a small (10 gal.) version in the garage. I put the extra-fine filter on the shop version because I use it as a DC for my sanders and to sand drywall.

BTW, the exhaust muffler does work, but the machine is still pretty loud.

Re: Shop Vacs

#7

JL

Re: Shop Vacs

JL

I have two Ridgid shop vacs. I picked up one last year as a Black Friday special.

I would buy Ridgid again - though not with a 1 7/8" hose - those hoses are too "flimsy".

I also bought a Shop Vac for the playhouse a couple of years ago. I was not impressed. The unit is too load and hasn't really lasted.

Re: Shop Vacs

#8

Re: Shop Vacs

Barry Irby

I too have an old Craftsman Vac I have had for thirty years. That thing howls like a Banshee but it really sucks.

It got left on a job fifty miles away so I bought a Shop Vac brand door buster special at Lowe's about two years ago to tide me over. It was cheap, Real cheap, but it is pitiful in the suction department and I would not buy another. I put a larger hose on it to improve the suction and I think the hose kit cost 60% of the unit. Helped, but not much. In fact, I am looking to replace it because its such a piece of crap.

A friend gave me a small (6 gallon) Rigid unit. Its old and out of production but similar to the current units. I replaced the filter and it is clearly more powerful that the Shop Vac. The same unit sells for about $70 at HD. Have not had it long, but based on that, I would buy another. I would have bought a larger unit, perhaps 12 or 14 gal.

The rigid units at the Depoe have labels on the boxes that list some statistics like air flow and CFM or whatever, but the point is they at least give you a comparison unit to unit. IIRC Shop Vac does not.

FWW the Tools and Shop issue just reported on shop vacs. Recommended the Bosch unit that is about $550. I love to have one, but I can't stand the money. That unit cleans its own filter. (For that price it should clean the shop too.)

A side note in the section was that the best buy was "your shop vac" Coupled with the Dust Right Vortex pre-separator from Rockler. They claim the Vortex unit, Similar to the Dust Deputy will pull out such a large percentage of the dirt, even the fines, that the vac stays virtually empty. I would like to have one of the units and may order one and couple it with my vac.

What I don't understand is: those separator unit look pretty simple. Why doesn't somebody manufacture one with a very small but powerful vac built in as a single unit with a double chamber? Why do I have to wrestle with two awkward units and a bunch of hoses?

Re: Shop Vacs

#9

Flexible hose

Pat Evans

If anyone makes a shop vac with a truly flexible hose, I'd recommend that one. The hard plastic "flexible" hoses are so stiff that trying to twist the hose to reach a spot results in the shop vac moving across the floor. I miss the old fabric hoses with the metal spiral.

Re: Shop Vacs

#10

Re: Shop Vacs

steve mackay

I'd have to stick with The "C-word". Never let me down. Never a problem. And I really like the new filters with the "closed" bottom (only a hole for the through-bolt). That alone makes the filter last twice as long.

(but your right, they DO sound like a C-5 on take off ! MORE POWER !)

Re: Shop Vacs

#11

Re: Shop Vacs

Dave Paine

Ellis,

I have a Rigid unit. Still "kicking" and still sounding like a Jet engine.

Some years ago I splurged on a Fein Turbo III at a WW show. I do not regret the purchase. I use this all the time. It is so quiet even my wife does not complain when she uses it to clean out her car.

I love being able to use my shop vac without worry of ear damage over time.

Just be prepared for sticker shock. Look around the sites these can be on sale. The old adage "buy the best and only cry once" comes to mind.

The Fein and Festtool are expensive, but in these cases, due to getting what you pay for. I think my Fein has two motors, one for suction and one to cool the motor. Even if only 1 motor, it is not one of the screaming universal motors so common in shop vacs. It also has a switched outlet, which I use with my random orbit sander.

The Fein and Festtool also have some of the better "head" ratings (height of equivalent water column which reflects amount of suction).

Re: Shop Vacs

#12

Use both Ridgid and Craftsman 12 ga Every Day

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Morning Ellis

I use both brands every day since my shop is comprised of two non-contiguous rooms. Both work well. The size is adequate, so the task of emptying them isn't too frequent. For household use, the 12 ga models are about the largest I'd buy. My wife loves them, and sometimes lugs one upstairs when extra suction is needed. After market tools are easy to come by and not overly expensive. I will agree that the hoses are too stiff, and I dislike the way the power cord keeps hanging up on the casters as the machine is dragged around. I'd give the edge to the Ridgid because of a severe Craftsman bias.

George

Re: Shop Vacs

#13

Re: Shop Vacs

nickinmass

I was going to put in another vote for a Fein (I have the mini turbo, maybe 10 years old), but I just got a look at what they are going for - yikes! The Feins are quiet and have great suction,but I would be hard pressed to justify paying the current price unless I were using the vac for applications where little air was moving through the hose - the Feins use bypass motor cooling, so aren't dependent on airflow through the hose...

Re: Shop Vacs

#14

too fine a filter

Jerry Gibbs

In my opinion most shop vacs have too fine a filter. If the filter is not rigorously maintained, the filter is bypassed and dust is spread from the floor to the air. I was recently in a classroom where several vacs were turned on at the same time and you could see the dust in the air. The would not be so bad if the filters were easier to clean or cheap and disposable. Enough rant- happy leftovers. Jerry

Re: Shop Vacs

#15

Re: too fine a filter

Dan arrowsmith

Has anybody tried using a shop vac with the regular filter and then using the exhaust connected to a second shop vac that has a hepa filter installed. Seems to me would be a cheap way of maximizing the life of the hepa filter and you have two vacs for other uses.

Re: Shop Vacs

#16

Re: too fine a filter

Jason in OC

I used a ShopVac with the stock filter to clean the ash out of my pellet stove about once a week. After a few weeks I thought I should empty the canister. When I opened it, the canister was empty. That is when I learned about drywall bags.

Re: Shop Vacs

#17

Re: Shop Vacs

Don Evans

Ellis:

See my post in thread just above.

Recommend "SHOP VAC" brand that uses HEPA and bag at same time. The size isn't important but mine is 6 gal cause of walking room in my shop is limited. I don't use it for dust collection either which could impact the decision.

Don

Re: Shop Vacs

#18

Re: Shop Vacs

Bob Entwisle in NJ

I've been using a Ridged WD1650, 16gal. w/detachable blower, for about 10-12 years. (looks like the current WD 1680 is similar, at $119.00).

It's a bit noisy, I have the 'muffler' attachment on it and think that drops the sound level down a minor amount. It mostly stays in a corner of the shop, I have a long hose on it, maybe 25ft?, and a wireless remote control, so I just grab the hose and remote and use it where I need it in the shop. It occasionally see's use around the house, for project cleanup, as well as a couple of water cleanup duties over the years. I'd replace it with another if it ever goes down.

Likes: Short squat design, means a low center of gravity, so is not prone to tipping over when dragged around by the hose.

It has been reliable so far.

The detachable blower makes it convenient to clean, I can remove the blower/motor assembly from the lid and bucket, and then take a garden hose to the lid and bucket every couple of years.

Dislikes: It's noisy. The hose is a bit stiff.

I'd love to upgrade to one of the Fein vacs, more for the noise factor than anything else, but the Ridged is 1/3 the price and does the job for me.

Bob in NJ

Re: Shop Vacs

#19

Re: Use both Ridgid and Craftsman 12 ga Every Day

Joseph Mulherin

George, I suggest you try using a different hose for vacumming without having to move the vac around a great deal...use a swimming pool vacuum hose...1 1/2" x 16-25ft...curl it up on a couple pegs on the wall.

And, to quiet down the very loud noise from the exhausts....try using some 2" PVC tubing from the vac outlet, turn down with a 90, drill holes in a 2x12" piece and stuff it loosely with some insulation. If a screw on cap is used at the bottom you can replentish the insulation at any time in case it get clogged. It works on my Craftsman 5.0 HP vac very nicely.

Re: Shop Vacs

#20

Good Tips, Joe

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

With a longer flex hose like a swimming pool hose, I could build a rack to accommodate both the vacuum and auxiliary tank, making it a two stage device. Perhaps it could live in a corner and not interfere with other tools' mobility.

George

Re: Shop Vacs

#21

Bart Goldberg

Rigid In My Experience

Bart Goldberg

has been a great shop vac. I bought a large unit over 10 years ago and used it in my shop till I bought a Fein with a tool activation switch. The Ridged was moved to the garage and still work great. It think it has a Lifetime Warranty from Home Depot. I agree with Mark about the muffler; it works well, but the vacuum is still real loud. Also , I did add one of those aftermarket Gortex filters that HD used to sell.

Re: Shop Vacs

#22

Re: Good Tips, Joe

Joseph Mulherin

You are welcome, George. Try the3 muffler I suggested...it does work to quiet down the exhaust a great deal.

With using the 1 1/2' POOL HOSE make sure that NO large chunks get sucked up the hose...just saw dust and shavings from router is all.

Re: Shop Vacs

#23

Re: Shop Vacs

Jay Lombardo

if memory serves me the old Craftsman and the current Ridgid vacs are (were) both built by Emerson tool company. Probably explains the similarities. I have an old 16 gal Craftsman that still works great. Yes it sounds like a bomber taking. If I had to replace it I would get a comparable Ridgid.

Re: Shop Vacs

#24

Ridgid with Scroll Noise Reduction

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

Ellis - If it isn't too late to chime in, I bought a Ridgid vac with SNR (Scroll Noise Reduction) as a Christmas present to myself last year. I think it is 12 or 14 gallons. I added the exhaust muffler and it is relatively quiet, sucks like crazy and works pretty well. Don't bother with the 1 1/4 inch hose - I wanted it for connecting to my sander, etc, but it is too small and too heavy.

The little tool bag works ok. The thingies that hold the extensions are a waste of plastic; someday I will have to rework it.

Robby Wright

San Marcos, CA