Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

OT - large flat screens

Posts

OT - large flat screens

#1

OT - large flat screens

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

Thinking maybe 37+ inches. LCD or plasma?

Not planning on broadcast TV, just for movies and tutorials.

ISP connection not fast enough for streaming - live in an old technologially deprived part of town, which allows me to pay the same amount as areas with much faster speeds, but don't let's go there!

Plan to use DVD's for content.

What do I want to consider?

What do I need, feature-wise?

What other gizmos do I need?

Re: OT - large flat screens

#2

Re: OT - large flat screens

Tony - memphis

I'm not much of a tv person. We don't have cable - just antennas. I recently bought a new Samsung for our excercise room (that's when I watch tv!). I have been extremely impressed. I was hesitant to buy this brand since I had no experience with them. It's a basic tv, nothing fancy. It has a PC hookup and two USB connections, HDMI, etc. I have an 802.11 adapter for it to connect to Windows via tehir DNLA or some such, but i haven't played with that yet. Our blu-ray player gives us access to Netflix and all that stuff, so we didn't need those capabilities built into the tv (this made our model much more affordable). I went to Best Buy at lunch one day and looked at the models that stood out. Picked this on based on price and reviews. Also, our "old" tv is a Sharp Aquos 37". That is a great tv too. Oh, I ordered both of these from Amazon and had no issues. Oh, and they are both LCD's. The pictures are incredible. To qualify, I am not a tv junkie, I usually only watch what I record while I am excercising, we haven't had cable for 15 years or so, and the tv we replaced with the sharp was a 20" RCA with an analog tuner. I have two antennas in the attic and with the digital tuners nowadays, we get excellent pictures - no more fuzz or ghosts! Great sound too.

Tony

Re: OT - large flat screens

#3

Re: OT - large flat screens

John McGaw

What are the viewing conditions to be? If you will be in an area where you cannot dim the lighting LCD is the only way to go but if you can reduce the lighting then plasma is just about impossible to beat. Typically LCD uses less power than plasma in the same size. If you will be using a blueray player then you will absolutely want a set which does 1080P. Personally I would go to something larger than 37" if the viewing distance warrants. I have a 42" LCD which works well at my viewing distance of 10 feet.

Re: OT - large flat screens

#4

Sort of agree

Dustmaker Mike

Here is how I judge the size you will need to be happiest. What I do is measure the distance I will be sitting from the TV. It does not matter the size of the room just the distance from your seat. Next go to the store Best Buy or were ever and stand about that far away. When the picture becomes to big and not looking so good go down one size that is the size set you need. Most people can not tell the difference between 720 and 1080 on most sets so the next thing to look at is your own eyes. Just because it looks clear in the store and the one next to it does not is no reason to count one out. A lot of places take it out of the box plug it in and leave it alone. See if you can adjust it to look better to you. The brighter the room the harder it is to see any TVs LED is a little better then an LCD Plasma is what I have in my room and it get lots of bright sun light and I have no problem seeing it. At night it seems kind of to bright. If you drive by a house and can see the TV flashing all over inside that is to bright. As for DVD or Blue Ray I would go Blue Ray. I have seen a lot of problems with the Vizeo brand as well as the older Samsung sets. If you get a good one of these they last if they fail they stay that way. My two bits

Re: OT - large flat screens

#5

Re: OT - large flat screens

Bill P.

Plasma is the way to go for movies. They have good black levels and color reproduction. They're not as sensitive to burn in like earlier versions. They do use a little more power but if it's only used for movie viewing I'm sure you won't notice. Plasma has less blur during fast motion too. I think they have a little better picture quality while viewing standard definition also. The recommended distance for viewing HDTV's is 1.5-2.0 times the picture size. EX. My 54" plasmas optimal viewing distance is 6.75-9.0 ft.

Re: OT - large flat screens

#6

Check out

Gary Smyth

"Optimal Viewing Distance, Television" and "What is Your TV Resolution"on your browser. There are several choices you can read. I suggest you use SMPTE (Society of Mothin Picture and Television Engineers) standards They are up to date and used by the TV manufacturers.

There was a time I could spout off the correct data and advise the best viewing distance to be six times screen width for the older repeating line resolution 3:4 TVs. The digital standard is probably a bit higher, perhaps seven. By the way do not buy a floor model as they typically have 1000 hours on them before they are changed out.

Re: OT - large flat screens

#7

Re: OT - large flat screens

Jesse Cloud

Lots of good advice above. One riff I would add is that large screen TVs are a rare occasion where it may make sense to buy the extended warranty. Consumer reports suggested this a few years ago. Apparently, they are extremely sensitive to power surges and unlike older TVs, everything is on the mother board, so repairs are very expensive. I scoffed at that advice and then wound up tossing a three year old unit. The repairs would have cost almost the retail price of a new and better TV.

Re: OT - large flat screens

#8

Re: OT - large flat screens - failed to ask

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

the right questions, evidently. The conversation got off on size which I did not ask about. The most lucid advise thus far is plasma for movies over LED and get a good surge protector and buy the extended warrently. Some talk about BluRay and DVD's whic I did not understand and motherboards. There is a mother board in a TV?

So what's the deal about BluRay and DVD's? I have tutorial DVD's I want to watch and I thought an occasional trip to a Red Box for a movie. No connection to the Internet (connection not nearly fast enough) and no cannection to broadcast TV (nothing worth watching), antennae, cable or otherwise. I hope this clears up my questions. Now if we could just clear up my confusion...LOL!

Re: OT - large flat screens

#9

Re: OT - large flat screens - failed to ask

Bill Howatt

Blu-ray is a higher definition DVD they are the same physical size but the information content is formatted differently. A blu-ray player will play standard DVDs but not the other way around. Blu-ray is obviously the newer standard but most movies still come in both formats. Your tutorials are very likely standard DVDs.

There used to be a gap between LCD and plasma. What each did better was definitely better but now the general feeling is that the issues have been reduced considserably and either will be fine. You also sound very practical so rather than worrying about screen gloss, black levels and blurring you will be paying attention to your programming rather than watching the pixels for the sake of the pixels. Crap is still crap whether in standard definition or high-definition.

Yes there is a motherboard in the TV and probably has more than one computer chip in it. While I normally shun extended warranties the TV is a good item to have it on. A repair can run several hundred dollars and that is if the replacement parts are available. Some stores offer discounts on your next purchase if you never have to use the warranty.

You do want to get the best possible picture from your DVD player. If your player isn't real new it probably won't have a HDMI connector and will use component video. You probably don't understand this so I recommend you take your DVD player manual with you to the store to ensure your TV will have the connectors for the best picture. If you don't have the manual just take in the player to be certain. Most TVs have lots of input signal flexibility but this will eliminate one area of concern.

Bill

Re: OT - large flat screens

#10

Re: OT - and don't pay $$$$ for HDMI cable


Re: OT - large flat screens

#11

Re: OT - and don't pay $$$$ for HDMI cable

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

Bill's response is most helpful.

But Bob, explain about the cables, please.

As for the player. I expect to get a new one. What I have is a Wally World $39 special several years old. So I should look at BluRay. Anything about that I should know before I subject myself to the younger generation of techno turks at the store?

Re: OT - large flat screens

#12

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT - large flat screens

Jesper, Denmark

You can never go wrong with a Sony. Both the TV set and the player should be the same brand - so they are guaranteed to work easily together and respond to hte same remote.

LED is preferable - lower power consumption, especially on stand-by. LED is LCD with LED's as the light source.

MP4 tuner ensures a future security for receiving HD from either the air or some sort of cable/internet.

Forget about 3D - it is not yet practical.

You will probably find that screen sizes smaller than 40 inches are not common, so that or even 46 inch is the way to go.

The Blueray player will also play the older DVD discs.

Both will have both SCART connectors and Ethernet connectors. The Ethernet connectors are both simplest and best.

If you have a wireless LAN, most Sony sets will connect to it, and you can play stuff from your PC or laptop on the TV - Powerpoint presentations as an example.

Personally, I find extended warranties are a dodge. Think about it - it's just a way to part you from more money.

Re: OT - large flat screens

#13

Re: OT - and don't pay $$$$ for HDMI cable

Allen Bryant - Bumpass, VA

Unless you have a very long run (like 30+ feet) from the DVD / Blue Ray player, the difference in quality between a $20 and a $100 HDMI cable would be hardly noticeable if you could even tell, and for most people they could only tell if the two TV's sat side by side and then the differences are negligible. I spent about $25 on mine just because I needed it to be 15 feet and HD pictures look just fine to me.

As for features in a blue ray player, the latest is the ability to connect it up to the internet. I believe you said that you lived in a technologically challenged area. I do as well, with satellite being our only option besides dial up for internet. Because of this I don't subscribe to netflix or any other streaming video service. So for me and maybe for you being able to connect to the internet may not be a requirement. If it isn't you could save some money and get a little bit cheaper model that will play the blue ray discs just fine.

Re: OT - large flat screens

#14

SCART Probably Doesn't Apply

John McGaw

I believe that SCART is pretty much a European standard. I've never seen a piece of equipment with SCART on this side of the Atlantic. After all, a connector with a French name like "Syndicat des Constructeurs d'Appareils Radiorécepteurs et Téléviseurs" was probably made illegal under some covert [redacted reference to a USA political party] law passed during the time of 'Freedom Fries'. ;)

Re: OT - large flat screens

#15

Re: OT - large flat screens - another ?

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

Allen brought up a point with regard to my current situation and perhaps not buying the very latest technology because I currently live in a technological museum. But I do not expect to be here longer than 2 years. The next location may well be a techno-heaven. How far down the road do you soothsayers think I might look with regard to the speed of technology in this environment?

Re: OT - large flat screens

#16

Re: OT - and don't pay $$$$ for HDMI cable

Steve Schoene

Even $20 is more than you need to pay for a HDMI cable. Try www.monoprice.com and you can find a good quality cable for under $5 I bet.

Why talk about the cable? The HDMI connection is currently the best way to get a good connection between DVD or BluRay players and the TV.

I don't think you can get a plasma as small as 37", or at least you would have to hunt for it. I'd stay with LCD. TVs labeled just LCD have flourescent back lighting which works OK. The ones labeled LED or LED/LCD have LED backlighting instead of the flourescent backlight. This makes for a bit better picture apparently, but also makes for a much thinner TV if that makes a difference.

Consumer reports has an issue currently on newsstands that you might find useful. They commented that LCD brands with consistently high performance were LG, Panasonic, Samsung, and Sony. The next tier down, would include Hitachi, Insignia, and Visio according to CR. They would pretty much avoid all other brands.

Re: OT - large flat screens

#17

Re: OT - large flat screens - another ?

Allen Bryant - Bumpass, VA

The next big thing in TV's seems to be 3D, at least for me prices and application of the technology has not reached a usable level for me to even consider upgrading. The replacement for blu ray technology is still in the design phase and years away from mainstream production. Anything you buy now would still be useful in 2 years.

Re: OT - large flat screens

#18

Re: OT - large flat screens LONG reply

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Carol, I will give my opinion for what it is worth. I bought a new TV about a year ago and did a lot of research prior to the purchase. First as to size, I realize you have a certain size in mind but I think you will find the best prices in a 42 inch - at least in this area Best Buy, H H Gregg and Wally world all seem to promote this size as the entry level. After several hours of online research and talking to friends and salespersons at several stores, I settled on an LG. They seem to have the best reviews and according to the sales persons the least returns/repairs of all the sets. In addition the LG prices seem to be on the lower side of the top brands. I have had Panasonic, Sony, Toshiba and LG - so far the LG is my favorite. Almost all Blue Ray and DVD players currently on the market have HDMI hookup. This is probably the simplest and best connection - It carries the full video signal and audio. The prices have dropped considerably in the last year - I have read that Japan is considering getting out of the manufacturing market since the Korean TVs have improved so much and the pricing is below the Japanese capability. As far as purchasing something that may be useful in the next few years - I would not concern myself about the future as it may change and pricing may go way down on newer technology before you need it. I do recommend purchasing the extended warranty. I seldom ever purchase one except for this appliance. As others have said the cost of repair often is a large fraction of or exceeds the purchase price. In my case I have used the extended warranty on the last 3 TV's I have purchased. The last one (a Toshiba rear projection 46 inch) started giving me problems after 4 years and 8 months of service. When they ordered the part to repair the unit, it was unavailable. After a bit of haggling, I ended up replacing the set with a $2,400 TV for about $1,000. It has all the internet connections etc. which after a year I have not used. I have the ATT U-Verse, with this service all of the internet options are not needed as they are available from the ATT receiver. Other providers such as Comcast in this area also provide similar access to the internet material. Therefore I wouldn't look to purchase it for additional cost in the TV. As far as the other options you will see 120 and 240 frame speed. This may be important to some who watch a lot of sports as the faster frame speeds reduce "blur" when viewing an object moving very rapidly. I have looked at various sets and personally I can't tell the difference. As far as reliability, the LED/LCD (usually stated as LED), seem to hold the edge as the fluorescent back-light styles and plasma sets both lose brightness far faster than the LED. The sharpest picture is produced by the 1080 P (progressive scan), then the 1080 I ( interlaced scan) the lowest HD TV resolution is 720 P (progressive scan) - it is almost identical to the 1080 I in my opinion. You should look at these models in the showroom to see what (if any difference) the resolution makes to your eyes. As others have said, be sure to have the sets you are interested in adjusted while you watch to determine what you want.

Re: OT - large flat screens

#19

6-7 years

Bruce, a MN Galoot

we just bought a Samsung 37" very similar to the one you're contemplating (our cable provider switched to all digital and our 23-year old set became obsolete) and bought the set at Best Buy. We asked a question about the longevity of the thing, compared to the 23 years of service we got out of our old set. The sales gal said that they only last 6-7 years anyway. Of course, that has a lot to do with how much you actually watch it.

Ours is the LED model. If absolutely nothing else, the picture is light years better than the old one. Why, we can actually read the score box on our alma mater's hockey games!

Re: OT - large flat screens

#20

Carol, my opine ...

Mike Farinella

Lots of good info here. Suggest you buy an LED - lower power consumption and a beautiful picture. Sony, Samsung and Sharp are the best.

BTW, how's your humongous oak table coming along. Need help?

Best regards, Mike

Re: OT - large flat screens

#21

Re: Carol, my opine ...

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

Thanks, Mike. I'll keep you in mind. LOL!

The large screen is intended to be my Christmas present. I'd like to watch a movie once in a while.

The oak table is in pieces and ready for clean-up. I have been gone 3 out of the last 4 1/2 weeks. Yesterday I finally got around to wiring for the saw and lathe. Haven't checked it out yet though. Today is our Thanksgiving service and tomorrow is serving at the Community Thanksgiving service. Hard to find time. Definitely have to get the next glue up on the altar done soonest.

Can I crash the woodworking guild's Christmas party or would that be considered ill-mannered? I am going back to Arizona right after Christmas and will bring back another load. I have a bunch of woodworking books I could bring and donate to the guild if they have/want a library. What do you think?

Re: OT - large flat screens

#22

Sound Quality

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

The thinner the unit, it seems, the worse the sound. Our 3-year-old 32" Toshiba has much better sound quality then our new, ultra-thin 42" Toshiba. The solution proposed by the store was to buy a $250 "sound bar". Not what I wanted to hear.

Re: OT - large flat screens

#23

Re: Sound Quality

Hank Knight

TV sound has been a particular problem for me. I have a significant high frequency hearing loss and TV sound has always seemed garbled. I probably got 50% of the dialog and music was almost a total loss. I bought a Sony 46" flat screen HDTV six weeks ago (love it) and splurged on a good Polk Audio sound bar with a remote sub woofer. The sound bar is much less obtrusive than a big 5-speaker home theater system and very easy to connect - one HDMI cable. What a difference the sound bar makes! Finally I can hear most of what is said on my TV, and music sounds great. Should have done it years ago!

Hank

Re: OT - large flat screens

#24

Re: Sound Quality

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

Thanks, Hank. Your hearing sounds like a page out of my book. I'll look into it!

Re: OT - large flat screens

#25

Re: Carol, my opine ...

Mike Farinella

Jim Stoltz is the Gran Poobah or leader of the guild and loves new people. He's a personable kinda guy. Just show up and ask for Jim and say Mike Farinella recommended this organization. All are VERY nice people.