Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

Posts

OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#1

JL

OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

JL

I've been getting quotes from a variety of vendors for the playhouse where I volunteer. This covers lighting, sound and curtains. We got a nice challenge grant that is going to cover quite a bit of new stuff.

I worked with one vendor securing lighting quotes and ironing out a system. I was doing due diligence and getting competing quotes. I got a couple of quotes for similar systems that were less expensive, but not as good quality (dimmer modules weren't as good). So anyway, I got a quote that was basically $5K less from another vendor. This is for essentially the same system, but with some amenities. What do I "owe" the first vendor?

They are reliable suppliers and the guy who is doing the system work is having a rough fall in his personal life. So I do feel somewhat "guilty" in giving the contract to someone else. However $5K is $5K. I can afford a decent sound system with the savings as opposed to having to cobble something up.

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#2

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

DocJim

I think that your first loyalty is to the playhouse that you are representing. That said I think there is nothing wrong in asking the supplier you worked with if there is any room in his quote.

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#3

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

Randy Johnson

If I understand you correctly, the 5K cheaper bid is for a system that is pretty much the same as the “better” one that you prefer.

The question I would be asking is not what I owe the first vendor. The question I would be asking, is WHY a comparable (in materials) bid is 5K cheaper. Something doesn’t smell right here.

I live in an area where just about anybody that wants to can get a magnetic sign for the door of their pickup, print a few business cards, and become a contractor. Although it varies from city to city and county to county, there is no such thing as a State License for electricians in Indiana. There is a requirement for a State License to do plumbing for hire but it isn’t rigidly enforced in rural areas and smaller towns.

The result, is “contractors” who, even if THEY know what they are doing, (and all too often they don’t) employ the cheapest help they can get. This help seldom has a clue how to do a quality job. There are a lot of people who only see the cheapest price. The shade tree contractors can always outbid someone who is operating on the up and up and employing qualified tradesmen.

Years ago I needed a new furnace. I got three bids. Two were less than a hundred bucks apart at around $1500. The third was around $800. Knowing how the system works around here, I didn’t even consider the $800 bid. It ain’t always about price.

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#4

JL

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

JL

The second vendor is quite reputable. It sells curtains, lights, rigging, etc. It has been in business since the mid 1930s.

The second vendor's prices are $5-10 cheaper per instrument - so that's about $300 right there. The light board (same light board) is $600 less expensive.

They are proposing a less expensive spotlight - $400 less - but it will do the job.

They don't have a line item for installation and training. You are basically on your own when it comes to setting up the light board. The dimmer rack comes with installation as part of the price.

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#5

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

Bill Tindall

Your situation is not totally clear to me but it would seem that your primary obligation is to spend the money of your client in the most effective way and not use it to provide charity.

You would ask for a revised quote from supplier 1.

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#6

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

Stuart Johnson

We just had a new roof and gutters put on the house. The vendor we selected was close to $3,000 less than the next bidder. This was for the exact same material and installation except the gutters ($2,000) weren't included in the higher bid. I didn't hesitate telling the loser he was high by close to $5,000, his only comment was that was less than their cost. Both gave an item by item bid with the biggest difference being in the number of squares and then add on such as 20% labor increase for roof incline, cost (not material) to install flashing. When the job was finished and after the final payment and inspection I let the winner know why they got the job. FWIW, both companies have been in business since the early 70's.

When I have to deal with vendors I want to put the job out for a final bid not for some sort of auction where they give me the cost but then say they can work with me if there is a lower bid.

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#7

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

Gary Evans

JL,

You mentioned that the first contractor helped you "iron out" a system. If he spent substantial time in helping you develop the specs for your system, then you at least owe him the courtesy of trying to match the bid from the second contractor.

I have a friend in the business of selling motorcycle tires who spends considerable time helping customers decide which tires will work best for their needs only to find them go and buy the tires he recommends from some low baller on the internet.

Sounds like part of what you are paying for with the first contractor is his willingness to invest his time in your interest. That is worth something in my opinion.

Gary

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#8

Moses Yoder

Re:Capitalism

Moses Yoder

I think you live in the United States, which has a capitalistic economy. You don't owe anybody anything until they have a signed contract. It especially amuses me that you feel bad about one of their workers having personal problems.

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#9

Re:Capitalism

Gary Evans

That's right. No room for compassion in a capitalist system.

Gary

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#10

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

Gary Bindel

One option would be to pay the first vendor for the time he spent on helping you design the lighting system. That way, you would be treating him fairly and could accept the lower bid in clear conscience. I know that working up a bid is part of business, but if he did design work, that could legimately be separate from the hardware and installation.

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#11

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

GolfSteve in Calgary

The vendors aren't bidding on the same items so it's not really a fair comparison. You could ask the first vendor to requote using the same materials as the cheaper bid.

One thing I never do is tell vendors what their competitors have bid - but I do owe it to them to do the bidding process on an apples to apples basis.

I know people that go vendor to vendor saying "X" bid $50, can you beat their price? Then they go back to "X" and say "Y" big $45 can you beat it? I don't like that - I prefer to go to the vendor who gives the best price up front.

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#12

Thats what struck me . . .

steve mackay

I would give him the chance to offer another bid. Tell him whats going on. He may address your concerns and you find out he MIGHT be the better choice. Who knows ?

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#13

Re:Capitalism

Yonak

You got it, Gary. You gotta run over 'em when they're down if you don't want 'em to bother you again.

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#14

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

Barry Irby

Having been a Contractor back in ancient history, I have been on both sides of this.

Actually drew up a set of plans for a guy and provided a bid with all top notch name brand components. He angrily denounced my bid and declared I was ripping him off for $50K. But the house he got built only vaguely resembled the one I bid, Lowered ceilings, several hundred less square feet, very low end materials, on and on. After crossing his path several times and receiving scorn from him I confronted him and pointed out the inconsistencies. His answer was that the house was big enough and he did not need all that fancy s@@t anyway.

I could go on and on. But, from the Vendors point of view, I would like an opportunity to bid on EXACTLY the same job as every body else. I would go back to the original guy and give him the very same specifications and let him bid. Or, He may explain to you why you don't want that stuff.

Sometimes there are acceptable substitutions. An example might be you need a router bit to cut a special profile that you only for one small project and are sure you would never use again. You could buy a steel bit for $20 or a carbide cutter for $50. If you are sure this is a once off bit the steel one would be better. In your case you need to be sure the less expensive equipment Will be adequate and durable and serve your needs safely. Is it as easy and convenient to set up and use? Does it have the same life expectancy? If it going to be difficult to use its not worth it. You have to live with this stuff a long time.

Another consideration is the total cost of the bid. If the $5K is 1 or 2 percent of the bid its one thing, but if it 10 or 20 percent, there is something else going on.

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#15

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

Bill Howatt

I can empathize with your situation but your duty is to the people you represent and doing bids is part of the cost of doing business.

Where I used to work we had a purchasing dept and they did the "legal" stuff in handling quotes. We had to define what we wanted and then evaluate the technical aspects of the bids received. Calling up bidder A and telling him his bid was higher than bidder B would get you into big trouble. Writing the specs for the new whatever had to be done carefully to ensure you didn't get some lesser stuff that met the specs. It was never pleasant knowing a nice, helpful salesman didn't get the contract.

The other side of the coin is to imagine yourself called up in front of the management of your playhouse group to explain to them why you spent $5K more than necessary. Do you think that, "Fred is going through some rough personal issues", is going to have them say, "Good idea, you're a great guy"? I doubt it.

You seem to have carefully evaluated the technical aspects of the equipment supplied and there isn't an "out" because of the quality or capability of the equipment supplied.

Bill

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#16

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have probably bid out over 1000 jobs in my previous life as a manufacturing Engineer. First - you have done every bidder a favor by accepting their bids. They can't stay in business without doing the bidding and getting jobs. I have seen tremendous variations in some bids dollar wise. Often this is a combination of factors, lower bids usually result when - 1) Shop needs work so they lower their profit margin to keep their people employed. 2) They have done a similar job in the past so they know there are no surprises. ( I have seen shops add 30 - 50% due to a fear factor - not knowing if their first attempt would be successful or if the material may be wasted.) 3) They have some of the material on hand for the job - inventory is just more taxes - not income. After 20 years or so in the manufacturing business, I knew when a vendor was way to low and would lose money on the job. I have went back to these vendors and refused the quote - telling them they may have missed something - then going over the specs again and affirming with them that I wanted a first class job. I never told them what they should bid or had "bidding wars". I have seen bids for these jobs come in with a 75% difference due to the above causes. - I never felt I "owed" any bidder more than the chance to bid. By the same token I never accepted a bid I thought would put the vendor out of business or cause him a major monetary loss. It didn't help my company to put any good vendor out of business.

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#17

Go a second round of quotes - with a target.

Ray - Middletown, IN

Review the quotes in hand and make any modifications you feel is necessary, then go a second round of quotes to get their best and final quotes on the system you specify in round two. Everyone has to understand you are working for a client not any vendor. Thank vendor no. 1 for his input and offer a consultation fee for his initial work if he does not get the bid. You could give him a hefty fee and still come out ahead for your client.

Ray

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#18

A second look...

Bill Howatt

When I did my first reply I may not have appreciated the work done by the first vendor in the process before the bids. If it was more than the norm then it would be proper to offer some conpensation. I don't know the structure of the playhouse organization but it may be wise to consult with others to protect yourself in case providing the compensation becomes contentious.

This situation parallels situations discussed from time-to-time on the forum - Vendor provides lots of pre-sale assistance and then the potential customer uses the information to buy from a cheaper supplier. We don't normally regard that as fair.

Bill

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#19

Suggestion

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

As a valued supplier, you "owe" him/it the opportunity to requote.

I would go to the guy with:

"You've been a valued supplier and supporter of the theater now for X years, and we want you to continue our relationship. We have a problem in that we've received a competing quote from a reputable firm that is $5,000 under yours. We have a fiduciary obligation to seek the most value for the donations we receive, and $5,000, which buys us a new sound system, is simply too much to leave on the table. If I give you the other quote's details, including equipment, etc., would you be willing to revisit your proposal?"

The guy has earned your trust and business. Perhaps he's been cutting his prices to the bone as a kind of silent supporter of your effort, perhaps even losing money on some items. His quote may actually get him "even" over the course of the prior transactions. If any of that applies, he'll be highly insulted if you don't at least give him the chance to meet the other guy's price. If he gets close, you can consider paying him the few extra scheckles it takes to maintain an important business friendship.

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#20

JL

Some clarifications

JL

The second vendor's package is actually better than the first vendor - all of the lighting instruments are of the better sort. There are also some accessories (gobo holders, drop in iris accessories, barn doors) in the second vendor's package.

The main differences are - training - the first vendor has a training package for over $4K and the first vendor is charging slightly more for all of the components.

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#21

Oh, So

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Your choice seems to be between a better lighting system and an adequate lighting system plus a new sound system?

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#22

Re: Some clarifications -Apples and Oranges

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

First - did you use the information provided by the first vendor to spec out the second quote? If so then you are morally obligated to repay the first vendor for his design time. I have never done this in my forty years of having jobs quoted - You should have had a quote for designing the system if it required much time. Normally I provided the requirements for the system I was purchasing and allowed the vendor the latitude to reach these requirements in the way they saw best.

Second you cannot compare one quote including training (if needed) with one that ignores any training. Both should be quoting on Apples. I would at least allow the first vendor to remove the training costs and re-quote (and you should specify the equipment you really want). OR if you do want/need the training I would ask the second vendor to re-quote with it included.

It is certainly unfair to have a vendor quoting on different materials and specifications for the job. You in all conscience should have all vendors quoting on the same things.

If you feel the training is necessary, I would ask for a second quote from the second vendor including the training.

Re: OT - vendors - do you "owe" them anything?

#23

JL

Re: Some clarifications -Apples and Oranges

JL

No - I did not.

I knew which instruments I wanted (Source Fours and Altman Fresnels). I just told both vendors what power I had (200 amps, 3 phase).

They both came up with the same board and dimmer rack independently.

The training is the issue. The lighting board is fairly complex, but there are manuals, forum and a help desk.