Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Vacuum Veneering questions????

Posts

Vacuum Veneering questions????

#1

Vacuum Veneering questions????

Barry Irby

I am wanting to get into Vacuum veneering. (Have been for years, just never been able to get past the overwhelming info that seems to be important, so I want to start with baby steps.) Also want to do it on the cheap because, well because I don't have an excess of cash.

I have a vacuum pump that I use occasionally for a vacuum chuck on my lathe. Its one of the small Gast pumps that is maybe a 1/4 hp and about the size of a shoe box. I can post the model number if that would help, but I'm too lazy to walk down to the shop to get it. Pump has had very little use. I have some tubing and a valve and a vacuum gauge.

I do not have a bag.

So, jumping ahead for a moment, is it OK to leave this pump running for the hours it takes for the glue to set? I am going to veneer some flat stuff now but may do curves later. I am thinking of using Titebond because I have it and there would be no creep issues on flat work. I am considering glue to both sides of some 1/8" plywood. So, with Titebond on flat work how long does the stuff stay in the bag and does that kill the pump?

Or do I have to get a pressure switch and develop a reservoir to allow for intermittent operation of operation?

Any Ideas on a bag? Stuff I can get locally?

Re: Vacuum Veneering questions????

#2

picture worth a thousand words

Bill Tindall



The picture shows Jeff Headley applying white glue to my crotch veneer and the second picture shows the finished result. The picture shows how much glue to use, how to apply it and how wrinkly the veneer can be and still work fine. Additionally the veneer is fixed to the substrate with low tack blue masking tape to hold it in place while the vacuum takes hold, which must be removed by pulling perpendicular to the grain to keep from lifting the grain.

Your wrote:

never been able to get past the overwhelming info that seems to be important.....it is very simple to do.

I have a vacuum pump .....any pump is fine. A piddly capacity is required for a leak-free situation

I do not have a bag....you must buy or make one.

is it OK to leave this pump running for the hours it takes for the glue to set?......yes and no. the pump will be fine for the hour it takes to set the glue, not hours.

I am thinking of using Titebond........The two people that I know that veneer this way use white glue, for whatever reason, so that is what I use.

creep issues ....more fretting about creep that is justified

Re: Vacuum Veneering questions????

#3

Re: Vacuum Veneering questions????

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

Let's see if I can wipe the cobwebs off here - used to teach this stuff. First, there will be as many opinions as responders - and maybe a few more! Such is woodworking.

The time in the bag. Glue in moderate temperature will set up in less than an hour, usually much less. Glue takes much longer to cure. For flat work, that means you need vacuum pressure for the set time only. For curved work, maybe a bunch longer. Depends on your cauls.

The bag. Go to Wally World and get clear vinyl, medium weight. Heavier weight is hard to fold and seal. Lighter weight simply tears. You need enough to cover the platen and the work all around. Get some good vinyl glue from the borg. Fold the vinyl in half. Glue one inch on the long edges, leaving the end open. Follow the instructions for the glue. For the corners at the fold, glue a triangle fold and clamp until cured.

The vent. This is where the vacuum hose enters the bag. See Joe's Woodworker site for ideas. I have a few others but it requires a lot more writing here. Place the vent in the middle of the top side of the bag - keeps it out of the way of the folds.

The platen. I used 3/4" double sided Melamine. Excess glue is easily removed. Or wax the snot out of MDF. Cut to a size that is 25% smaller than the bag interior and shorter on the open end. Round ALL the edges with a router. Score 1/8" deep cuts 4" apart. Give a quick sanding to make sure there are no sharp edges.

The caul. It is a board that tops the flat work. Cut it 1/4" bigger than your project. Round ALL the edges. I usually use 1/2" material, with the sawn grid described above.

Making the 'sandwich.' The sandwich is the veneered work. Glue both sides completely, but not overly generous. Vacuum will suck glue though open celled wood, like oak. Goldilocks approach here. Not too little, not too much, just enough. Apply veneer to BOTH sides of the substrate. One sided gluing will likely make potato chips of your project.

A word about substrates here. Playwood is not flat, so if that is your aim, look elsewhere, like MDF.

The stack in the bag. Place the platen in the bag. Put the sandwich on the platen. Add the caul to the top.

Closing the opening. Turn triangle corners and roll/fold the open end in to the work. Clamp between two pieces of narrow wood.

Hook up the vacuum. Run to double the glue set time. The pump will get hot. You really need a vacuum pressure switch. You do not need a reservoir. It is just another chamber that will need the air evacuted from it. And another source of potential leaks.

Curing. I leave everything in the bag overnight. The vacuum is off. I don't need to burn down the shop.

Having said all that, you are invited to ask questions and you are highly recommended to visit the Joe Woodworker site.

Re: Vacuum Veneering questions????

#4

Re: Vacuum Veneering questions????

Thomas S Stockton

Barry

The advice you've gotten so far is good. The main question is do you buy a bag or make one, I prefer to buy them a small vinyl bag isn't that expensive and I always had a hard time getting homemade bags to seal.

I have a larger oil lubricated Gast vacuum pump that we used to put outside ( it's kinda loud)and let it run for hours and never had a problem with it so I think you could run yours for a couple of hours with out any problems.

Joe woodworkers site has the best info out there on building your own set up and his commercial site has everything you need at a pretty fair price.

Tom

Re: Vacuum Veneering questions????

#5

Re: Vacuum Veneering questions????

Jesse Cloud

Good advice above. Here's a couple of riffs.

Before you put a lot of time and/or money into this, go to Craigslist and post a "Want to Buy Veneering Setup" ad. With this economy, lots of shops are cutting back on tools and vacuum setups (1)generally don't bring much at the pawn shop and (2)are often considered something the shop can get by without.

You just might get a bargain. I did.

Any particular reason for 1/8 ply? You will introduce a lot of glue moisture on to that first side and it will want to go U shaped very badly. Thicker may be easier, mdf would definitely be easier.

Titebond will work - only problem is its short open time. Use a spreader or a roller to put the glue on quickly. My trick for how much glue is to draw some lines across the substrate and when you can barely see them, you have enough glue. Its very important to get the glue on evenly.

Curves are pretty easy. Make your "platen" from MDF. If you are doing a big 3D curve, make MDF ribs and attach some bending ply for a skin.

Veneering is a real game changer. All the best wood goes to veneer these days and you can do things with veneer that just aren't possible with solid wood (e.g. a 30 foot long birdseye maple conference table).

+1 for Joe Woodworker

Re: Vacuum Veneering questions????

#6

Re: Vacuum Veneering - the real answer

TomD

"I have a vacuum pump that I use occasionally for a vacuum chuck on my lathe. Its one of the small Gast pumps that is maybe a 1/4 hp and about the size of a shoe box. I can post the model number if that would help, but I'm too lazy to walk down to the shop to get it. Pump has had very little use. I have some tubing and a valve and a vacuum gauge."

Sounds perfect. One would think that maybe there would be a relationship between pump size and effectiveness, but there isn't. The pump isn't creating the pressure. The pressure comes from the atmosphere, all the pump does is move the air out. A very small pump can get it done, but it will either be under power, or under air volume. Neither is normally a problem, particularly talking Gast. Sometimes one needs to us a shop vac to pull the excess air volume out for efficiency sake, but that is rarely a problem at furniture scale.

"I do not have a bag."

Furniture guys have all gone nuts on bags. You can use visqueen, poly bag/sheet. The problem with that is that it may not seal quite as well. Furniture projects, and sub-assemblies are usually small enough that dudes can splash out for the fancy rigs. They are designed around the proposition of not running the motor all the time. Ads huge complexity, but normally worth the trouble at small scale and frequent use.

If you dump that objective, then you do not need an expensive bag. Pretty much all my bagging has been done with 6mil and some kind of caulk or housewrap spline.

"So, jumping ahead for a moment, is it OK to leave this pump running for the hours it takes for the glue to set?"

In boat building we normally run the pump for 8 hours because we are using ambient cure epoxy. With titebond you are looking more like 30 minutes. Curves are not normally a huge problem. Veneer is tough, something like a Birdseye can represent a tiny arch, and be very difficult to press down, therefore might pop up. So just be a little careful, even with flat. Cauls out of plywood can help even out the surface.

Most of these pumps are designed for continuous use applications and will pull for ever. Just be sure they are getting cooled appropriately. Not your gast, but some use flow air for cooling.

"I am going to veneer some flat stuff now but may do curves later. I am thinking of using Titebond because I have it and there would be no creep issues on flat work. I am considering glue to both sides of some 1/8" plywood. So, with Titebond on flat work how long does the stuff stay in the bag and does that kill the pump?"

Limp curves are no biggie, heavy spring back ones like say rocking horse runners - a firehose with positive pressure is a much simpler option.

"Or do I have to get a pressure switch and develop a reservoir to allow for intermittent operation of operation?"

By all means, but you can start now, and put that stuff on order.

"Any Ideas on a bag? Stuff I can get locally?"

Clear plastic drop clothes, or house wrap.

Re: Vacuum Veneering questions????

#7

So We have a bag.....

Barry Irby

Followed Carol's advice and went to Wally World. Went to the fabric department thinking I was looking for rolls of vinyl. Nope, all they had was flat packages. I had been thinking about what size bag to make. Turns out the package had piece 54" by 9'. Perfect. Never even unfolded it all the way. Left it 54" square. Used E-6000 they had there and scuffed the surfaces Glued both sides and clamped it between caul's after rolling it. Waiting for the over night cure.

Went to an Auto Parts store and bought a tire valve that bolts in. At the Borg bought two rubber fender washers Bedded them in glue between two steel fender washers. Removed the stem. Looks good.

Got the parts to hook a tire snorter to the Gast pump and I am ready to go. I think.

Got to develop a base (platen?) and some cauls.

Meanwhile my son has been working on the doors we want to veneer first. And I have a gallon of white glue. Not sure why I have it, but I do.

What could possibly go Wrong?

Thanks for all the help. I have been procrastinating on this for a long time and I am finally moving.

Re: Vacuum Veneering questions????

#8

Re: So We have a bag.....

Thomas Norton

Consider getting some of the "Mesh" from Joe Woodworker. It works great for top plattens. I have been veneering for the last few days and some of my panels are 48" x 96".

Re: Vacuum Veneering questions????

#9

No sure of your glue choice

Keith Newton

White glue is water base, grabs fast, doesn't like to be squirmed after first grab, should have 50 - 90 # psi.

These things are going to weigh heavy on your mind while waiting longer than the open time for your little pump to reach its maximum pull, which at its best, will likely be -14, or less than one third of the minimum suggested.

I don't recall if you mentioned wood type. Some soft woods are more absorbent than more dense woods, which can shorten open time as well. Going with heavier glue coating can lead to other problems like puddles which will form, that you don't have to worry with on normal clamping joinery, where it squeezes out the edge.

Re: Vacuum Veneering questions????

#10

Re: No sure of your glue choice

Jesse Cloud

What can go wrong?

Do a test run on scrap and you will find out. A dry run helps to work out process and roles, e.g. who holds the bag open while the other slides the sandwich in, how long does the process take, etc.

Re: Vacuum Veneering questions????

#11

some incorrect assumptions

Bill Tindall

For veneer gluing only 15 psi is required according to the Franklin technical bulletin. 150 psi or more is recommended for edge gluing. Furthermore, it is the only glue used in the Mack Headley shop and they have using it since it was invented without issues. I have heard that the Krenov school also uses it but this is not first hand information. That said, as you state there are glues formulated especially for veneering that would be preferred should you have some on hand.

There are two important times for glue, how long the joint can be exposed to air before assembly and after assembly, how long can the joint be coaxed about. This second time is longer than the first under typical conditions and longer than a typical veneering operation.

Re: Vacuum Veneering questions????

#13

Re: some incorrect assumptions

TomD

90 psi is pretty unlikely under most circumstances, except directly under a clamp. Titebond, a yellow glue but not like some of the more chippy oriented ones, rubs well, including in structural applications, and needs no pressure at all. A lot of times pressure is just there to get contact, because the surface is not a good as it needs to be. This may account for the numbers Bill is quoting. It takes special preparation to get a good result with the proximity joint. Any of this applies to decent white glue. I actually prefer it.