Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

OT voice recognition software

Posts

OT voice recognition software

#1

OT voice recognition software

Gary Smyth

This week I had to go through some 700 documents recording data such as date, version, author, location, etc. I had to hand search boxes of stuff going back several years. My laptop was too much of a hassle for the searches. The result was that I yellow padded the data and now have to transfer it a multi page formatted sheet I still need to finalize and set up in Excel or Word.

On the plane back I read about voice recognition program named Dragon. The web reviews indicate that voice recognition has improved by a lot since I thought about it almost ten years ago. Voice recognition would save me much time now and should I ever have to repeat the process. Not only that, I have lots of other applications where, if it works, I’ll buy one before the end of the week. Anyone have, or use voice recognition software. Any hidden things I need to know about? Special headsets? Oh, and if it works, is there any vendor that you might recommend better than Amazon, Ebay.

Re: OT voice recognition software

#2

Re: OT voice recognition software

Doug Adams

Hi

I don't know anything about the software but you should try---- Tiger direct---- before you buy.

Doug

Re: OT voice recognition software

#3

Re: OT voice recognition software

John McGaw

I used Dragon Naturally Speaking a few years ago and it was impressively accurate then and the newest version is supposed to be vastly better. Reports of nearly 98% accuracy without training to an individual voice are not uncommon and training will improve that.

I wish I had had such a thing to work with decades ago when I wrote a custom litigation support program for a major civil suit. Then we had to train operators to mentally encode the document and then enter the document number and the appropriate codes for each of tens of thousands of documents dumped on us during discovery. The 'advanced' computers we were using then had 20mB hard drives and took most of an evening to process the day's input to get ready for the next morning. Come to think of it, none of these computers had the capacity to store 1% of the Dragon program and even less capacity to do the processing it would demand so I guess having it would have been useless.

Re: OT voice recognition software

#4

JL

Re: OT voice recognition software

JL

I have a friend with MS who uses Dragon. She has a lavalier microphone that she clips to her clothing - but her voice is quite soft - so that may be why she has a clip-on microphone.

It works quite well for her and her applications (Word, Internet Explorer, Outlook).

Re: OT voice recognition software

#5

Re: OT voice recognition software

John T

I use a medical version of Dragon, and have been extremely impressed by how easy it was to set up and use. Training is really simple and takes only a few minutes (even for the specialized medical version). Accuracy out of the box was amazing - maybe not 98%, but better than 90, and the more I use it, the better it gets. And you just talk normally - you don't have to slow down you speech, or try to speak extra clearly - you just talk as you normally would, and Dragon will catch up.

I'm sure that the home user edition would be similar, just not with the specialized dictionary of the medical version.

A bit of a learning curve if you want to use voice commands to operate the rest of the computer (open programs, write and send emails, save files, etc) but the capability is there to more or less replace the keyboard and mouse with voice commands only for a full hands-free experience....

The only caveat I have is that if the software DOES misinterpret what you said, it will substitute what it thinks is correct, so you have to proofread closely. You can wind up with some interesting substitution errors, and since everything is going to be spelled correctly, spell check won't highlight them for you.

I believe the software comes with an over the head microphone, but you can readily pick up a different style for less than $20 (I have an extra Plantronics model that works very well and is comfortable). You can also use a hand held digital voice recorder to dictate, then wash the voice file through dragon and it will transcribe it for you.

Awesome product, and I heartily recommend it (No connection with the company, just a very satisfied user).

-John-

Re: OT voice recognition software

#6

Re: OT voice recognition software

Galen Vetterick

I still have an old version of Dragon Naturally Speaking Preferred Version 3. (1996 or so) Guess they are up to version 11 now and the claims for working are about the same as listed for version 3, so maybe they got it to work! The software came with a mic/headset and I believe the new does as well. I spent hours trying to read into it to recognize my voice and then tried to add company technical terms to library. Even using the correction comands it typed something else totally off the wall instead of backing up to correct. I did have to speak slower than normal for it to be halfway accurate. I gave up back then so cannot help with the new version. I know for Windows 7 it takes at least 4 meg of RAM.

I have not seen anyone demo this software in a long time to know how it has improved. I would think more people would be useing if it really was accurate and faster.

Re: OT voice recognition software

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Modern voice recognition.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

First, I think you meant 4 GIGS of RAM needed in Win7 for VR. I bought a computer in 1995 that had 4 megs of RAM...

Anyway, I don't have Dragon, nor have I ever seen or used it. What I do have is an iPhone 4. I don't use its built-in voice commands much, but I do have the Google app downloaded and installed on it. The Google app is basically just a mobile version of their search engine interface, except that it also has a VR option--which I do use. It is incredibly accurate. The shortcoming that I've seen with it, though, is when I am searching for something obscure or technical, it has a hard time coming up with the correct terms.

I'm not 100% certain, but I would guess that the app works by recording what you speak and then uploading it to their servers for processing--not by processing the VR on the phone itself.

It's been a few years since I messed with it, but there is a VR plug-in for WinXP that works very well, though it requires training to a specific voice. I found it to be pretty accurate after just 15 minutes or so of training. I haven't looked into anything for Win7, even though 2 of my 3 computers now have it.

Jason

Re: OT voice recognition software

#8

Dah, Yah 4 GB