Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Air dried lumber pricing?

Posts

Air dried lumber pricing?

#1

JL

Air dried lumber pricing?

JL

I have an opportunity to purchase some air dried black walnut and red oak.

I typically buy red oak (kiln dried) for on the order of $2.25/board foot. Black walnut runs me about $4-5/board foot.

I was figuring on offering a bit less than the kiln dried price. It is rough lumber - dried right from the chain saw mill.

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#2

Grade Is Everything - Size Counts

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

No. 2 common shouldn't be more than $2/bf

F&S, No. 1, and figured go higher.

How thick? 4/4 to 8/4 is one thing. 16/4 is hard to find so you'll pay more.

Slab (36+") quality? Different world; can go to $16-20/bf

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#3

Re: Grade Is Everything - Size Counts

Robin Corell in Arascadero

A lot of wood workers have the erroneous idea that kiln dried lumber is better than air dried. I think a more correct way of thinking is that if done correctly kiln dried lumber is just as good as air dried lumber. Both will need to acclimate to your shop and both will end up at exactly the same moisture level. If the kiln dried lumber was dried correctly it will be just as stable as the air dried.

Consider that most of the top luthiers will only use air dried lumber and then rethink offering less solely because the wood is air dried.

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#4

kiln dried is typically better on several counts

Bill Tindall

It is a fact that an operation running 100,000 bd.ft. and greater capacity kilns knows more about drying lumber than the average air drier, for example this chain saw mill. They will used this knowledge to deliver a better product. If lumber is kiln dried by a reputable operation it will be better than average air dried lumber on several counts. To begin it will be sawed and trimmed more precisely. Most significant one will know the moisture content for it will have been carefully dried to 7% and the lumber can be used at once. The lumber will have been stacked perfectly on sticks that will leave the lumber stain-free. The drying schedule will have been optimized to leave the lumber stress and stain-free. The lumber will likely have been graded so you have a reliable measure of quality. I am trying to think of any advantage of typical air dried lumber and nothing comes to mind.

The cost to dry lumber at a large integrated mill is almost nothing. So the cost for all these advantages is not much for an equivalent grade of lumber. However, one can often find inexpensive air dried lumber at small to tiny mills that don't have an otherwise good way to market their product into commercial channels.

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#5

JL

I don't have a problem w/ air dried

JL

I use air dried, kiln dried and green lumber all of the time. I usually pay based on the quality of the lumber.

But after all is said and done - kiln dried is usually graded lumber. This is not graded. It is chainsaw milled lumber. I can't judge the boards that well with such a rough surface. It isn't like I can bring my planer or jointer to evaluate the surface.

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#6

Re: I don't have a problem w/ air dried

Dale Lenz

JL: I'd be thinking... log run #2 average boards, chainsaw sawn, etc. No more than $0.75/bd.ft.

Good luck

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#7

For walnut ?

Yonak

Any walnut I'd find around these parts for 75¢ would be pretty trashy (there's an oxymoron for ya).

I got a 1/3 pick-up truck load of black walnut and red cedar last weekend for $30. The cedar's not too bad but the walnut's one grade above firewood.

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#8

Re: For walnut ?

Dale Lenz

Been buying green hardwood for years. I stand by my statement.

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#9

Don't forget insects.

Dick Coers

I have always been a big fan of air dried wood. Especially the color of air dried walnut. That was great until I started finding a lot of powder post beetle damage. When you start throwing away 12/4 cherry, it kinda gets you down. More of a fan of kiln dried these days!

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#10

Re: Don't forget insects.

Dale Lenz

That the reason I usually don't buy someone else's AD wood, most folk don't take care of it right. I try to buy my wood right off the saw and hopefully the log hit the ground in the last day or two.

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#11

Re: For walnut ?

Yonak

I don't doubt you, Dale. You know your market.

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#12

sure you can.....

Bill Tindall

If it is just "log run" then it is like buying a cow. There is a lot of hamburger meat along with the tenderloin.

The main defects are knots and they show up on rough sawed just fine. Then look for any black stain which can be a sign of all sorts of things you don't want. Look carefully where the stickers were to see if there is stain there(fatal). Look how it was piled. Is the lumber as straight as you are used to?

You are smart to be wary. Lots of ways to get screwed buying lumber of this sort.

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#13

which of these pieces was only air dried?

Bill Tindall


While air dried walnut looks different for a while it reacts to air and sunlight to become the same color as steamed or just KD walnut. These test pieces were resawed from a single piece of freshly sawed 8/4 walnut. One was steamed and KD as would be done in a commercial operation, while the other was left to simply dry. Each was left in my sunny dining room for about 3 months. Up close and personal I can still tell the steamed piece as it remains slightly darker but that won't last another few months. In any case, the fleeting purples treasured by the air dried enthusiasts are long gone.

The bottom line is that walnut photobleaches and it doesn't matter whether one starts with air dried or KD it all will wind up the same color eventually.

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#14

PS

Bill Tindall

you can make a good guess about quality from the width of the lumber. In general....Small trees haven't grown enough to have shed their juvenile limbs and grown much clear lumber over the scars.

One gets the best yield of high quality lumber from turning the log to find clear lumber during sawing (see description of sawing logs in my article on hardwood production in the Articles). Odds are the chain saw mill didn't saw this way and as a result even a good log would have yielded more low grade lumber that it could have. Playing the odds, having not seen the lumber, I would guess it is mostly #2 common or less.

Nothing wrong with buying #2 common. I buy a pack of 500 bdft #2 common poplar now and then to make internal furniture parts from. #2 common will yield 50% clear lumber cuttings, more if you are careful and have lots to choose from. But the price should be substantially less than FAS KD.

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#15

the one on the right kiln dried


Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#16

yes but not from drying

Bill Tindall

Actually the difference has little to do with the drying and everything to do with steaming, something almost always done commercially with walnut. Hence, KD usually means also steamed. Steaming turns the walnut pigments nearly black and indeed one can see the remains of this darker pigment in the right sample. But all the pigments bleach in the sun over time, which is why I always stain walnut.

The purples beach in hours in bright sun. Fresh sawed I have seen walnut that looks yellow or yellow-green. This pigment quickly oxidizes to purple, brown etc.

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#17

Re: yes but not from drying

del schisler

I know i have been around this wood for over 50 yrs and have seen lot's of walnut. I like air dried and from a dead tree that has been sawed up. The wood is lite weight and look's nice and lite brown. I also stain walnut so that it is even color. I use a conditioner made by charles neil also . You wouldn't belive the difference it make's. go to his web site and watch his video on blotching. thanks for the return post. I used to cut timber so i pick the tree's. http://www.youtube.com/profile?user=InTheWorkshop#p/u/35/IfCYMdrP8rM

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#18

Re: Somewhat disagree

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Bill, in my area I have purchased several thousand bf of air dried lumber - note that this is in a area where there are Amish and old order families. These families are excellent craftsman and are very aware of the correct methods of cutting, curing and storing lumber. Usually I find that the lumber from the estate sales is either old growth or from very large trees. They can select these trees and haul them out with horse teams unlike the commercial mills. Some of the advantages in addition to large boards are that you never find case hardening, color (in some species like walnut is better - I like the variation in sap wood) and often the wood stack is from one large tree. The idea that kiln dries will have more consistent moisture content is only valid when the lumber is removed from the kiln. At least in this area all kiln dried lumber is stored in unheated, non climate controlled buildings. After a few weeks the moisture content is the same as the air dried stored in similar conditions so I have to insure all lumber is held until it acclimates to my shop (heated and air conditioned).

Re: Air dried lumber pricing?

#19

Re: My average at Estate sales less than $.50 bf