Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

A question on Chair design.

Posts

A question on Chair design.

#1

A question on Chair design.

Barry Irby

I know there are a number of requirements in good chair design. Comfort, Appearance, strength, durability etc.

Triangles are strong in an Engineering frame of reference. Many chairs seem to use rectangles or trapezoids. Rungs enter legs at approximately right angles. This requires exceptionally strong tightly fitted joints to resist the racking and twisting forces on the frame of the chair. So, why not use triangles? Are chairs supposed to be somewhat flexible?

Re: A question on Chair design.

#2

JL

Re: A question on Chair design.

JL

Triangles are strong in an Engineering frame of reference. Many chairs seem to use rectangles or trapezoids. Rungs enter legs at approximately right angles. This requires exceptionally strong tightly fitted joints to resist the racking and twisting forces on the frame of the chair. So, why not use triangles? Are chairs supposed to be somewhat flexible?

I've made "triangular" i.e. three legged stools. They sit reasonably well. Why make four legged chairs? Several reasons. Tradition, looks, easier to make (especially drilling the holes), etc. You have more wood on each side of a tenon if it goes in closer to a 90 degree angle - so strength is also a factor.

Another thing to think about are stress points. How does someone sit in a chair? Where does the weight go as they are sitting or getting up? With two legs in the front and back, you have something to take the strain.

Many chairs are somewhat flexible. There is often a slight spring to the undercarriage. The "give" to the chair makes them more comfortable (in my opinion). Flexibility is also important in the upper portion.

You've made an interesting point. I'll have to do some sketching and see if I can come up with something I'd want to make.

Re: A question on Chair design.

#3

I suspect...

John in NM

That a large part of it is the difficulty of executing MT joints at anything but near right angles. You see triangles in engineering applications because it's not difficult to weld them together. It would be interesting to see a chair designed like a wood truss, where the angles are made by sandwiching truss members rather than cutting joints.

Re: A question on Chair design.

#4

Re: A question on Chair design.

Jesse Cloud

"Are chairs supposed to be somewhat flexible?" I'll try to take that one...

I recently attended a short class by Brian Boggs at Woodworking in America. He addressed that very issue. Traditional 'green wood' chairs were made with wet legs and dry stretchers, so that the mortise in the leg would shrink around the tenon in the stretcher, making a tight, but flexible fit. He demonstrated by holding down the rear part of a chair and lifting the right leg. It went up fully one inch with no noise and snapped right back when released.

Only problem is that this doesn't work with tenons with shoulders.

Another issue is that we like our chairs to be light and graceful, not big chunky affairs. So that limits the amount of real estate available in any one leg for joinery. Four legs spreads out the stress.

Re: A question on Chair design.

#5

Re: A question on Chair design.

Yonak

Barry, I'm not an engineer, but thinking about your question caused me to come to the following ideas :

Triangles are ultimately more stable than rectangles. That's one reason why the pyramids have been around for millenia.

The problem with using a true triangle as a chair support is that, if you set the triangle on its base, at the top is a point. If you look at the chair from the side and the legs form a triangle, you would have to teeter the seat on a point (which might make a good amusement ride).

Many chair designers in history have come to the use of a trapezoid, which is a truncated triangle, and with the best features of a triangle and a rectangle. That is, the top is flat for seat attachment, and the legs are angled for stability. The idea is to get the best compromise trapezoid shape.

Re: A question on Chair design.

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: Well

Moses Yoder

I think Yonak has the right idea; it would be rather painful to sit on top of a pyramid.