Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

OT - asking for help

Posts

OT - asking for help

#1

OT - asking for help

AndiWolfe

I'm participating in the SciFund challenge, which is an effort to raise money for research via unconventional methods. Usually scientists have to wait for grant proposal opportunities, which are becoming more and more challenging every year because Federal and state budgets are being cut back all the time. So, this is a first attempt at work outside the box.

My goal is to raise $5,000 by December 15, 2011 - a modest amount that will go towards field research and laboratory supplies. Please contribute (every little bit helps), and please spread the word. This is a crowdfunding effort, which needs to take advantage of social media and personal contacts. Every contribution level has a reward (check out the $1000 level if you are a collector of wood art). Thanks for your help!

Here's the link to my SciFund page at RocketHub: http://www.rockethub.com/projects/3761-cats-nails-a-parasitic-plant-of-south-africa#

Updates about my research are here: http://wolfelab.wordpress.com/


Re: OT - asking for help

#2

Research in what?


Re: OT - asking for help

#3

Re: OT - asking for help

paul in AZ

From your site:

"It's an All & More funding mechanism: if I don't reach my financial goal I get to keep what I raise. But if I do reach my goal, I get access to exciting opportunities."

Is there any connection between your target date of 45 days and your Xmas shopping?

Re: OT - asking for help

#4

Re: asking for help

Yonak

I agree that scientific research is important. Since research funds are scarce there days, perhaps it's time we should reconsider being more sensible in how we go about conducting it.

Andi, I'm sure your research is laudable. You want money to go to South Africa to conduct research on a parasitic plant. Certainly, such research would yield some critical knowledge.

There are many smart people in South Africa who could do such research and are already there. They wouldn't need funding to get there and stay there.

Why don't you find a research project on your own continent .. one which you could drive to ? There is much critical botanical research that needs to done close to where you live.

Re: OT - asking for help

#5

Re: OT - asking for help

Andi Wolfe

None whatsoever. The check will go to Ohio State University for my research fund.

Re: OT - asking for help

#6

Re: asking for help

Andi Wolfe

I wish there were enough researchers in South Africa who could do this kind of work, but that is certainly not the case.

I do have a project close to home, which is on another plant group. However, the work we are doing in South Africa is very important for getting the baseline data on this parasitic plant and its importance for ecosystem monitoring.

I should mention that I've been working in South Africa since 1996 and am well aware of the research situation there - especially for ecological and basic biology questions. There are few students in South Africa who choose to go into non-medical biological research. It's an ongoing problem with no solutions in sight, so having researchers from other countries working on projects in this biodiversity hotspot is very important to characterizing what species are there, what is at risk for extinction, and what ecosystems are in peril.

Re: OT - asking for help

#7

Probably the wrong venue

doug f, san clemente, ca

Laudable as it may be, your research is far from the purpose of this forum. I, for one, believe that what you have posted approaches the description of SPAM.

You might be better off soliciting from the alumni of Ohio State, your fellow students or even the scientific community that would understand and value your efforts. This is not the place.

Re: OT - asking for help

#8

Really?

Andi Wolfe

Doug,

I'm sorry if you find this posting to be spam-like. Marking the message as OT and asking my friends, woodworking colleagues and acquaintances for assistance via social media connections IS the whole point of this effort.

How is this different from anyone asking for assistance on any other topic that is not directly related to woodworking or woodturning, or, for that matter, announcing the acquisition of a new pet or the birth of a grandchild? People are always asking for prayers, for advice on non-woodworking topics, etc. This is a posting along the same kind of lines - OT, asking for help.

My apologies to anyone who finds this out-of-line.

Andi

now slinking back to the woodturning message board where people are a bit more friendly

Re: OT - asking for help

#9

I don't agree at all...

John in NM

We have lots of OT posts, discussing lots of diverse subjects. Are all of the posts I've seen discussing and encouraging Kiva loans spam?

Lighten up you guys, only the first reply could really be considered neutral, the rest negative, and frankly one is on the fringe of Jerkdom.

I have to say, Andi is quite accurate in calling this unfriendly, and I find it disappointing.

Re: OT - asking for help

#10

I think you've misunderstood

doug f, san clemente, ca

The purpose of my post was not to criticize the research or the funding method; merely to suggest that this forum might the wrong venue for your search.

With regard to the spam comment; my definition of spam is a message that is a solicitation for money or information from an unknown sender. I noted that this was your first post on the board, solicited funds and had only sketchy information on you, thus my definition of spam.

If I have offended you, I sincerely apologize; it was not my intent.

I believe that if your original post had a bit more about you and why you chose this forum for your solicitation it would have precluded a goodly amount of misunderstanding.

This is a diverse group with the usual amount of differing opinions on lots of things, but it certainly doesn't make us unfriendly, just human.

Good luck with your project.

Re: OT - asking for help

#11

Re: I think you've misunderstood

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

This certainly is not Andi's first post on this board, despite what the board's counter says.

Re: OT - asking for help

#12

Moses Yoder

Re: Well

Moses Yoder

He is asking for people to give him money. While that is not against the rules yet, I have noticed a number of posts on here lately saying we should give people money and asking for money. I don't really have an issue with people asking to be given money, but it does kind of seem in poor taste. Not only do we have to deal with beggars on the street corners, we have them in our internet forums as well. I just hope they won't think less of me if I decide not to give them anything, which is a long shot.

I mean really, we can't discuss politics but it's okay to ask for money?

Re: OT - asking for help

#13

Re: OT - asking for help

Mark Nowicki

I think it would have been in good form to check with Ellis first.

After the hurricane Katrina fundraising fiasco, he did clearly state that this board was not to be used for those purposes ever again.

Mark

Re: OT - asking for help

#14

different perspective

Bob Hackett

I don`t take posts like Andi`s as asking for anything but support. IMO it`s just one way of saying, "I think this is important enough to merit my support and I`m hoping you may find it worth supporting as well". You either agree and support it or don`t and pass.

I find it rather disappointing that others here would openly debate the merits of the approach another member takes when they feel strongly enough about a cause to bring it to our attention and ask us to consider supporting it too.

Re: OT - asking for help

#15

Re: different perspective

FredD

I certainly would applaud efforts to contain or destroy Parasitic plants , in this country and likely would help fund such a worthy cause.

Like Kudzu in the South and the Aquatic plant in the S.F. Bay Delta that fouls props and ruins recreational use of the area.

If one would find a cure for the Emerald Ash Borer and the Walnut Twig Beetle , they would be a candidate for a Noble prize at least.

FredD

Re: OT - asking for help

#16

Re: Really?

Howard Norman

Andi, since you clearly marked your message OT I found your posting to be appropriate. And actually the short video that I watched was interesting. I don't have any extra money to aid your cause but good luck with your efforts.

howard

Re: OT - asking for help

#17

Re: I think you've misunderstood

Howard Norman

I think Andi and her work is well known to a lot of us on this forum. She has been around WC for a long time.

howard

Re: OT - asking for help

#18

Moses Yoder

Re: Well

Moses Yoder

I like my church very well, I think very highly of the people there. We could use some money. How would you feel if I posted on here asking for money for my church? I didn't really think too much of it at first with the Kiva advertisements, then I saw more and more of them and now I see other people kinda feel the same way. A friend of mine is selling Girl Scout cookies, are you interested in buying some?

Re: OT - asking for help

#19

Re: I don't agree at all...

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

I found nothing offensive in the posting. Andi has made many contributions to this forum and should be able to request help for a cause she believes in. Either read it or ignore it with just a click of a key.

Re: OT - asking for help

#20

Re: Well

Bob Hackett

Post it and I`ll feel free to ignore it Moses just like you would if I posted asking for donations and offering a complimentary Pentacle or voodoo charm (your choice) with each donation.

Andi`s post had nothing to do with politics or religion so it follows Ellis`s rules for posting here. I`m just surprised and disappointed that some here are suggesting her post was inappropriate. The fact that it has been allowed to remain makes in clear that the person who runs the show and makes the rules doesn`t share your perspective.

Invasive plants and imported insects have a direct effect on the forests that supply the wood we work and our forests have been forever changed by things like Dutch elm disease and the blight that decimated the Chestnut trees that used to be a prime source of timber (and food) in this country. Another member mentioned the Emerald Ash Borer,an insect that threatens to bring a new wave of devastation to our forests. I look at any effort to help contain and eliminate the threats to our forests to be a worthwhile cause and very much on topic.

My perspective may be different from most as I tend to harvest and process my own material and therefore spend more time in the woods than I do in the lumberyard.

Re: OT - asking for help

#21

Comments from the moderator gallery

I talked with Ellis this morning - his place is still out of power, thanks to the snow storm that knocked down so many trees and branches (who'd have thought the East Coast would get such a heavy storm while the leaves are still on the trees?), and the power company is saying it'll be days before power is restored. In the meantime, he gets to WC through his iPhone; my impression is that it's like looking at an auditorium through a keyhole, and posting isn't easy.

He wants to be supportive of Andi, but is also sensitive to the concerns many of you have expressed here. Those concerns are now pretty thoroughly aired. Let's just acknowledge that the concerns exist, and leave it that people can support or ignore Andi's request.

Andi is, by the way, not a newbie, but, if you're not a turner, it's not surprising you wouldn't recognize her name; she's an active turner, and posts mainly over on the Turning board.

Re: OT - asking for help

#22

Re: Comments from the moderator gallery

Howard Norman

Bill, thanks for talking to Ellis about this. As I have already posted I did not find Andi's post objectionable at all. If it had come from someone that I was not familiar with my thoughts could have been different I guess, in other words if the post had come from a WC "newbe". I am amazed that some have been so vocal on the subject.

howard

Re: OT - asking for help

#23

Ellis Walentine

A good cause

Ellis Walentine

Hi Andi,

I'm sorry your solicitation turned into a polarizing issue here today, as you clearly marked it "Off Topic" and it's fair enough for friends and supporters of WoodCentral to publicize their worthy causes on these boards. I think that a lot of people here are protective of our "non-commercial" policy, which is intended mainly to discourage commercial entities from unfairly competing with our paid advertisers for the attention of our visitors and friends. I don't view your cause as particularly commercial, and it certainly isn't competing with our regular advertisers' offerings -- and you're a personal friend and frequent contributor here -- so.... no harm, no foul.

Good luck with your project.

Ellis

Re: OT - asking for help

#24

Re: OT - asking for help

Thomas S Stockton

I agree with the majority of the poster that it is fine. I think if you don't like it take it up with Ellis or a moderator instead of flaming Andi.

I also put my money where my mouth is and donated.

Tom

Re: OT - asking for help

#25

Re: A good cause

AndiWolfe

Thank you, Ellis! I really appreciate your support - not only here on the forum, but also for donating to the project. I'll send a virtual hug your way for that :D

I hope your power situation has been repaired now. You guys really got hammered over there.