Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

Posts

OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#1

OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

charlie belden

While at the service station I've been going to since 1975 to get my 18 month old battery replaced under warrantee I picked up a gallon of anti-freeze, winter, such as it is here in the SF Bay Area is coming. Handed the attendant a ten dollar bill, expecting change.

"The days of inexpensive glycol anti-freeze are over sir. It'd be almost cheaper to use champagne. That'll be $22.95 PLUS sales tax - $24.84 will be your total."

OK, so every year animals, and a few people, get poisened by the "old" anti-freeze. That's not a good thing. Changing what's in anti-freeze to something that WON'T kill people or animals is a good thing. BUT - the New & Improved formulation still has a "Antifreeze/Coolant is poisonous, harmful or fatal if swallowed or inhaled. Contains ethylene glycol." warning label.

Is something that makes you less dead than just plain dead really better. Just as "full, fuller, fullest" doesn't make sense, "dead, deader, deadest and less dead" don't make sense.

I'm semi-sure there's a good reason for the change of antifreeze formulation - but I haven't a clue as to what that reason may be. Anyone got the answer to "why change?"?

Guess, after trying DNA and LDD soaks of green wood, I won't be trying any AF experiments . . .

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#2

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Well, mine is good for 10 years or 100,000 miles; it's cheaper in the long run than using the old annual flush and change routine.

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#3

move to TN

Bill Tindall

I got some for much less than half that last week. You provide yet another example of how over regulation is strangling our economy. If the stuff was $10 gallon you could have bought lunch with the other $10.

Now what astonishes me is why anyone buys the stuff already diluted for almost the same price as the stuff that is 100%.

As I understand it the "safe" stuff is 1,2-propane diol, a particular form of propylene glycol, one carbon bigger than ethylene glycol. I stick a pint of the stuff down a sheep's throat when they are going into ketosis as it is equivalent to an IV of glucose for a ruminant.

In any case all these chemicals are less than a dollar a pound in bulk quantity. Not sure why the retail price for the formulated stuff is so high.

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#4

Wow! $12.84 per gallon at Walmart on Saturday.

Scott in Montana

Just checked my receipt to make sure I was right. Prestone Long-life Concentrate antifreeze $12.84 per gallon. I just checked the bottle to make sure I hadn't accidentally bought the 50/50 mix.

Sorry prices are so high in the bay area. Never thought I'd be gloating about anti-freeze.

Scott in Montana

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#5

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

Dale Stansbery

I just bought 4 gallons (100%, not 50/50) of Peak AF at Rural King Yesterday for $6.99 each. It was $5.49 after a mail in rebate two weeks ago, but they sold out before i got there.

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#6

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

Neal in San Jose

I think they saw you coming, Charlie. I just checked O'Reilly and they have it for $10 to $12 depending on brand. Grainger has it a little cheaper - I buy it there for some chiller systems here at work. One tid-bit I ran across is that there is a push to recycle it. Is it possible there is a recycling fee built into that price?

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#7

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

Howard Norman

I think I know now why I never buy antifreeze or anything but gasoline from a service station anymore.

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#8

Should've Shopped Around

charlie belden

An hour after buying the "champagne" priced antifreeze at the service station I was at an O'Rieley's where 100% (as opposed to "50/50") was $8.95 to almost $15 depending on the brand - "HEAVY DUTY" was the $15 stuff.

I don't think it's a matter of "government stifling business" - but more like "free market capitalism" - get as much out of the consumer as possible. I suspect there's a bit of colusion between makers and retailers, but that's only a hunch - no hard evidence to base the hunch on.

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

50/50?  Simple.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Depending on what I'm doing, I use the 50/50--particularly for topping off coolant if some leaked out, or lost some during a repair, or some boiled out, whatever.

Around here, the 50/50 is only a couple bucks more, and it ensures that I keep the ratio correct without fooling around with mixing it. Also, if you read the directions closely on the full-strength stuff (at least the ones I've seen), you're supposed to mix it with distilled water only. Tap water is generally not good for cooling systems (fine for an emergency, but not long term). Well, I don't keep distilled water on hand, and auto parts stores don't sell it, so that's an extra trip, wasted time and expense, etc.

Jason

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#10

I've never understood...

John in NM

Why we're not using propylene glycol instead of ethylene glycol. Cost of packaging and transporting individual gallons to an auto parts store likely outweighs the cost of the material itself.

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#11

Why buy at the gas station?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

For most service stations, that's kind of like buying your food at a 7-11 or other convenience store: their volume is low enough that they have to charge more to have a decent bottom line. Go to an auto parts store.

That said, I don't recall what I paid for antifreeze the last time I bought any.

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#12

Re: Should've Shopped Around

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My dad ran a gas station back in the 60s, and I've talked with the managers of the station across the street from us (the franchise has changed hands several times). People don't realize that most gas stations* make no money on the gasoline itself, and, in fact, may even lose money on it, depending on the current delivered wholesale price. As strong as the temptation might be, I will refrain from here going into a rant about the oil companies, who exercise a LOT of control over the franchise operators of their stations (Dad lost his franchise with less than a month's notice when the big national oil company decided he wasn't moving enough of their gasoline; he was, at the time, making a decent profit, as explained in the next paragraph).

When Dad had his gas station, the back room - repairs from tire repairs up through tune-ups and even more advanced mechanical repairs - were where the money got made, the gasoline just being the loss leader to get customers in. Automotive technology having changed in ways that require more expensive testing and repair equipment than most gas stations can afford, the average modern gas station makes its money on either automotive accessories/supplies, including oil, antifreeze, and the like; or junk food, for those stations that have a convenience store attached.

Rent, insurance, utilities, and labor costs all add up; and then there you are, with $23 antifreeze, of which the station may sell a gallon every two weeks, but of which they have to maintain an inventory to be sure they have it when you ask for it.

Small business capitalism is often like being the last guy on the sleigh, rushing through the snow trying to escape the wolves: you can feel that hot breath on your ankles all the time, and hear the teeth gnashing, and just a moment of inattention or bad luck results in happy wolves**.

I may, here, have made clear why I didn't go into business for myself. Years of seeing Dad only by being at the car lot and gas station convinced me there were better ways for me to make a living.

*The exception being the super-high-volume gas stations near highways and suchlike; although I suspect even those places would be on the edge if people stopped liking chocolate, coffee, and sweet rolls.

**And, yes, I know the wolf pack chasing the sleigh is mainly mythology; but it makes a great metaphor.

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#13

Moses Yoder

Re: Small service stations

Moses Yoder

That little station you were at is probably struggling to stay in business as it is. When Meijer moved into Three Rivers, MI, all the little privately owned grocery stores ended up going out of business. Sad, but that's progress.

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#14

Progress?

Bob Hackett

All the upheaval in our economy has made a lot of us rethink what the term "progress" means to us up here in Maine. We have come to realize that progress is a term that means vastly different things to different people. As one example I`ll use the recently defunct Borders booksellers.

There used to be quite a few local book stores within about a 45 minute drive from our house before Borders moved into the area and set up shop. Within 2 years there were fewer than 3 left. Those locally owned shops survived for a while by specializing and offering things like book exchanges and used books. Once Borders went to new books for less than $3 (clearance prices) for newer issue hardcovers by well known authors even those few that were left couldn`t keep up.

Now that Borders has closed their doors we are left with just one high dollar boutique bookstore/coffee shop or the used books from either the thrift stores or the library used book sales. Borders came in,pushed the locals out of the market by slashing prices and then left leaving next to nothing in their departing wake. This same thing has been repeated by grocery chains and the big box stores like Lowe`s and Home Depot and Rite Aid up here. Now we are seeing these large corporations are closing down the outlets that forced locals out of business because they are "not profitable enough to remain open". Those jobs they used as leverage to open their big stores are leaving with them as well as the taxes they touted as helping the local economy.

What most didn`t realize is that if we hadn`t bought into their interpretation of "progress" our main streets wouldn`t have near as many "for rent" signs on them and our kids wouldn`t have to drive off the peninsula to chase jobs.

Many of us were fooled by "progress" and now that we have been fleeced, stung and then abandoned we don`t plan to be fooled so easily again.

The local lumberyards and sawmills are starting back up (at greatly increased prices,which is understandable) and people are buying and supporting locally grown,made and harvested once again instead of driving to the Borgs.

It has been our experience that the "progress" that we were talking into meant progressively better profits and bottom line for people who were operating from a distance and only really cared about the contents of our wallets rather than our community. When times got tough for these corporations they left us high and dry,many times with little or no notice. We are paying more now in order to support locally owned and operated businesses but we get better quality, better selection based on local needs rather than what the people at a national corporate headquarters decide would be most profitable to stock the shelves with. Perhaps most important of all,we can drive on down and talk to the real owner rather than a manager and that owner is willing to be part of a face to face partnership that allows both the customer and the business to meet specific needs and be here over the long haul. This is our renewed,local definition of "progress". All it took was a step back and a perspective from both sides that was expanded to include the thought that things other than the "bottom line is the dollar sign" should be considered.

The benefits of local access, support and resources are many times something you never think of until they`re gone and you have to come together again to rebuild you community in the wake of broken promises from corporations operating from a distance.

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#15

Re: Small 'anything'

Tom Dunlap

WalMart got their game plan wired years ago. Move in, drive down the prices, eliminate competition and then have a monopoly....or not...if they didn't make their projected sales ratios they walked away. Leaving behind blighted stores and weed infested parking lots. And empty store fronts from the small stores they drove away.

A buddy of mine turned me onto the concept of 'chumming the local waters' with some money left behind from the Big City whenever visiting small towns.

Re: OT - $23 a gallon AntiFreeze!?

#16

Re: Small 'anything'

Bob Hackett

Maybe a better parallel might be a recent automotive repair I was asked advice on. My friend had hit something in her driveway a while back that dented her oil pan and started her drain plug leaking. After a couple of oil changes the dealer told her the entire oil pan needed to be replaced to the tune around $400. She asked me what I thought and I told her to bring it by the house and I`d fix it and change the oil for around $75 in total costs if she brought the oil and filter.

I drained the oil, cut the old drain plug out with a hole saw and welded a new,heavier,industrial plug assembly ($20 my cost) in place. Once it cooled I cleaned what little debris was left from the repaired area,changed the filter and replaced the oil in under an hour right there in the driveway. Took longer to jack up the car and wait for the oil to drain than it did for the actual repair.

The factory dealers think in terms of maximum profits and flat rate manuals. Successful (and honest) local people think in terms of helping friends and neighbors. Different approaches to the same equation which many times bring vastly different solutions.