Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

"Self-centering" punch . . .

Posts

"Self-centering" punch . . .

#1

"Self-centering" punch . . .

steve mackay

I've always eyeballed my center marks for hinges but I'm wondering if I can do better. I'm dealing with hinges 3/4 x 5/8 with two 1/16 screws. Is something like LV's "Spring Loaded, Self-centering Punch" too big for such a small application ?

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

#2

Vix-bit

Bill Tindall

I couldn't install hinges without the aid of the self centering drill call Vix-bit.

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

#3

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Probably too big for this application, but it works fine for "full"-size hinges. I've had problems with the Vix-style jamming with chips; if you don't catch it, you can get a really off-center hole.

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

#4

centering the Vix-bit

Bill Tindall

The drill must be perfectly perpendicular to the hinge plate or it will be off center in the hinge hole.

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

#5

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've had a supposedly centering punch for years, but never had much good luck with it. The Vix bits seem superior.

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

#6

DANKE ! . . .

steve mackay

Sounds like it wouldn't do what I'm after. Ya'll saved my twenty bucks. The motto around here is "I can have all the tools I want, as long they get used."

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

#7

Re: DANKE ! . . .

Barry Irby

Steve, I have both self centering punches and Vix Bits. The punches I have are cheapies I bought at Lowe's or some other Borg. they don't work very well, I think because they are too dull or blunt and too "sloppy". Unless the wood is completely consistent the punch glances off the hard part of the grain and the holes are not centered. I have not tried it but what might work better would be to have the punch ground off completely blunt like a drift punch so that a flat surface its the wood and punches into it rather than skating off the harder wood. For what you are doing the punch would be tiny, maybe 1/16".

The Vix Bits work better, but you do need to be careful that they clear the chips and the bit retracts.

Another thing I have done is to position the hinges and then touch each hole with a counter sink. It centers in the hole and drills a little cone into the wood and you drill the hole in the center of the cone. Only takes a light touch to drill out the wood and not over drill the hinges.

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

#8

Re: clearing the Vix bit

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

I have that problem when drill multiple shelf pin holes. I found spray the bit with a light lubricant helped a lot. I've used WD-40 with no ill effects to finish later. (Lots of sanding drill drilling to finishing!) The other trick I discovered was to allow the bit to come to full speed before drilling the hole.

FWIW.

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

#9

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . . *LINK*

Jim Dillon

Steve,

I've used the Vix bits as well as the dedicated Starrett self-centering punch (link below) for years. Both work OK, but sometime the grain will cause the punch to move to one side just a tad, but enough to cause problems bring the screw head flush to the hinge surface. Overall, I think the Vix bits are a better option.

Jim


Starrett Self-Centering Punch

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

#10

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

steve mackay

Thank you. The space I've got is cramped though. Reaching into 1 1/4 x 1/2, 'bout 2 deep. The most drill I can stick down it is my gimlet. Guess we'll just stick to eyeballing it.

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

#11

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

Jim Dillon

Steve,

I now understand your problem better. That 1/2 inch measure might be a tight squeeze for a Vix bit body but it would depend on the size of the bit being used as the outside diameter of the bit body varies somewhat as the diameter of the bit varies IIRC. I do not have access to my shop right now so I can't make any measurements of the bits to give you more input. Sorry. For sure, the Starrett's punch body is bigger than 1/2 inch. I have, on occasion, also eyeballed it with an awl and that works maybe half the time but my eye-hand coordination ain't what is used to be for sure ;).

Perhaps you could put a tapered point on the end of a metal rod which is the same diameter as the width of the screw head using a lathe or drill press along with a metal file. Kinda like a center-locater for a drill press or router. Just thinking out loud here.

Jim

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

#12

Re: "Self-centering" punch . . .

JMOHNIKE

I have a set of transfer punches. They work very well for this application. I had poor results with the Vix and other similar punchs.