Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

Posts

Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#1

Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

Bill Tindall

I watched my first episode recently. It was about finishing. I was put off by the frenetic pace of the show. The two guests seemed to know their stuff but the host couldn't resist interrupting them with banter that didn't add value. I didn't think any topic was covered to a depth that would have enabled one to learn much from the show.

I did pick up one tidbit. The finisher used a stop block while sanding a place where two pieces joined at right angles, like a cabinet door frame. The block placed along the line that joined the two pieces blocked the sand paper from lapping onto the perpendicular grain. Good trick I thought. I wish this experienced finisher had more opportunity to teach his tricks.

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#2

Sanding Fence

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

My grandfather showed me that "stop block" trick a whole bunch of years ago, along with shallow champhering the two sides of that joint to get rid of tear-outs in the cut edges.

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#3

Yep

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

The show does lack polish, especially in the first season. The second seems to be a little better. But Tommy does clown around a good bit and it is distracting. I do enjoy the show, even though it reminds me of how much we miss Norm. I hope Tommy continues to evolve his own style and gets more comfortable with his chosen path. The November PopWood has a nice article on the show and FWW did a bit on him last year.

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#4

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

Ron in Sterling, CT

I watched several episodes last winter, and was not impressed. Tommy Mac has his own style of presentation.

Ron

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#5

I watch "Rough Cut"

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Happy Sunday Bill,

I watch it even though I am somewhat put off by the choppy tempo and demeanor of the host. I think he knows his business, but I can't get used to the too fast and too shallow presentation. Norm is more pleasing to listen to, and more continuous in his presentations. For a very nice education, I like American Woodworker with Scott Phillips, available on the "Create" channel here in the Philly area.

Rough Cut is aptly named, because it is certainly "Rough".

George

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#6

Re: I watch "Rough Cut"

Joseph Mulherin

NewYankee has weekly videos of some projects Norm made, and they change to a new video on Fridays.

Just go to NewYankee.com and you can watch, and also order some plans with videos of the project for a reasonable price.

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#7

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

John McGaw

I have seen a few episodes. The entire program is so irritating (on more than one level) that I don't anticipate watching any more. So far as I can tell there is not even one woodworking program that does it right.

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#8

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

Ron Conrad

Norm was slow and had a presentation style that was relaxed. Now "Guys" Tom is new and nervous in front of the camera. You know "Guys" you would be too. What we need to do "Guys " is wear a tee shirt 3 sizes too small. Then we "guys " could get a show of our own. Norm must be enjoying the new wave of wood working talent that replaced him. Maybe it's too much coffee before a taping ??

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#9

Where is this on? What Channel?

Barry Irby

Actually does not sound great, but I an Jonesing for some WW TV. Help me find it and then I will tell you how much I don't like it.

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#10

Re: Where is this on? What Channel?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Check you "education" PBS station listings

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#11

Recently, I discontinued my cable service

North of the Border

as I don't spend much time on TV. Plus that there're no new NYW episodes.

I watched Tommy's show (recorded) and like others here, found his pace sometimes too fast and technique details missing. He seemed to be getting better in the recent season. But he is definitely much better than many blog hosts who put up their shop-made videos on the Internet: those amateur hosts (no names please) often produce very very long-winded clips that turn me off after five minutes into them. Some can go on and on and on upon a simple point endlessly. Most of them can be cut in half or even more of the time they ran and would still do the job they were supposed to do.

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#12

Re: Recently, I discontinued my cable service

Barry Irby

We used to publish a newsletter on Home Inspection issues. Each moth we had a technical article and one on promoting the business. One person wanted us to publish his article, but said we couldn't change it because it was so tightly written. We agreed. He sent us the article and it was so bad and wordy I cut out a third of it and really edited the rest of it. He did not notice.

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#13

I miss David Marks


Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#14

Me Too


Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#15

Re: Recently, I discontinued my cable service

TomD

I know what you mean, and I threatened to cut my cable, but with kids it's tough. They don't watch much, but I don't think they would find a replacement as easily.

Personally I really support people who have something to say.

I prefer watching someone build a state of the art guitar soundboard with carbon and epoxy, and wood on youtube, than watching Norm hack out another project for the cheap seats. Production values are of little interest to me if the material covered is just pap. Even the first Taunton videos were rough, but it was great to actually see someone do something one had only had through the printed word up to that point.

Norm seems like a an extremely able carpenter, never claimed to be a woodworker, and for abundant good reason. He has a wonderful manner, though he has been at it a long time.

Tommy has the skills, but he is slanted way below my demographic. Probably a lot younger, and maybe more female. I hope the tight shirts aren't for me. I must see if he could get the attention of my three girls. Norm got his start at 29 and is now 61. So I hope Tommy can bring along a new generation of woodworkers.

So is the NYW over? Roy was the best of the lot, real skills, and a master communicator. But he lost interest I think, and his skills actually declined over the years. I think he might be the kind of personality that needs the stimulation of the near disaster to keep interested. There has to be a word for that, sorry.

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#16

Re: I watch "Rough Cut"

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don't like American Woodworker at all, and switch off Woodsmith as fast as it comes on. They assume you know nothing.

Tommy, OTOH, assumes you know the basics, and I like that a lot. It is fast, and that's okay. I like someone who treats me as if I know what's happening and he's letting me in on how to take my skills another step higher.

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#17

Re: I watch "Rough Cut"

Dave in Bryn Mawr PA

To George:

Hi George: What channel is "Creat" I am on

comcast

Thanks

Re: Does anyone watch "Rough Cut"

#18

Hello Dave

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Evening Dave,

On our TV Comcast cable, Create is Channel 266. Scott's American Woodworker is on Tuesdays and Thursdays at 11:00PM. Roy Underhill's program is on at 10:30 PM Tues and Thurs. I usually enjoy both, except when I prefer to watch Cecilly Tynan on 6ABC. She's better looking than either Roy or Scott.

George