Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

What wood would you use to resist "writing dents"?

Posts

What wood would you use to resist "writing dents"?

#1

JL

What wood would you use to resist "writing dents"?

JL

I'll be making a Windsor style writing chair with a "tablet" on the end of the arm.

What would be a reasonable wood to use for the "tablet"? I've got a fair bit of white oak stashed as well as ash, maple and cherry. I'll end up painting the chair when I'm done, so I have no problem using a dissimilar wood from the rest of the chair.

I've also got poplar - but I know that would be too soft.

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing dents"?

#2

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing den

Barry Irby

If its hard maple I would use that. Or the Cherry. I would shy away from the oak as the grain might be too pronounced and "show" in the writing.

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing dents"?

#3

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing den

RobCarr

Use whatever wood you want and put a piece of glass over it.

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing dents"?

#4

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing den

Dale Lenz

If you use ash or white oak, you will need to fill the grain. Guess I'd go with cherry or maple to keep from doing the extra work of filling the grain.

Good luck

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing dents"?

#5

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing den

Jason Waters

I don't like writing agaisnt glass, not with one sheet of paper or something. If using oak or something like that, I would want to fill the grain.

How about making it with a removable insert like 1/4 thick that you can take out and replace easily (think magnets in chair, with recess washer glued into bottom of insert to stick to). Or you could even laminate the insert (done nice, this could look good with some of the laminates they offer-faux leather look). Or you could use real leather.....lots of things....

The other thing to do is just make it out of what you want and write on it, and realize the dents, marks, etc. are just part of normal use, and character of the chair. Scars of life.....Like my kitchen table. I gave up. It's a cheap (but good) table I've had for 15 or more years, but it looks used, like we actually eat there........which we do, nearly every night we are home.

Whatever you do, it's probably better than anything you could have bought, and will be here to stay. I say make it and enjoy it.....

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing dents"?

#6

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing den

John Veerkamp

Before formica, school desks were traditionally red oak. The pores were not filled but every year they were sanded off and a new coat of varnish added, After a few years the grain was effectively filled. These old desks now bring a premium with the ink stains and carved initials that never quite went away.

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing dents"?

#7

maple

Bill Tindall

Maple would be the logical choice for a painted surface, certainly not cherry. This recommendation can be confirmed by doing your own test. However, dents will be determined by the paint hardness. We sold mountains of maple for industrial usage and maple was used for flooring in early factories, and currently it is the wood of choice for bowling alleys. It was the material of choice for dent resistance and overall durability.

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing dents"?

#8

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing den

Jesse Cloud

Maple definitely has the best dent resistance and will present a smooth surface for writing. I cringe, though, at the thought of painting over maple....

Traditional writing desks often had a thin layer of leather over the wood for a writing surface.

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing dents"?

#9

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: What wood  - I prefer leather

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

A nicely routed out 'tray for a piece of top grain leather would be the perfect writing surface for me - assuming, of course I'd be using a ballpoint pen or a pencil.

If I'm to be using a fountain pen (my writing utensil of preference) then a smoothly finished wood surface is all that's needed. Keep in mind that when these chairs were originally made, the writing was probably done with a quill or dip pen, and there may have been an indentation, or even a hole, to hold the ink container.

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing dents"?

#10

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing den

JMOHNIKE

Maple first choice then birch. I have restored a slot of school desks and the ones made from maple and birch had held up the best.

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing dents"?

#11

JL

I hadn't thought about birch - I'll go with that

JL

I've got a bit of 4/4 birch. Thanks.

Re: What wood would you use to resist "writing dents"?

#12

Re: I hadn't thought about birch - I'll go with th

Bill Tindall

According to some data in a book I have maple is slightly more than 50% more resistant to denting than birch.