Somewhat OT - thinning trees
JL
I have a lot of young poplars growing in one stretch of my property. Obviously they all can't be allowed to reach full growth.
Anyone have any clue as what sort of guidelines that I should use to thin them?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Somewhat OT - thinning trees
JL
I have a lot of young poplars growing in one stretch of my property. Obviously they all can't be allowed to reach full growth.
Anyone have any clue as what sort of guidelines that I should use to thin them?
Re: Somewhat OT - thinning trees
paul in AZ
As a general rule a tree's root system is as wide as the canopy. Anything inside the drip line is competing with the tree for food and water. Hybrid poplar spacing is cited at 12 feet to 20 feet when grown.
Myths *LINK*
Tom Dunlap
In some cases most of a trees larger roots are inside the dripline. but for the majority of trees the majority of the root volume is wayyyyyy outside.
The root system of a tree is like the base of a wine glass....thin and wide.
Have you ever seen a carrot type root system after a storm tips a tree over? How about after the bulldozers push over the trees for lot clearing?
The canopy does NOT 'compete' with the roots. The tree is one whole organism and the roots support the canopy and the canopy supports the roots.
There are a couple of websites that will answer the pruning question and show how trees grow:
Ed Gilman's work will amaze you. Find your way to the pages where he describes 'blowing' the trees with the 'hurricane machine'!
http://warnell.forestry.uga.edu/warnell/service/library/index.php3?docID=146
Go backwards on the UGA page and find more articles by Kim Coder. He is brilliant!
Trees Are Good
check with local Forester
Bill Tindall
In general thin so the tops don't overlap
Not pruning - thinning
JL
I basically have too many young poplars in a few areas. I need to know what sort of spacing I need for the trees to thrive and grow properly.
But thanks for the links - they'll help with pruning.
The 'other' thinning...oops
Tom Dunlap
I read your post as thinning the canopy not thinning the grove.
Arborists call your type of thinning a 'horizontal pruning' job 
Find your regional small woodlands forester. there should be one who works for your state ag, forestry or dpt. of natural resources.
Re: Somewhat OT - thinning trees
Dale Lenz
JL, around here as a general rule and with out seeing what you have, I'd recommend a D+6 method. For each tree you chose to leave, take that tree's diameter in inches and add 6. Say your keeper tree is a 10" diameter, at breast high, DBH, + 6 equals 16, the units of the 16 is in feet. So you clear out all trees 16' radius around your keeper tree. This is what I recommend to forest landowner that I can not come out and see what they have. Once again this method is a place to start. As others have said call your local forester as he/she will have more local knowledge than I do. BTW, if your populars are small, the cut ones will spout back 10X come spring unless you do something about that.
Good luck
Re: Somewhat OT - thinning trees
JL
Okay, that sounds doable - though I'll probably be more aggressive than that.
I'm looking to thin out many young shoots and a couple of the older ones. I don't want to thin out everything - just enough to neaten things up
preventing resprout
Bill Tindall
After you cut the tree paint the stump with brush killer. They will not resprout, even if they are the notorious locust. It doesn't work so well in spring when sap is flowing strong
To locate your local State forester contact the Ag extension agent for your county. Often they share the same building.
Dale.....the Federal forester required more aggressive thinning for timber production, under their "crop release" program. They didn't want tops touching. I thought this was ridiculous over-thinning and didn't do it. Maybe they only know about pine trees......or they never leave a desk in Washington. Consistent were the ignorant planting recommendations- upland trees recommended for riparian areas, for example.
Crowns not touching?
Dale Lenz
Bill, I fail to understand your logic here, thinning so the crowns are not touching is not a bad thinning plan as long as you don't have 20' between crowns. At 10' between crowns the residual tree's crown will close in a few years. I always recommend to leave smaller trees on the sunny sides of a high value trees when thinning to keep the target tree from epocormic(SP?) branching, bole spouts.
Agree, following Big Brother's game to get some money can be nuts at time. It's all about Money!
Re: preventing resprout
FredD
Most Hardwares and all Co ops around here carry a product called Tordon that prevents regrowth from Stump , if it is applied right after cutting the tree or Sapling.
FredD
Tordon RTU, Ready to use
Dale Lenz
Can be used during most of the year.