Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Dust

Posts

Dust

#1

Dust

Doug Ridley

I have a 2 hp dust collector with a large pleated filter on top. I do a lot of power carving and create an awful lot of fine dust, almost like talcum powder. As the filter begins to clog up the suction drops off dramatically, causing me to have to take it off and blow it out pretty often. It takes a pretty long time to get it clean with my small air compressor. Now I also have the 2 micron felt bag which I could use instead of the pleated filter. Which would be best for all that fine dust? Would the bag or the filter last longer without a drop-off in suction?

Also if I stay with the pleated filter can I wash it out with a water hose without ruining it?

Doug

Re: Dust

#2

JL

Re: Dust

JL

A thought - if you were to put a Thein separator or a "trash can" separator, would it collect enough of the dust to make a difference?

Before I got my cyclone, I had a drum separator - but my activities don't really generate a lot of fine dust. I will say my 5 micron bags worked reasonably well and were easy to empty.

Re: Dust

#3

Re: Dust

Dave Paine

I have a 1 1/2HP Dust Collector with pleated canister. Mine is not washable. I expect yours is also not washable.

When clean the pleated canister has more surface area than a bag, not sure once the pleats fill with the fine dust.

You may want to consider 1 micron over sized bags. I saw some company making these in a magazine article. Have to do some internet searches to find the name.

My canister has a paddle to supposedly knock off the dust. Only manages to knock down the big stuff. Like you I have to eventually take it off, brush off as much as possible, clean with the shop vac, then take outside and blow off with compressed air. Takes a some time and can be messy.

Re: Dust

#4

Re: Dust

Doug Ridley

Thanks, I just got done doing all that and it made me wonder if I would be better off using the bag as I thought maybe I could just whack it pretty often with a paddle and make the fine dust fall out.

Re: Dust

#5

Re: Dust

frank ashmore

I keep an old tennis racket by the D/C and just give a couple of good wackes to the bags before I start work

Re: Dust

#6

Re: Dust

Doug Ridley

That's what I was thinking about. I guess my question is--Since I have so much really fine dust, would I be better off using the pleated filter and periodcally taking it off and cleaning it or switch to the felt bag?

Re: Dust

#7

Re: Dust

Barry Irby

Doug, I can't really answer your question, because I have limited experience. I have a 1 1/2hp unit with the bag that came on it, Might be a one or five micron, I don't know. I have it in a closet out side the shop and that's a great thing. whatever dust it picks up is either in the bag or gone with the wind. I don't notice the decrease in suction much.

A friend has the pleated filter type and my son and I used it while sanding some parts. This was before I got my system. I was very surprised at how quickly the suction dropped as we sanded. I think the pleating is better than if it were not pleated, but not much. The pleats fill up pretty fast and that negates their value. Then cleaning them becomes the problem. So the solution is the problem. You might look up "Bag Houses" used in industry to house lots of bags with lots of surface area. Some of them include shakers to shake the dust down out of the bags. Some includes air nozzles that surround the bags and blow pulses of air threw them from the outside to dislodge the dust.

And then there are the cyclones that spin the dust out of the air. This is clearly superior if for no other reason, the debris does not go through the fan.

Re: Dust

#8

Re: Dust

Doug Ridley

Thanks for your ideas, everybody. I guess I'll just stay with the pleats until they need cleaning again and then switch to the bag and try it for a while.

Re: Dust

#9

Re: Dust

Charlie Lenz

A Thien Seperator would be worth a shot, it doesn't cost you much but your time. I would question how much of the flour type dust that it would capture though, most Seperators, includeing Cyclones generally catch the larger stuff. I have a Thien baffle in my Seperator and luv it, but I mainly use it for my table saw and thickness planer. The dust collector that I have came with a 1 micron felt bag and I have no plans of replaceing it with a pleated filter anytime soon. When I feel that the bag is geting clogged I remove it and just simply vacuum it out from the inside, you'd be suprised how clean I can get it.

Re: Dust

#10

Re: Dust

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Single stage dust collectors are a lose-lose proposition. They do not pre-separate any dust, so it immediately begins to rapidly clog the filter. As the filter clogs, suction at the source, the MOST IMPORTANT goal of dust collection, declines. It does so quickly! Hobby and other small shop woodworkers are generally the only ones who attempt to filter and return DC air to the shop for re-use. Industry knows better. It locates its separators and bag house filters external to the workshop and vents the cleaned (or partially cleaned) air to the atmosphere.

Single stage dust collectors with standard fabric bag filters are little more than "dust pumps." Many allow too much dangerous, sub-10 micron dust to escape. The common, misguided, practice of "seasoning" a filter with wheat flour, etc. will improve initial filtration but is counterproductive - it reduces flow so the DC captures less dust at the source where the operator is standing and inhaling it!!! Expensive cartridge filters with their larger filter area just delay the inevitable. Frequent use of a "beater bar" is essential with those. Without it, the filter will clog quickly and is harder to clean than a fabric filter. Few woodworkers realize how often that should be done, while fewer still, realize the use of a beater bar or compressed air damages the filter media and reduces its effective life- replacement cartridges can be very expensive!

Even a cyclone is not the complete answer. It just delays the inevitable filter clog a little longer. A DC with cyclone or other separator that removes the majority of dust, but then discharges the air to the atmosphere with no filter is, by far, the best arrangement if you can do it. This may not be possible for small shops that use portable DCs and is probably contrary to OSHA regulations for commercial shops, but it is the best arrangement in fixed installations.

Re: Dust

#11

Re: Agreed Alan

Charlie Lenz

I agree with what you said Alan, and that a good dust mask should be used. I think that too many hobbyists expect a dust collector to do what an air filtration unit does. I have both, a good dust collector and an air filtration unit, but I know that the biggest bennefit to haveing them is a shop that has less dust settleing on everything, nothing more.