Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

Posts

Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#1

Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Here is the latest from the CPSC on tablesaws. You can follow the previous link, but it was short enough so I just copied it below. I'm sure all the magazines and their E-zines will carry this and provide info how we can comment. I added the red bolding and underline- this pretty much says which way the CPSC is leaning unless they get an overwhelming number of comments recommending alternatives. I'm not sure what it will take to dissuade them.

U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission

4330 East West Highway

Bethesda, MD 20814

STATEMENT OF COMMISSIONER ROBERT S. ADLER REGARDING THE ADVANCE NOTICE OF PROPOSED RULEMAKING (ANPR)

FOR TABLE SAWS

October 5, 2011


Today, I joined my fellow Commissioners in unanimously approving the Commission staff’s recommendation to publish an Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPR) for table saws. This is the first step on the road to a possible mandatory performance standard. I did so with a sense that we have reached a critical point with this issue.

Shortly after I joined the Commission in 2009, I saw a demonstration of a braking mechanism for table saws, called SawStop, which would stop a saw blade instantaneously upon encountering someone’s finger or hand. This led me to take a look at the injury data for table saws. The injuries associated with this product are horrific – deep lacerations to the arms and hands, broken bones and, worst of all, amputations to fingers and thumbs. Injuries like these often leave victims facing long, painful recoveries as well as significant financial hardship and employment challenges. I have met a number of these individuals, and, as far as I could tell, every one of them was an experienced woodworker who made a single small misstep or had a momentary lapse in attention – with ghastly consequences. To my mind, small errors like these should not produce tragic results on such a grand scale. In the case of table saws, roughly 36,000 blade contact injuries occur annually, with about 10 percent of them resulting in amputations.(1)

Since 2003, the federal government has known that SawStop’s flesh-sensing technology seems to virtually eliminate the amputations and severe lacerations that result from contact with a blade saw. Over the years, no one has stepped forward to challenge the efficacy of this technology. I realize that serious policy issues remain regarding how best to address table saw injuries, but I think that if someone had evidence that this new technology didn’t work, we would have heard from that person.

(1) I note that a disproportionate number of the injured appear to be Americans 65 and older – a matter of great concern to me. I welcome any comments on specific steps that the agency might take to address safety issues with table saws for this increasingly vulnerable group of consumers.

I am also aware there are other competing technologies to SawStop that have yet to be brought to market. I know, for example, that the Power Tool Institute has developed flesh-sensing technology. Further, I have met with a gentleman named Dave Butler whose company, Whirlwind Tool Company, is seeking to patent a similar technology. I hope efforts on these and other fronts will continue. Although I find myself extremely impressed by the SawStop technology, I am not in favor of writing a standard that would result in mandating a patented technology if such a result is avoidable.

On this point, I note that when CPSC writes product safety standards, we do not mandate a particular technology. We write performance standards and leave it to manufacturers to decide how to meet them. Of course, simply writing a performance standard doesn’t automatically guarantee that other technologies will find their way to the market, but I remain hopeful that they will.

My personal preference is that the table saw industry finds a way to adopt a voluntary standard that would substantially reduce or eliminate these 36,000 annual injuries. Flesh-sensing technology is definitely one solution that they should consider. Whether there are other approaches that are equally effective, I leave to them at the moment.

Our job is to work on behalf of consumers, keeping in mind that the cost of the safety must be reasonable. In making this point, I note that CPSC staff estimates the annual cost of table saw injuries in the billions of dollars. I also note the serious concerns in the industry about new technology adding considerably to the price of this product. This, of course, explains why the Commission wants to publish an ANPR: we need to gather more data on costs and benefits.

Our comment period closes in 60 days. I cannot stress how important it is for all interested parties to weigh in on the ANPR. Comments from the public inform and enlighten us as to whether moving forward with this mandatory rulemaking is necessary and, if so, exactly what direction it should take.

I know the Commission stands ready to work collaboratively with all parties on important safety improvements. Now that we have reached this critical moment it is in the interests of all stakeholders, especially consumers, that the table saw industry, including Mr. Gass and other inventors, and the Commission continue to work together to improve table saw safety.

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#2

Safety at last.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Last I heard, Saw Stops sold well. Testament to free market me thinks. And good for them! But if Big Brother ever decides to make this retro-active they'll have to pry my Unisaw from my cold dead stump fingered hands.

Can't wait until they come out with "Chisel Stops".

Tom

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#3

Re: Safety at last.

iew

Does this mean that since I am over 65 I will have to get a saw stop?????

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#4

A.J. Hamler

Why should they be dissuaded?

A.J. Hamler

Fortunately, this is coming up right as the weather is getting nippy again.

Good thing, as I'm willing to bet that the ensuing discussion on the topic will bring up absolutely nothing new, will repeat (endlessly) everything that has already been said a hundred times and, as usual, will generate far more heat than light.

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#5

I keep think'n . . .

steve mackay

Glad I bought my "last" table saw last year. It'll be illegal next year. Just as I was getting rid of sin-full activity (drink'n, run'n around, write'n bad checks) I'm starting a whole new list.

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#6

Sawstop threads remind me...

John in NM

Of Oscar Wilde....

He would say "Thank God there is no odor"

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Why should they be dissuaded

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

They should be dissuaded because nanny regulations do more to hurt us than help us.

What if I WANT just a cheap saw that will do what I need without expensive, onerous "performance standards". How about we just go down the list of available tools with CPSC "performance standards" and basically run Harbor Freight out of business. What if I want to buy a custom tablesaw from a backyard tinkerer who doesn't have access to the "performance standards", but it does what I want/need it to do?

I'm just not a fan of Big Brother getting involved in every single stinking transaction between two parties. It's getting old real quick.

Jason, one of the other 6 dwarfs.

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#8

Re: Why should they be dissuaded

Joseph Mulherin

Welcome to the "1984" world of George Orwell. The TSA, the EPA, the govt. decisions on our driving needs and equipment....where does it ever end??? and the local cops think we are all criminals if we do not single our turns or drive over the limit by 5mph ...evertywhere you turn you are guilty of something

or they think you are.

Just look at what is going on with that missing baby in Missouri....the cops "think" the mother did it and they are saying the family is not "cooperating" with them.... why cooperaqte when they think you are the ones who did thye event and look no further than their own pre-opinions on the case.

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#9

Just one question...

doug f, san clemente, ca

What happens the first time Saw Stop fails to stop an injury?

Doug

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#10

Don't we wish it was that simple

Neal in San Jose

Have you heard of Social Security Disability? Who do you think pays for it? Who do you think will claim it when he/she becomes disabled due to a table saw accident? Many things aren't simple personal decisions anymore.

Full disclosure: I own a SawStop.

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#11

Re: Just one question...

John McGaw

That, and what happens when somebody runs a slightly-too moist (like finger-moist for example) piece of wood into the blade or if the sensor circuit malfunctions from interior failure or external interference? Who is going to pay for the brake cartridge which must be replaced for a rather high price and the time wasted in waiting for it and a replacement blade which might have been damaged in the crash stop?

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#12

Re: Why should they be dissuaded? *LINK*

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Only if woodworkers want them to be and only if possible.

Need another log? Its a relatively small log, relative to drug companies, etc. and I haven't seen the PTI log yet.


Log

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#13

I'd support a Saw-Stop rule if...

Stuart Hough

Saw Stop had to make the technology available for EVERYONE who had a table saw other than their brand, and made a reto-fit kit for every style table saw made in the last 70 years, and were required to make the kits available for $25.00 each. Then let's see how Saw Stop would like Big Brother mandating how much profit they could make, and how they would like to operate under someone else's rules.

Yes, Saw stop...admit it...all this really was just about the money!

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#14

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

FredD

This from The Power Tool institute in July which seems to indicate a growing trend for safer saws.

"The Power Tool Institute is a trade association comprised of the nation’s largest manufacturers of portable and stationary power tools. Power Tool Institute members have invested hundreds of millions of dollars in an effort to make table saws and other power tools safe when used properly. As a result, injury rates are declining even as saw usage has more than doubled in the last 10 years.

The updated voluntary standard for table saw safety, UL 987, includes new guard designs and other safety features and the results have been positive.

In fact, since 2007, manufacturers have introduced more than 800,000 saws with newly designed guards that meet the requirements of the UL 987 safety standard. To date, there have been no reported blade contact injuries on a table saw with the new guard. These new guarding systems are modular and offer excellent visibility and ease of removal and installation. The guards protect the operator from blade contact as well as injuries caused by thrown objects from kickback."

FredD

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#15

Leo Cuellar

All for change for the better, but

Leo Cuellar

peoples choices should never be mandated away. I've suffered a mild table saw injury, no permanent damage fortunately. It was however, due to negligence on my own part and could have been prevented without the addition of costly technology. It is highly unfair that companies who provide products designed to make our lives easier get sued by unscrupulous people who are out to blame others for their own ignorance. Table saws shouldn't be singled out, what about chainsaws, grinders and for that matter automobiles? The list could go on, why do we settle for mediocrity on so many things that affect our lives to a much greater degree?

Nothing personal to you, Alan. Thanks for letting me rant a little :D

Leo

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#16

Re: Safety at last.

Randy Johnson

I took this picture a couple of years ago.

It’s the interior of the privy near the first Appalachian Trail shelter north of Wayah Bald near Franklin, NC.

The location of the privy makes it pretty much a certainty that nobody who ever uses it will need handicap bars. When I took this picture I did so because I thought they had been installed as a joke.

While talking to some thru-hikers this past June during a hike in central VA I mentioned the privy and how funny I thought the handicap bars were. They informed me that the bars are REQUIRED on all new A.T. privies by the National Park Service.

God help common sense when government bureaucracy and the Peter Principal step in.


Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#17

To be fair . . . *LINK*

Bob Lang

PTI also spends on lobbying, easily found from the same source. The problem with this issue is there aren't any good guys. Both sides have put profits above safety for many years, and when this issue makes the news (NPR, Washington Post, etc) it's a rehash of the spin from someone's mouthpiece. No one even bothers to check the math or the facts.

Public comments will open soon on the proposed rule-making from CPSC, and that will be the only chance we woodworkers will have to weigh in on this. If you want to read about this until your ears bleed, there is a lot of stuff on the Popular Woodworking Editor's Blog, including all the pertinent documents from CPSC.

Bob Lang


PTI Lobbying $

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#18

Because . . .

steve mackay

In the end, as always, we'll find out that SOMEONE is involved with someone else who owns the SawStop. When things like this get forced on the pub;ic, EVENTUALY, we ALWAYS find out it was due to profit and coruption. Next will be a federal operator's license for that chain saw you mentioned. Think I'm kidding ? Cars started out that way didn't they ?

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#19

Re: Safety at last.

Pat Evans

Are they going to put ramps and handrails along the entire length of the AT?

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#20

Re: Because . . .chainsaws

Tom Dunlap

"Next will be a federal operator's license for that chain saw you mentioned."

FWIW---chainsaws have been called the most constructive and destructive tools humans have ever made. A chainsaw injury is never clean or neat, even a minor one.

The saws that I use now are SOOOOO much safer than the ones that I used 35 years ago when I started my career as an arborist. Mechanical chainbrakes that clamp onto the clutch, inertia chainbrakes that stop the chain when it kicks back, chain that is designed to reduce kickback.

Add to that, better training for their use. The day of the one handed chainsaw use is gone. Starting it without having the brake set...gone. Drop starting...gone.

Cut resistant leg protection...always.

In the UK, and oddly, most of the rest of the former Commonwealth as well as in Germany, it is mandated that a chainsaw user go through qualified training in order to use a chainsaw. In order to buy a top handled saw in the UK the purchaser has to go through training. Their use is restricted to pro users only since it is way too easy to use one of them one handed.

It is VERY unlikely that this sort of regulation of chainsaws will happen in the US anytime soon. I sit on the ANSI Z133 committee which sets work standards for arborists. Neither OSHA nor the Z committee are inclined to go that far.

I wonder how chainsaws and tablesaws compare in risk and bodily injury???

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#21

Re: Just one question...

Neal in San Jose

The person that will pay for the new brake cart. and blade is probably the same person that would pay for the emergency room co-pay. If you think replacing the brake cart. is wasting time, how long will it take to regrow a finger? As far as setting the brake off with wet wood, I've never had that problem even with some green, just cut cherry and construction 2 x 4 brought home in the rain. If in doubt, just put the wood in contact with the blade before you turn the saw on, and it will tell you if it's going to trigger the brake. I haven't had to, but I can disable the brake circuit for that one cut if I think the wood would set it off. When I turn the saw off, it defaults back to the brake-engaged mode.

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#22

Re: Just one question...

Howard Acheson

>>>> What happens the first time Saw Stop fails to stop an injury?

Same thing that happens when a seat belt mechanism doesn't work.

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#23

"safety"

Robert R. Clough

Most machinery that I have operated has had some form of safety device which works when used properly. Furthermore most of us have been taught from childhood onward about basic sfety. A spinning flywheel may appear stationary but, . . .

My tablesaw (contr.) has basic safety guides as does my bandsaw. A drum sander is dangerous unless used safely, and so on. Most instruction books stress safety! It is the people who refuse to use safety who mandate the CPSB. I have seen far too many agricultural accidents with disastrous results caused by stupidity as well as reading about home tool accidents, to dismiss (unfortunately) the CPSB. Years ago a friend of mine nearly killed himself in a PTO accident. He always took the guards off PTO connectors - His clothing was caught in the unguarded PTO and would have strangled him except he was able to literally rip his clothing off. He only had a major heart attack instead.

An other farmer, whose name fit him, lost first one arm and then the other in a corm picker - the same year. His name? Louis Stumpf.

All this means is that we need such agencies, unfortunately! Please note that we also have speed laws for much the same reason.

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#24

Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

steve mackay


Re: Latest from the CPSC on Tablesaws

#25

Re: Is it really neccesary ? where will it stop ?

Charlie Lenz

There are alot of dangerous things to do in life, includeing drinking hot coffee. If you want to kill off woodworking as a hobby for the less fortunate, thats a good way to do it.