Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

"Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

Posts

"Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#1

"Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

steve mackay

Starting to look like, in the near future, we'll need to prove the "origins" of our Doug Fir. Then we'll move on to whatever flavor all those woodchips are in your MDF. "The Wood Police, da-da-da-da-da . . . " (Cheap Trick).

Sorry, I gotta stop listening to the "news". :\

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#2

???????????? Ya Lost Me


Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#3

Steve Strickland

Re: They hit Gibson again


Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#4

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

paul in AZ

I ran into this in trying to find a luthier to repair an antique lute that has mother of pearl and various hardwood inlays. If the instrument was shipped and intercepted it would become a documentation nightmare and could lead to a big fine.

As written the law could make you provide the pedigree of a doug fir 2x4. I think the intent was to regulate importation of rare and endangered woods.

Apparently gibson is not as squeaky clean with their exotic wood imports as their press releases would have you believe.

Federal regulations under the Lacey act now control all commercial movements of ANY item with plant or animal derivatives, regardless of CITES listing or not. An international shipment is not possible, the paperwork is impossible to comply with

legally and the risk if challenged on a species identification on the Federal form PPQ 505 which you can't prove is too great.

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#5

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

Ken Oakley Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

Does this mean I could go to jail for selling and shipping pen blanks I cut from locally salvaged wood?

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#6

Unless you have paperwork on the wood, yes.


Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#7

Re: Unless you have paperwork on the wood, yes.

Joseph Mulherin

Do you guys get the feeling that we ARE living in the "1984" world of George Orwell?

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#8

A Shame

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

That the actions of those who would destroy the planet's forests or spread plant diseases with the capacity to obliterate entire species from our ecosystems, all in pursuit of current profits, require such invasive governmental actions to control.

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#9

Re: Unless you have paperwork on the wood, yes.

Ken Oakley Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

I hear prisoners in Federal Prisons get better treatment than old folks in Nursing Homes. I stopped shipping outside the US long ago so maybe I am safe for a while. If not, I'll be sining the Jail House Blues.

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#10

Black Suburbans . . .

steve mackay

Thats the trick . . . you probably won't even KNOW it 'till the Black Suburbans pull up in the driveway with a federal warrant and start rooting through the lumber rack in your garage. They aren't going to listen about you making toys for your grandkids.

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#11

Not just for export/import.

paul in AZ

The Lacey Act also makes it unlawful to import, export, transport, sell, receive, acquire, or purchase in interstate or foreign commerce any plant in violation of the laws of the United States.

Not clearly spelled out the act seems to extend to any foreign country's laws concerning endangered or protected products.

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#12

Re: Not So Fast

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

"Not clearly spelled out the act seems to extend to any foreign country's laws concerning endangered or protected products."

The act pertains only to US [Federal] law. That would include wood and wood products that are covered either by a ratified treaty or international compact, such as the Brazilian rosewood embargo. However, absent such an agreement between the U.S. and the source country, there would be no legal authority for such enforcement unless the statute enacted by Congress contains a specific prohibition and prescribes a penalty.

Congress can say, for instance, "It shall be a violation of this Act to possess, transport, (etc. etm.) Brazilian Rosewood [insert species name(s)]. It can't, however, make it a crime to possess "any wood subject to restriction in Brazil," because while a US citizen can be held to know the law of the US (+ the States), there is no such duty with regard to the laws of every country in the world. Such a provision would, I'm fairly sure, be unconstitutional for being too "vague". Congress could, however, make it a violation to possess wood included on a list maintained and published by the USDA, FDA, or ICE but the act must be specific and the list must be freely available.

I, for example, have a piece that I carved from a billet + a bookmatched pair of 1x12 5' boards of Brazilian Rosewood that I bought from the importer in Landisville, PA way back in 1968 (long before the embargo). Do I have a bill of sale, import documents, provenance, permit, or any other part of that other Hoo Ha stuff? No. Am I worried? No.

;)

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#13

Steve Strickland

Re: But that's what it does say

Steve Strickland

It's illegal in the U.S.A if any country in the world says so. Well, they don't even have to say so. In Gibson's case they have a ruling from the Indian Government that the wood exports are legal so this is just pure harassment by the American government. There is no complaint from India.

Now you have every little pisspot in the world extorting cash off American woodworkers. Our government is gleefully delighted to provide the muscle.

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#14

Exactly ! . . .

steve mackay

The act is worded in a way that any agency can make the Act say just about whatever they want it to say.

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#15

Re: Exactly ! . . .

Stuart Hough

So, if I understand correctly, the aftermarket sales of vintage Bailey-style planes could possibly land me in violation of the Lacey Act, due to the Rosewood totes and knobs, that were harvested over 100 years ago in many cases?

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#16

But, how far . . .

steve mackay

CAN/WILL it go ? Not only "old" knobs & totes but what anout the aftermarket ones on Da' Bay ? For that matter how many of your "antique" or "collectable" tools (marking gages, sliding bevels, file handles, etc, etc) have "questionable" materials. Remember that when this act was signed they told us it was for poachers and such. "Legitimate" and "honest" folks need not worry. NOW it keeps going further and further down the food chain.

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#17

Restrictions *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

If you'd like to know what the restrictions actually are, read, not the Lacey Act, but rather the CITES Convention Appendices that have been agreed upon among the concerned nations. The link is to them and you need to scroll down to the sections, keeping in mind the scientific (latin) name of the wood you're concerned about , then see further the exact restrictions in the foot/end notes listed for each.


CITES

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#18

Steve Strickland

Re: Quote From The Lacey Act

Steve Strickland

(iii) taken, possessed, transported, or sold in violation of any limitation under any law or regulation of any State, or under any foreign law, governing the export or transshipment of plants;

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#19

Re: Not So Fast

iew

See the all new Gibson Guitar made from Southern Yellow Pine.

Re: "Drop the 2x4, punk !" . . .

#20

A greater shame...

John in NM

That said governments have not the wit to implement their desires through incentivizing those they wish to control. The attempt to regulate "undesirable" activities out of existence always fails, but it does keep many involved in the writing and enforcement of such regulations shielded from the unpleasant necessity of making an honest living.