Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Insulation question OT sort of

Posts

Insulation question OT sort of

#1

Insulation question OT sort of

Dustmaker Mike

As some of you know I built a 16 by 20 addition on my garage last year to use as a shop. Over the course of the last year I have pretty much stopped working on it full time on weekends. Well I have started to work on it again and the electrical is almost done and will be inspected in the next few weeks. The next step is insulation. So now comes my question. I know how to do the walls my problem is the floor. When I built the shop I had a 5'5" space under it, so made it into storage for the lawn equipment. This leaves all the floor joist exposed underneath. I know I need a vapor barrier between the floor and the insulation but the flooring is glued and screwed down now, so I can not put plastic down. So can I get a thing of spray foam and just do a 1" layer under the floor or is there a cheaper easier way to do it? Do I need it?

Thanks

Mike

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

#2

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

John Veerkamp

get insulation with vapor barrier and install it with the barrier up. Alternatively , for easy

barrier, spray the underside of the floor with exterior paint.

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

#3

JL

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

JL

What John said. Is the air in your shop conditioned for heat and air? If so, definitely put in insulation.

As an aside, the insulation contractor for our church remodeling did a spray insulation in one of the areas. It seems to be working reasonably well. Some people are sensitive to the chemicals in that type of insulation, so that may be a factor.

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

#4

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

Barry Irby

The Question "Do I need it?" is the key one. It really is like "How high is up?". there are lots of variables like what climate you are in and what you are doing inside the space. Working in a shop generally does not generate the moisture you might have in a house. In the house you have cooking and bathing and watering plant and laundry and....that all generate moisture that must escape or at least equalize with the outdoors. In a shop, not so much. Unless you binging a large quantity of wet wood and let it dry. That could generate a lot of moisture vapor.

Another question or set of questions comes form how wet is the space underneath. I take it you are storing stuff down there so its not too wet. (I hope)

What I would do is buy the insulation that has a vapor barrier on one side and install it with the barrier up against the floor. Or the type that is in the polyethylene sleeve and install it. This would cover the bottom side and make your storage space a little more pleasant. Actually, you probably don't need a vapor barrier in this application. Assuming the space below is relatively dry and not much moisture is generated in the shop and plywood or OSB is a pretty good vapor barrier because of the glue even unfaced batts would be fine.

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

Jesper, Denmark

Barry, you do need a vapor barrier. The shop will be generally warmer than the space below, and the vapor barrier is to stop condensing water vapor FROM THE TOP in the insulation.

It is not a big deal to staple visqueen (SP?) under the floor and along the joists. I did my unheated basement that way. Screwed 1 by's to the sides of the joists at the bottom, which help keep the Rockwool batts in position. You can leave the insulation unfinished below - I hold the insulation batts in plcae with 1 by's across, set into the long pieces, as I will eventually drywall under the joists.

BTW my joists are more or less squared off 8 x 8 logs, making the drywalling a bit of a challenge.

Again: The moisture is not from below, but warm air containing more water vapor than cold air can, migrating down the insulation.

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

#6

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

FredD

The only thing in your situation that needs to be addressed assuming the space beneath your shop is dry all of the time is moisture condensation .

This will occur in the winter when cold air hits the warm underside of the shop floor. Not from the shop interior down as has been stated.

The fix is 6 mil plastic sheeting stapled over the face of the joists.

If you want the benefits of FibreGlas insulation install plain batts with no paper on either side . In jobs like this we bought from the Insulation supplier stiff wire lengths cut for standard joist spacing and sharp on each end, you slide up a Batt and snap two or three of these between the joists ,so they curve up or down and then staple on the plastic.

The plastic vapor barrier prevents the cold moisture laden air from migrating to the underside of the shop floor , so there is no condensation.

This is a job best suited for two people rather then one, especially with the plastic barrier installation.

Your Shop sounds like it will be a dandy when done.

FredD

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

#7

Steve Strickland

Re: Insulation question OT sort of *LINK*

Steve Strickland

Take a look at Foamular. Has vapor barrier on both sides with tongue and groove edges. Very easy to install and featherweight.


img

Foamular at Home Depot

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

#8

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

Barry Irby

This question is MUCH more complex than it appears. It depends on the temperature of the crawl space and the RH there. And the temperature of the shop and the RH there.

Its simpler to figure out in a heating only climate with a constantly dry crawl space. Or an Air Conditioning climate with a Dry Crawl Space. Any combination that was constant on each side would be easy to figure, but that seldom happens. Where I am (Near Richmond, VA) is a very difficult climate to work with. Its cold in the winter and hot in the summer. We often humidify our houses in winter and dehumidify them in summer. Crawl spaces are often wet. An example would be that you really don't want to open your foundation vents in warm humid weather if your goal is to dry your crawl space. It would be better to open them in cold dry weather. The cold air would come in, warm up and no matter how wet it was when it came in, if it warms up it could hold more humidity and carry the extra out with it when it passed through. But then you don't want to open the vents in cold weather because your pipes might freeze. But that's two different issues, drying the crawl space versus protecting from freezing.

Locally the crawl space insulation is generally installed with the vapor barrier up against the (warmer) floor. I find evidence of condensation on the band board around the perimeter often, but never under the floor itself. But I commonly find condensation in copious amounts clinging to the bottom of the fiberglass insulation. In Spring, the crawl space has cooled off over the winter. Warm wet air enters through the vents and condensation forms on the bottom of the fiberglass. (the Fiberglass serves as nucleation centers for the moisture.)

As I said, Very complicated.

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Yabbut......

Jesper, Denmark

You still need to put the vapor barrier on the (predominately) warm side of the insulation, not below in the crawl space.

The transitional situation in spring is of relatively short duration. Humidifying the inside air in winter should not bring the RH much above 50%, or you will get condensation on the windows, but even then, there will be more water in the warm air than in the cold, so the point is to stop this warm air from migrating to the insulation and condense in winter.

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

#10

Re: Yabbut......

Barry Irby

You are right. I have not re-read my posts, but I think the suggestion was to use faced batts with the face up against the plywood, or the battles that are in poly sleeves.

The vapor barrier on the ground is to help keep the storage area dryer.

I find it an interesting observation that the brief period in the spring when the condensation occurs on the bottom of the fiberglass, the condensation is a DEHUMIDIFICATION function. Apparently the moisture condensing on the fiberglass prevents both water and humidity from rising higher. the fibers are basically horizontal and it seems water does not readily wick upward through them. So in severe cases every thing below the fiber glass rots and everything above is OK. There is a transition line that follows the fiberglass. In those spaces I believe the structure would be much better off if they hug the fiberglass about an inch below the joists, but then that would leave and air cavity above it unless it were about ten inches thick. Of course, it would be better still if the crawl space were dry.

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

#11

Re: Yabbut......

Fred Davis

Barry you and Jesper need ro reread Mike's post , the area under his shop that you are treating as a typical crawl space , is actually a storage area 65 inches in height ,so the framing under the floor will be treated as wall framing typically with 6 Mil Visqueen or Tyvek applied on the under side of the joists.

This eliminates any chance of condensation forming against the underside of the flooring.

Whether he insulates between the joist or not isn't relevant to cold outside air condensing against the warm underside of the shop floor.

Laying plastic on the ground which actually is a walking surface wouldn't be near as good to walk on as a nice inch or two of gravel

You especially should know this Barry, given your background in building.

FredD

Re: Insulation question OT sort of

#12

The floor is

Dustmaker Mike

a hand trolled concrete floor about 6 inches thick. It stays dry under there I store all my lawn equipment and some other stuff there. Thanks for the help I get the idea of what needs to be done.