Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

2 questions please

Posts

2 questions please

#1

2 questions please

Terry Alexander

I have an opportunity to purchase about 200 bf of 25/32" cherry for $3.00 bf. Good deal?

Starting on Christmas presents and wanting to do cutting boards this year. My research here says the preferred woods are: cherry, maple, birth. Is that accurate? Oh....and must the cutting boards be made with the end grain up?

As always....TIA

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: 2 questions please

#2

answers

Bill Tindall

I have an opportunity to purchase about 200 bf of 25/32" cherry for $3.00 bf. Good deal? ....... Let me answer by analogy. I have offered you 50 pounds of lamb already cut and wrapped for freezing for $2.50 per pound. Is it a good deal? (I raise sheep so this will be a lamb example, not beef).

If you prefer lamb chops cut at 1 1/4" for grilling and my chops are cut 3/4" it may affect your enthusiasm for what otherwise seems an steal. Oh, by the way this lamb is shanks, stew meat and shoulder steaks. I have already sold the top grade loin and back leg for $5 per pound to someone else.

Bottom line: without knowing the grade, how well it was dried and whether you have any use for thin lumber I can't say if it is a good deal or not.

Any nonporous wood is good for cutting boards. Oh....and must the cutting boards be made with the end grain up?....no Make what ever looks good to you.

Re: 2 questions please

#3

Re: 2 questions please

Barry Irby

I agree with Bill.

One thing you do not make clear is whether the lumber is dressed or not. If it surfaced on two sides and nice and straight and flat, it entirely different than if it is rough and crooked and warped.

25/32 dressed is a lot more attractive than if its rough.

And as Bill mentioned the grade will also affect the value. If this is Wide and long and clear, its much more attractive than if its shorts and narrow and knotty.

And he is right about the cutting boards. Any fine grained wood will work. Cherry makes good ones. End grain might be important to a butcher in a butcher shop where it would get heavy long term use, but not so much in one for the average kitchen.

Re: 2 questions please

#4

Two more answers

doug f, san clemente, ca

Terry - I'm in Southern California and have been paying between $5 and $6.50 per board foot for clear, S2S, 6-8" wide boards. If yours are similar then $3.00 is a steal.

Do you have to make cutting boards without the grain up? No, they work just as well with flat grain, BUT your design options are a bit more limited and besides, end grain boards LOOK cool and they're no harder to make than flat grain boards. There is a great tutorial on the Wood Whisperer site.

Have fun with your projects.

Doug

Re: 2 questions please

#5

Re: 2 questions please

Dave Paine

As other replies mention, whether this is a deal or not is difficult to advise with only knowing the board feet and not knowing grade, whether boards are straight or warped, or will warp.

I prefer hard maple for the "slab" of my boards. I also like to embellish with other species for contrast.

I normally make my boards with face grain. I have made one board which was end grain. Good learning experience.

If you do want to go with end grain, I recommend you check the saw's alignment (vertical and fence for parallel). When I did my board I had not recently checked for vertical and the pieces were slightly off 90deg. Easier to overcome in face grain, but not in end grain.

25/32 thick is thinner than I prefer. I prefer at least an inch. If you go with the thinner stock, consider "bread board" ends to aid in preventing warping with use (water on one side but not the other).


Re: 2 questions please

#6

Re: 2 questions please

Yonak

Terry, if this wood is rougn sawn, don't forget the face measurement is 3/4 the board feet of what it would be if it were 4/4.

Re: 2 questions please

#7

Couple of other answers

Howard Acheson

The advantage to end grain up cutting boards is that the knife or cleaver will not damage them as much. Think of a straw broom. Picture cutting with the grain with a knife. The broom straw is not damaged. However, if you cut across the straw, the straw will be damaged. End grain cutting boards sort of "heal" when the knife is with drawn.

The true thickness of the board is not real important. No matter what the thickness, you can make an edge grain cutting board any thickness. You just rip the board into the width strips you want equal to the thickness you want.

Re: 2 questions please

#8

Moses Yoder

Re: No & No

Moses Yoder

A good deal on cherry would be $1-$2 per board foot or less. Since the going rate is about $4 bd ft for good stuff, $3 bd ft is more like a sale price than a good deal. And wood cutting board can be made in any grain orientation you want to. The end grain up might last a little longer and looks better, but it is not a must.

Re: 2 questions please

#9

An experience and a question

Yonak

A friend of mine got, supposedly, "a good deal" on some cherry at an auction for $2.25/bf and I, unfortunately, had to approve or disapprove on the phone while agreeing to take half of it. The wood was not worth it. It was in fairly poor shape, not much color, and was somewhat on the thin side, some things my friend didn't think of to look for. I now have a bunch of cherry that I make drawers out of .. rather expensive drawers.

Regarding the cutting board : I've never made one with end-grain-up. I wonder if the end grain is more porous than the face grain and, therefore, may soak up more organic juices to decay.

Re: 2 questions please

#10

Re: An experience and a question

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

All "Butcher Blocks" used in groceries and meat markets (and many farms) that I saw when I was young, were made with end grain construction. My father did some custom butchering in the early 1900's and his butcher block/table was still at our home when I was raised. I have seen some worn down 3 or 4 inches in the center, as far as I know no one suffered any ill effects from eating meat from these. I have read reports that wood has a natural sanitizer effect, killing all bacteria on the cutting block in a short time. I don't recall if there were any "stains" in the wood surfaces - I'm sure there would have had to have been some.